1. TGad Editor Report Date: 2011-03-13 Authors: March 2011 April 2007
doc.: IEEE /0570r0
March 2011
TGad Editor Report
Date:
Authors:
Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation
Eldad Perahia, Intel Corporation

2. Draft update and next steps
March 2011
Draft update and next steps
TGad draft D1.2 released on March 01, 2011
D1.2 = D1.1 + speculative implementation of all technical and editorial comments resolved since the January/11 mtg
All comments as part of LB168 have now been resolved and implemented into D1.2
D1.2 has gone has gone through an editorial review by TGad’s editorial panel before its release
Goals for this mtg with respect to the draft
Approve creation of D2.0 on the basis of D1.2
Start a recirculation LB on D2.0
Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

3. March 2011
LB168 update (10/1220r21)
Editorial comments were resolved by Editor and reviewed by the editorial panel
The latest comment database is /1220r21, and contains the resolution to all comments
Technical
Editorial
Totals
Resolved
Open
PHY 42 23 65
MAC
509
406
915 BF 24 34 58
Others 95 96
191
670
559
1229
Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

4. Report for January 2011 January 2011
Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

5. Draft update and schedule
January 2011
Draft update and schedule
TGad draft D1.1 released on January 16, 2011
Speculative implementation of all technical, and some editorial, comments resolved to date (10/1220r12)
Targeting March/11 session to conclude LB168 comment resolution
TGad draft D2.0 will be generated weeks later, which will trigger the start of a recirculation LB
Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

6. January 2011
LB168 update (10/1220r12)
Editorial comments will be resolved by Editor after all technical comments are resolved
Some technical comments will resolve editorials
Contact the Editor if you want to volunteer to resolve Open CIDs
Technical
Editorial
Totals
Resolved
Open
PHY 38 4 6 17 65
MAC
315
194 30
376
915 BF 20 34 58
Others 78 92
191
451
219 40
519
1299
Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

7. Report for November 2010 September 2010
Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

8. TGad draft specification update
November 2010
TGad draft specification update
Draft 1.0 was released on September 24, 2010
Implements the approved comments indicated in the D0.1 comment database (10/717r15)
Following the release of D1.0, a 30-day WG letter ballot (LB168) was initiated on D1.0
LB168 closed on October 24, 2010
Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

9. LB168 update (10/1220r1) LB168 received 1229 comments
November 2010
LB168 update (10/1220r1)
LB168 received 1229 comments
Resolution to CID1162 was presented on Oct 14th conf call ( /1200r1)
Approximately another 160 T/TR CIDs already have proposed resolutions to be presented and are indicated 1220r1
Contact me if you want to volunteer to resolve CIDs TR T ER E
Totals
PHY 28 9 19 65
MAC
278
237
192
208
915 BF 13 10 26 58
Others 80 15 71 25
191
399
271
281
1299
Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

10. Report for September 2010 September 2010
Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

11. TGad draft specification update
September 2010
TGad draft specification update
Draft 0.2 was released on August 05, 2010
Implements editorial comments and technical comments that passed motion at the July/10 TGad mtg (10/777r0)
Draft 0.3 was released on September 02, 2010
Speculative draft that implements comments that received no objection during conference calls held after the July/10 TGad mtg
Draft 0.4 was released on September 10, 2010
Implements corrections identified by the editorial panel
Drafts are publicly available at
Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

12. Comment resolution update (10/717r14)
September 2010
Comment resolution update (10/717r14)
TGad come out of the July/10 mtg with 120 (out of a total of 513) open comments
Since then, 94 comments had resolutions proposed and received no objections (see list in next slide)
As a result, TGad starts the Sept/10 mtg with 26 open comments
MAC: 1 CID (CID91)
MIB: 16 CIDs
Security: 7 CIDs
Beamforming: 2 CIDs (CID98 and CID292)
Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

13. CIDs with proposed resolutions which received no objection
September 2010
CIDs with proposed resolutions which received no objection
Discussed in San Diego, but not motioned:
320, 330, 331 (BF): 10/717r11
Conference calls:
3, 405, 406, 407, 408, 412, 414, 416, 417, 56, 418, 346 (PHY): 10/944r1
447, 448, 449, 316, 58, 59, 317, 318, 319, 461, 438, 386, 413 (PHY): 10/894r1
112, 113, 141, 232, 247, 378 (MAC): 10/947r1
382, 384, 385, 387, 388, 435, 439, 454, 465, 466, 471, 472, 473, 475, 476, 479, 480 (MAC): 10/948r2
323, 422, 445, 326, 328, 332, 333, 375, 433, 13, 100, 288, 289, 290, 291, 314, 340, 312, 374, 381, 427, 434, 452, 453, 464, 481, 482 (MAC/BF): 10/977r5
159, 256, 225 (MAC): 10/983r0
371, 372 (MAC): 10/946r0
321, 477 (MAC): 10/1010r0
84, 88, 89, 90 (MAC): 10/1007r2
175 (MAC): 10/999r0
389 (MAC): 10/1014r0
368 (MAC): 10/995r5
345 (PHY): 10/1029r0
487 (General): 10/1004r0, 10/1002r0, 10/1005r0, 10/1013r0, 10/1012r0, 10/1019r0, 10/1026r0, 10/1031r1, 10/1023r1
348 (PICS): 10/978r1
Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

14. September 2010
Editorial panel
sent to TGad reflector on September 03, 2010, soliciting volunteers for an editorial panel responsible to:
Review drafts for:
Mistakes made by the editor when implementing contributions; and
Editorials
Report those to editor, so that they can be fixed before the TG approves a new draft
Typically, there will be an editorial review for a few days before a new draft is intended to be posted
Volunteers so far: B. Lynch, J. Barr, J. Yee, S. Trainin, S. Grandhi, P. Loc, S. Shankar, T. Derham, L. Chu and I. Toyoda (?)
Contact the editor if you’d like to volunteer
Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

15. July 2010
Report for July 2010
Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

16. TGad draft specification update
July 2010
TGad draft specification update
Draft 0.1 was released on May 28, 2010
Draft is publicly available at
Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

17. July 2010
Comment submission
Following the release of D0.1, a 3 week commenting period was opened on D0.1
A total of 513 comments were received – comment database is document /717
Comments were reviewed during the July 1st conference call and classified into (sub)groups:
236 editorial comments (ER) = handled directly by the Editor
277 technical comments (TR) = resolutions to be proposed by volunteers
2 in the General comment group
24 in the Beamforming comment group
207 in the MAC comment group
41 in the PHY comment group
3 in the Coexistence comment group
Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

18. April 2007
doc.: IEEE /0570r0
July 2010
Comment resolution
Comment resolution will take place starting at the July/10 session
Via submissions
Via proposed resolutions suggested by assignees
Via comment review sessions led by the Editor
As per the TGad timeline, goal is to complete comment resolution at the September/10 session and enter WG letter ballot
Any motions to approve comment resolutions should be done by September/10
Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation
Eldad Perahia, Intel Corporation