1. T2.3 - Mechanisms for implementation, replication and upscaling
WP2
Loriana Paolucci
ISINNOVA

2. Year 2: Focus on Replicability aspects
Objective of T2.3
Task 2.3 will assess mechanisms that support the implementation of strategies and integrative planning for sustainable urban development, and the replicability and upscaling of project results to the city level.
Year 2: Focus on Replicability aspects
Multi-dimensional analysis for the estimation of the Replication Potential of urban solutions in different contexts (EU-China)
Results helpful for :
Identification of the most relevant Implementation gaps
Collection of Policy Recommendations
WP 2

3. Twofold Approach Replication Governance structure? Local Cooperation?
Socio-cultural barriers?
Institutional priorities?
Public/Private sector involvement?
Legal constraints?
...
LOCAL CONTEXT
Replication
Specific characteristic of the solution/technology:
Degree of human interaction?
TRL or SRL?
Interoperability/Standards?
Economic worthiness? …
SOLUTIONS
WP 2

4. B
Multi-dimensional analysis for the estimation of the Replication Potential of urban solutions
Replicability 5D:
Socio-cultural
Institutional
Technological
Environmental
Economic
WP 2

5. Global Replicability Potential
Multi-dimensional analysis for the estimation of the Replication Potential of urban solutions
Global Replicability Potential
Socio-Cultural Replicability
Institutional Replicability
Technological Replicability
Environmental Replicability
Economic Replicability
Solution 1 ?
Solution 2
Solution 3
Solution 4
Solution 5
Solution 6
Global Replicability ?
WP 2

6. B
Multi-dimensional analysis for the estimation of the Replication Potential of urban solutions
Overall Approach
INPUT
X-axis: Variables dependant on the specific characteristics of the SOLUTION (Data collection through Desk Research)
Y-axis: Variables dependant on the specific characteristics of the CONTEXT where the solution would be replicated (Data collection through Questionnaires)
OUTPUT: 
Replicability???
WP 2

7. B
Multi-dimensional analysis for the estimation of the Replication Potential of urban solutions
Overall Approach
INPUT
X-axis: Variables dependant on the specific characteristics of the SOLUTION (Data collection through Desk Research)
Y-axis: Variables dependant on the specific characteristics of the CONTEXT where the solution would be replicated (Data collection through Questionnaires)
R=100 %
R=90
R=80
R=70
R=60
R=50
R=40
OUTPUT:
Z-axis: REPLICABILITY POTENTIAL
Values ∈ [0%-100%]
R=30
R=20
R=10
Replicability
WP 2

8. B
Multi-dimensional analysis for the estimation of the Replication Potential of urban solutions
Socio-cultural
X-axis: “User Interaction Independence” [0-5]
Y-axis “Population Acceptance and Needs” [0-5]: average of
Social Acceptance [0-5]
Population needs [0-5]
WP 2

9. B
Multi-dimensional analysis for the estimation of the Replication Potential of urban solutions
Institutional
X-axis – “Public-Private Cooperation” [0-5]
Y-axis – “Responsiveness to Institutional Priorities” [0-5]
WP 2

10. B
Multi-dimensional analysis for the estimation of the Replication Potential of urban solutions
Technological
X-axis – “Solution Global Readiness”: average of
TRL (or SRL) adjusted [0-5]
Interoperability/Standardization level [0-5]
Y-axis – “Context Global Readiness”: average of
Interest from Research/Industry/Private to invest in this solution [0-5]
Integrability with existing infrastructures [0-5]
WP 2

11. B
Multi-dimensional analysis for the estimation of the Replication Potential of urban solutions
X-axis – “CO2eq saved per inhabitant index”: [0-100%] - adjusted
Zero impact saving 0% – 80 – 100% Green solution
Y-axis – “Legal viability”: Absence of legal/environmental/landscape constrains index”: [0-5] – (then adjusted 0-100%)
Not allowed Viable
Environmental
X-axis – “Internal Return Rate Index”: [0-100%] - adjusted
Y-axis – “NPV/CAPEX Index”: [0-100%]- adjusted
Economic
WP 2

12. Global Replicability Potential
Multi-dimensional analysis for the estimation of the Replication Potential of urban solutions
Global Replicability Potential
Socio-Cultural Replicability
Institutional Replicability
Technological Replicability
Environmental Replicability
Economic Replicability
S1 - Bike Sharing
35%
65%
78%
69%
41%
S2 - CHP+DH
45%
51%
30%
66%
S3 - Efficient Lighting
85%
80%
90%
55%
49%
S4 -E-Mobility Infrastructure
43%
50%
61%
52%
84%
S5 - 3D Platform
70%
64%
38%
S6 - Automated vehicles
20%
25% 0%
0,0%
Global Replicability
58%
47%
72%
68%
15%
WP 2

13. Next Steps Selection of Case Studies (ISINNOVA/AIT) April- May
Development of the questionnaires for collecting inputs (ISINNOVA) April- May
Translation of the questionnaires (CCUD?) May
Desk research for data collection on the case studies (ISINNOVA) April-June
Sending questionnaires and collecting results (ISINNOVA/CCUD) June - July
Application of the method and analysis of results (ISINNOVA) August- September
Replication Workshop in JINGEZHEN (WP2 & WP5 partners) November? …
Test and Replication WS also in Wuhan (and others?) Spring 2020
WP 2

14. Thank you for your attention
WP 2