1. July 2010
Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs)
Submission Title: Proposed resolution of CIDs 190, 194, 195, 868, and 868a
Date Submitted: [12th July, 2010]
Source: Joachim W. Walewski, Tae-Gyu Kang Company: Siemens AG, ETRI
Address: Munich, Germany; 138 Gajeongno, Yuseong-Gu, Daejeon, Korea
Voice: joachim.walewski curly a siemens.com, tgkang curly a etri.re.kr
Re: Response to LB50
Abstract: This document describes LB comment resolution related to regulatory documents.
Purpose: [To resolve LB comments related to regulatory documents]
Notice: This document has been prepared to assist the IEEE P It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s). The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study. The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein.
Release: The contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution becomes the property of IEEE and may be made publicly available by P
Tae-Gyu Kang

2. Proposed resolution of CIDs 190, 194, 195, 868, and 868a
July 2010
Proposed resolution of CIDs 190, 194, 195, 868, and 868a
Joachim W. Walewski, Siemens AG
Tae-Gyu Kang, ETRI
Tae-Gyu Kang

3. July 2010
CID 190 (Subclause 5.7)
Comment: It would be helpful to include local or regional regulations on VLC.
Suggested remedy: None.
Tae-Gyu Kang

4. July 2010
CID 194 (Subclause 5.7)
Comment: Please review the 2009 IEEE Style guide with respect to the use of "safe", "safety" and related words. The best rule is to say nothing. The regulatory bodies have handled this for us and we should say nothing more than that they need to be obeyed.
Suggested remedy: Delete word "safety" in this sentence. Also delete the paragraphs "Flicker can cause ... [B38].", "It is suggested ... and upper cut-off frequencies.", and "This standard does not specify ... [B38]."
Tae-Gyu Kang

5. July 2010
CID 195 (Subclause 5.7)
Comment: Once the "safety" issues have been deleted, there isn't much to remain in this subclause.
Suggested remedy: Delete word "safety" in this sentence. Also delete the paragraphs "Flicker can cause ... [B38].", "It is suggested ... and upper cut-off frequencies.", and "This standard does not specify ... [B38]."
Tae-Gyu Kang

6. CID 868 (Annex I) Comment: (SY) This annex is empty
July 2010
CID 868 (Annex I)
Comment: (SY) This annex is empty
Suggested remedy: Fill the annex or delete the annex.
Tae-Gyu Kang

7. CID 868a (Annex I) Comment: Annex I is currently blank
July 2010
CID 868a (Annex I)
Comment: Annex I is currently blank
Suggested remedy: In the document we have Annex B.2 which is called "Regulatory documents" and we have Annex I which is called 'VLC Regulatory Annex". We don't need both. Suggest we delete Annex I and keep Annex B.2.
Tae-Gyu Kang

8. Resolution strategy Current text: Subclause 5.7
July 2010
Resolution strategy
Current text:
Subclause 5.7
Annex B.2 (regulatory docs)
Annex I (regulations)
Proposed text:
Subclause 5.7 (see doc 10/530)
Annex B.1: introduce reference toward doc 10/543, latest rev.
Annex B.2 (regulatory docs): replace with doc 10/543, latest rev.
Annex I (regulations)
Tae-Gyu Kang

9. July 2010
CID 190 (Subclause 5.7)
Comment: It would be helpful to include local or regional regulations on VLC.
Suggested remedy: None.
Proposed remedy: Accept in spirit. Many local regulations on, e.g., radiation safety, are directly derived from international regulatory documents. We prefer thus to list international regulatory documents instead of derived regulations. However, a contribution providing a discussion of pertinent national and regional regulations will be referenced in Annex B.1 (doc 10/543, latest revision).
Tae-Gyu Kang

10. July 2010
CID 194 (Subclause 5.7)
Comment: Please review the 2009 IEEE Style guide with respect to the use of "safe", "safety" and related words. The best rule is to say nothing. The regulatory bodies have handled this for us and we should say nothing more than that they need to be obeyed.
Suggested remedy: Delete word "safety" in this sentence. Also delete the paragraphs "Flicker can cause ... [B38].", "It is suggested ... and upper cut-off frequencies.", and "This standard does not specify ... [B38]."
Proposed remedy: Accept in principle. Clause 5.7 will be deleted.
Tae-Gyu Kang

11. July 2010
CID 195 (Subclause 5.7)
Comment: Once the "safety" issues have been deleted, there isn't much to remain in this subclause.
Suggested remedy: Delete word "safety" in this sentence. Also delete the paragraphs "Flicker can cause ... [B38].", "It is suggested ... and upper cut-off frequencies.", and "This standard does not specify ... [B38]."
Proposed remedy: Accept in principle. Clause 5.7 will be deleted.
Tae-Gyu Kang

12. CID 868 (Annex I) Comment: (SY) This annex is empty
July 2010
CID 868 (Annex I)
Comment: (SY) This annex is empty
Suggested remedy: Fill the annex or delete the annex.
Proposed remedy: Accept in principle. Delete this entry. Regulatory documents are listed in Annex B.2. A contribution providing a discussion of pertinent regional and national regulations will be introduced to Annex B.1 (doc 10/543, latest revision).
Tae-Gyu Kang

13. CID 868a (Annex I) Comment: Annex I is currently blank
July 2010
CID 868a (Annex I)
Comment: Annex I is currently blank
Suggested remedy: In the document we have Annex B.2 which is called "Regulatory documents" and we have Annex I which is called 'VLC Regulatory Annex". We don't need both. Suggest we delete Annex I and keep Annex B.2.
Proposed remedy: Accept in principle. Delete this entry. Regulatory documents are listed in Annex B.2. A contribution providing a discussion of pertinent regional and national regulation will be referenced in Annex B.1 (doc 10/543, latest revision)
Tae-Gyu Kang