1. Charles D. Raab University of Edinburgh c.d.raab@ed.ac.uk
REGULATING AMBIENT INTELLIGENCE: THE ROAD TO PRIVACY IMPACT ASSESSMENT?
Charles D. Raab
University of Edinburgh

2. ISTAG AND SWAMI ISTAG Scenarios: deficiencies
Emphasis on society and business; omits the public sector and the state
Emphasis on ‘security’: misleading
SWAMI scenarios: more searching, but…
SWAMI safeguards: depth, but a catalogue

3. TOWARDS A MORE HOLISTIC APPROACH
Not just a ‘toolkit’: tools not ‘stand alone’
Interactions and dependencies
Roles, relationships ad responsibilities
Strapline: ‘Safeguards: Who Should Do What, when, and How?’

4. PRIVACY IMPACT ASSESSMENT FOR AmI?
Potentially useful process
Emphasis on risk, but difficulties
Precautionary principle?
Implicit in SWAMI’s analyses of ‘threats and vulnerabilities’ in myriad contexts

5. QUESTIONS FOR DISCUSSION
In regulating AmI, who should do what, when, and how?
2. What are the prospects of building privacy and other impact assessment into the development of AmI?