1. Rate the research papers

2. This paper asks you to
Construct an inductive argument (question at beginning, thesis/answer/solution at the end)
Pitch it to a specific audience
Take into account that audience’s FBIs and F&P concepts as you organize, develop, & present the paper
Find sources that audience will respect
Show your thinking—go thru alternatives, use SEE-IT
Execute with accuracy and precision
Pass a CAIR standards check on your own pitch

3. Remember you have already
Analyzed your own FBIs and F&P concepts—reflection/conclusions at the end (somewhat inductive)
Analyzed how Fallows made his case to a specific audience in a deductive argument (thesis at the beginning)
Analyzed how a cultural events presenter made a pitch specifically to you
Used your F&P concepts and P.O.V. to look at a section of Wilson
Evaluated how well others looked at Wilson…

4. Pitch defined purpose and clearly stated question/problem at issue and clearly connected it to a green agenda (5)
Dick Van Dyke
Bill Murray
Emily Dickinson
LeBron James
Omarosa
Phil Mickelson

5. Pitch tailored information to a specific and identifiable audience, including allowing for its FBIs and its F&P concepts (8)
Dick Van Dyke
Bill Murray
Emily Dickinson
LeBron James
Omarosa
Phil Mickelson

6. Using an inductive strategy, writer established context, exposed barriers, established P.O.V. (5)
Dick Van Dyke
Bill Murray
Emily Dickinson
LeBron James
Omarosa
Phil Mickelson

7. Heavy preponderance of sources from appropriate peer-reviewed or disciplinary accepted sources (Nosich ch. 3) gave pitch credibility (5)
Dick Van Dyke
Bill Murray
Emily Dickinson
LeBron James
Omarosa
Phil Mickelson

8. Writer provided adequate, credible information and analyzed its importance (use of SEE-IT) (10)
Dick Van Dyke
Bill Murray
Emily Dickinson
LeBron James
Omarosa
Phil Mickelson

9. Organization was clear, psychologically appropriate and logical (7)
Dick Van Dyke
Bill Murray
Emily Dickinson
LeBron James
Omarosa
Phil Mickelson

10. Writer showed work & weighed alternatives, options, outcomes, solutions appropriately and thoroughly, meeting the standards of depth, breadth, and sufficiency (10)
Dick Van Dyke
Bill Murray
Emily Dickinson
LeBron James
Omarosa
Phil Mickelson

11. Using an inductive strategy, writer made a clear and convincing recommendation to solve the problem and showed the implications of doing so, meeting the CAIR standards (5)
Dick Van Dyke
Bill Murray
Emily Dickinson
LeBron James
Omarosa
Phil Mickelson