1. PRESENTATION, ORGANISATION AND PROCEDURAL ASPECTS OF THE EUIPO’S BOARDS OF APPEAL
Gordon HUMPHREYS
Chairperson of the 5th Board of Appeal
18/05/2017 and 19/05/2017

2. Composition and functioning

3. Chairperson
4 Members
7 Legal assistants
Chairperson
3 Members
5 Legal assistants
Chairperson
8 Members
Chairperson
4 Members
6 Legal assistants
Chairperson
4 Members
8 Legal assistants
President
3 Chairpersons
+ 5 Members

4. THE BOARDS OF APPEAL - COMPOSITION
1 President of the Boards (who acts as well as Chairperson)
3 Chairpersons
15 Members + Legal Assistants
Organization in 4 trade mark Boards + 1 design Board
Decisions are normally taken by a panel of 3 (1 rapporteur, 1 ordinary member + Chairperson).
Registry + KISS (including proof-readers)

5. SOME KEY FIGURES 2015 2016 2017 EUTMA Direct 108 515 135 259 121,529
International
8 053
18 785
24,880
APPEALS
Filed
2 611
2 446
2 948
Decisions taken
2 911
2 884
2 718
JUDGMENTS OF THE GC
296
332 -
APPEAL RATE OF BOA DECISIONS IN
9.7%
9.6%
10.9%
BOA DECISIONS CONFIRMED BY GC
82.2%
85.7%
86.0 %
Ex-parte
93.2%
95.7%
92.5 %
Inter-partes
77.2%
81.4%
83.8%

6. APPEALS FILED BY LANGUAGE – 1997- 2017

7. FUNCTIONING OF THE BOARDS
The Boards are part of the Office.
There exists “a continuity in terms of their functions between the Board of Appeal and the examiner”.
What are the Boards?
They are not a Court.
However, they work like a Court!
IMPORTANT!
Members are independent (Art. 166 (7) EUTMR).
Members are not bound by any instructions, but only by the law (Art. 166 (7) EUTMR).

8. PRESIDIUM – ART. 167 (1) EUTMR
Composition (Art. 167 (1) EUTMR)
President 1
Chairpersons 3
Members (elected) 6 (including 2 alternates)
Total 10

9. PRESIDIUM – ART. 167 (1) EUTMR; Art 46 EUTMDR
Responsible for:
Decision on abstract criteria for allocation of cases.
Internal rules of organizational nature.
Practical instructions for the parties.
Reallocation of cases if annulment by General Court.
Instructions to the Registry – Presidium Decision of 10 December 2009.

10. COMPOSITION OF GRAND BOARD – Art. 167 (2); Art. 45 EUTMDR
Art. 7 (List of Members) and Art. 8 (Rotation criteria) Rules concerning the Organization of the Boards, Decision
President 1
Chairpersons 3
Members (rotating) 5
Total 9

11. REFERRAL TO THE GRAND BOARD – Art. 37 EUTMDR
Reasons for referral to the Grand Board
Legal difficulties.
Importance of the case.
Diverging case law.
By the competent Board, or
By the Presidium on proposal:
of the President of the BoA,
of a member of the Presidium.
By the Executive Director on points of law, particularly where the BoAs have diverging relevant case law.
Not by the parties or another Board.
The view of the ED on legal interpretations may be sought.
Interested commercial and consumer groups can submit observations on cases submitted.

12. REGISTRY
Responsible for receipt, dispatch, safekeeping and notification of documents in the BoA proceedings.
Compilation of appeal files for rapporteurs.
Monitoring deadlines and other formal appeal requirements (e.g. submission of the notice and of statement of grounds).
Allocation of files among Boards in accordance with Presidium criteria.

13. KNOWLEDGE, INFORMATION & SUPPORT SERVICE (KISS)
The Knowledge, Information and Support Service set up by the President’s decision ADM of 2 October 2014.
Its tasks include:
Quality, Performance and Risk Management;
Proof-reading;
KC Appeal Processes;
Administrative Support;
Information Technology (IT);
Publications concerning the activities of the Boards of Appeal;
Legal advice to Registry;
Events & visits.

14. The Appeal procedure

15. COMPOSITION OF THE BOARDS
Decisions taken by 3 members:
The general case (Art. 39 EUTMDR)
Decisions taken by single member (Art. 36 EUTMDR):
Lack of difficulty in legal or factual subject-matter, absence of special circumstances;
Board decides if case is referred to single member.
Grand Board Decisions (Art. 157(2) EUTMR)

16. DECISIONS SUBJECT TO AN APPEAL
Trade Mark Matters (Art. 66 and 159 EUTMR):
Final decisions of:
the Examiners: Filing date (incl. priorities); formalities; AG for refusal;
the Opposition Division: Admissibility and allowability of an opposition;
the Cancellation Division: Application for revocation; application for a declaration of invalidity;
the Department in charge of the Register (including recordals in the EU Trade Mark Register and list of professional representatives).
Design Matters:
the Invalidity Division: Admissibility and allowability of invalidation proceedings;
the Administration of Designs and Legal Division: Recordals in the EU Trade Mark Register and list of professional representatives.

17. Any party to proceedings adversely affected by a decision:
WHO IS ENTITLED TO APPEAL?
Any party to proceedings adversely affected by a decision:
Art. 67 EUTMR.
Who is adversely affected?:
Party not prevailing with its claims (but not including):
Alternative grounds that are not examined;
Unexamined matters affecting conversion rights.

18. FORM OF APPEAL & TIME LIMIT (Art. 68 EUTMR)
Appeal must be written.
Notice of Appeal (NoA) within two months after notification of contested decision.
Shall be deemed to have been filed only when the fee for an appeal has been paid within the above mentioned period.
Statement of Grounds (SoG) within four months after notification of contested decision.
Cross Appeal (Art. 68 (2) EUTMR)
The other party to inter partes proceedings may seek in its submissions in defense a decision annulling or altering the contested decision on a point not raised in the appeal.

19. EXCHANGES BETWEEN PARTIES
Appellant:
Appeal (€800/€720)
Statements of grounds
(Revision)
Reply
Defendant:
Observations
Rejoinder

20. BOA DECISION
Art. 71 EUTMR
Decision on the appeal:
Decision on the admissibility and the substance of the appeal;
Option to continue proceedings exercising any power within the competence of the department which was responsible for the decision appealed;
If appropriate, remit the case to that department, which is bound by the decision’s ratio decidendi for further prosecution.
Decision on costs.

21. ORAL PROCEEDINGS (Art. 96 EUTMR); Art. 49-55 EUTMDR
Only 2 in 14 years.
Boards are not against them, but difficult to find files that are appropriate for oral proceedings.
Most files are sufficiently complete to enable decision.
Could be useful to explore evidential issues (e.g. internet evidence of generic nature of a sign).
2 convoked by 4th Board but both times parties settled.

22. MEDIATION (Art. 47(4), 64(4), 151(3) and 170 EUTMR)
Available for admissible appeals at BoA level in inter partes TM and Design cases .
Free of charge in Alicante; EUR 750 admin fee in Brussels.
Initiated by:
Joint request from parties;
Unilateral request forwarded by the Boards to the other party for acceptance;
Invitation from the rapporteur to the parties to consider mediation.
Appeal proceedings are suspended pending the mediation outcome.
Possibility of co-mediators.
Significant time and cost savings.
Possible outcomes:
Settlement agreement (transfer, withdrawal or limitation; co-existence ; joint venture);
No agreement and ressumption of appeal proceedings.
Confidentiality guaranteed.

23. PROCEDURE IN A NUTSHELL