1. 2008 Stage 3 centralised review– lead reviewer perspective
Justin Goodwin

2. LR Perspective Preparation Communications The Team The Week
Work needed in weeks prior to review
Communications
Questions management
The Team
Previous experience
Language
Generalist
The Week
Well supported by EEA (FTP site etc)
The Parties
Responsiveness
The Data
Recalculations Comparisons & IEFs important (Activity Data)
The Foundation
Improved Guidebook will improve ability to recommend
Cross cutting chapters important
Transparency is important
Language issues

3. Stage 3 Review Process Organise... Assess... TCCCA
LRs teams and outputs
ERT Sector/Country
Assess... TCCCA
Big sectors (Pollutants, Timeseries)
Recalc., NEs & New?
Follow up previous reviews.
Engage.. As early as possible
Questions. identify problem.
Ask more questions
Produce..
Transcript (Complete Record)
Report: (Priority findings & Recommendations)

4. Recommendations for Improvement
Data:
Sector specific recalculations
CLRTAP and NECD sector specific differences
All Emissions data & Activity & IEFs
UNFCCC CRF activity data
IIRs:
IIRs should be structured the same
Non English IIRs to have English summaries
Stage 2 support:
Ask parties to review and comment on KCA done by secretariat
Process:
Questions need to be managed better by LRs.
Generalise + LR needed to help this run smoothly...
IT:
Shared Server for working file.
Templates better linked (Transcript and Review Report).

5. Thank you
And...
New Review Report
New Transcript