1. July 2004
Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs)
Submission Title: [Merger Proposal #2 Affirmation of Commitment to the MAC]
Date Submitted: [July 12, 2004]
Source: [Matthew Welborn] Company [Freescale Semiconductor]
Address [8133 Leesburg Pike, Vienna, VA 22180]
Voice:[ ]
Re: [Response to TG3a Chair request for affirmation of commitment.]
Abstract: [The authors of the Merger #2 Proposal (DS-UWB) affirm their commitment to working in good faith with the TG3a to develop an Alternate PHY layer Standard that meets all of the requirements for the authorized work project. These include meeting the technical and application requirements identified by the TG 3a members, as well as the requirements entailed by the IEEE Standards Association]
Purpose: [To help the TG3a members understand the intentions of the Merger #2 Proposal team and ensure a clear understanding of the technical and legal requirements for the TG3a Alternate PHY project.]
Notice: This document has been prepared to assist the IEEE P It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s). The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study. The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein.
Release: The contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution becomes the property of IEEE and may be made publicly available by P
Welborn , Freescale Semi

2. Requirements for TG3a PHY Regarding the 15.3 MAC
<month year>
doc.: IEEE <doc#>
July 2004
Requirements for TG3a PHY Regarding the 15.3 MAC
Extracts from the various documents governing the TG3a Alt-PHY project and direct responses from the Merger #2 Proposal team affirming commitment to the requirements contained therein
List of requirement sources
15.3a Project Authorization Request (PAR)
5 Criteria Document
15.3a Requirements Document
15.3a Selection Criteria
Standard (PICS)
Welborn , Freescale Semi
<author>, <company>

3. Requirements from the 15.3a PAR
July 2004
Requirements from the 15.3a PAR
13. Scope of Proposed Project:
This project will define an alternative PHY clause, in the frequency range of up to 24GHz, for a higher data rate amendment to standard
14. Purpose of Proposed Project:
The intent of this project is to provide a standard for a low complexity, low cost, low power consumption alternate PHY for (comparable to the goals for ). The data rate will be high enough, 110 Mb/s or more (see 18a), to satisfy an evolutionary set of consumer multi-media industry needs for WPAN communications. The project will address the requirements to support multimedia data types in multiple compliant co-located systems and also coexistence (18b).
Welborn , Freescale Semi

4. Merger Proposal #2 Response
July 2004
Merger Proposal #2 Response
The Authors of the Merger #2 Proposal (DS-UWB) affirm their commitment to creating an alternative PHY for the Standard
Specifically, we are committed to work to create a low complexity, low cost, low power alternate PHY for 15.3 to satisfy the requirements for WPAN multi-media communications applications
Welborn , Freescale Semi

5. Requirements from the TG3a 5 Criteria Document
July 2004
Requirements from the TG3a 5 Criteria Document
2.0 COMPATIBILITY
IEEE 802 defines a family of standards. All standards shall be in conformance with IEEE Architecture, Management and Inter-working. All LLC and MAC standards shall be compatible with ISO 10039, MAC Service Definition, at the LLC/MAC boundary. Within the LLC Working Group there shall be one LLC standard, including one or more LLC protocols with a common LLC/MAC interface. Within a MAC Working Group there shall be one MAC standard and one or more Physical Layer standards with a common MAC/Physical layer interface. Each standard in the IEEE 802 family of standards shall include a definition of managed objects, which are compatible with OSI systems management standards.
Note: This requirement is subject to final resolution of corrections and revision to current ISO 10039, currently inconsistent with ISO 8802 series standards.
The MAC (Medium Access Control) Layer of the Alternate PHY Standard will be compatible with the IEEE 802 requirements for architecture, management, and inter-networking and will be based upon the IEEE MAC.
Welborn , Freescale Semi

6. Merger Proposal #2 Response
July 2004
Merger Proposal #2 Response
The Authors of the Merger #2 Proposal (DS-UWB) affirm their commitment to creating an Alternate PHY standard that will meet the IEEE 802 requirements for architecture, management and internetworking and which will be based on the MAC
Welborn , Freescale Semi

7. Requirements from the TG3a Requirements Document
July 2004
Requirements from the TG3a Requirements Document
9.0 Supplements to functionality
It is envisioned that the alt-PHY project will allow supplements to In addition to the PHY itself, the project may include MAC functionality necessary to support the selected PHY.
It is required that the alt-PHY operate with the MAC without fundamental change in operation. It is also required that any enhancements or modifications are enabled by reference to alt-PHY specific PIB parameters.
As an example, from the project request, document 01/532r0 (alt-PHY study group proposal), location awareness is considered as a possible feature of certain alt-PHY technologies and is an example of supplemental MAC functionality. Such a provision may be supported by the PHY PIB parameters in the proposed standard MAC or via supplemental MAC capabilities provided by the alt-PHY project.
Welborn , Freescale Semi

8. Merger Proposal #2 Response
July 2004
Merger Proposal #2 Response
The Authors of the Merger #2 Proposal (DS-UWB) affirm their commitment to creating an alt-PHY that operates with the MAC without fundamental change in its operation.
We are committed to creating and alt-PHY that requires nothing beyond supplemental MAC functionality based on specific alt-PHY technology
Welborn , Freescale Semi

9. Requirements from the TG3a Selection Criteria
July 2004
Requirements from the TG3a Selection Criteria
4. MAC Protocol Supplements
4.1    Alternate PHY Required MAC Enhancements and Modifications
Definition
Supplements and modifications to the MAC may be required to accommodate the alternate PHY. It is preferred that the supplements be additions which expand the solution capability as opposed to changes in the MAC that represent an alternative way to do a particular function.
Welborn , Freescale Semi

10. Merger Proposal #2 Response
July 2004
Merger Proposal #2 Response
The Authors of the Merger #2 Proposal (DS-UWB) affirm their commitment to creating an alt-PHY that operates with the MAC without fundamental change in its operation
In particular, We are committed to creating and alt-PHY that supplements MAC functionality only, and does not contain any changes in the MAC that represent an alternative way to do a particular function
Welborn , Freescale Semi

11. Merger Proposal #2 Support for Simultaneous Operating Piconets
July 2004
Merger Proposal #2 Support for Simultaneous Operating Piconets
The Authors of the Merger #2 Proposal (DS-UWB) affirm their commitment to creating an alt-PHY that operates with the MAC that provides the simultaneous operating piconet (SOP) capabilities as required by the 15.3a Requirements document and Selection Criteria
In particular, we are committed to creating and alt-PHY that support SOP operation with a minimum of four supported SOP (optional support for up to a total of 12 piconets at this time)
This support includes the required functionality to support all security features provided by the a MAC
Welborn , Freescale Semi

12. July 2004
The 15.3a PICS
The Protocol implementation conformance statement (PICS) define which MAC sub-layer functions & frames are required for compliant 15.3/15.3a devices
These PICS specify MAC functions such as
Device association and dissociation
Medium access techniques
Beacon generation & support
Etc.
There functions are fundamental to the MAC operation as defined in the 15.3 standard and must be supported by any Alt-PHY standard developed for use with the 15.3 MAC
Welborn , Freescale Semi

13. Merger Proposal #2 Response
July 2004
Merger Proposal #2 Response
The Authors of the Merger #2 Proposal (DS-UWB) affirm their commitment to creating an Alternate PHY standard that will provide the functionality required to implement a compliant 15.3a device based on the 15.3 MAC, as defined in the PICS specification
Welborn , Freescale Semi

14. Supporting Details Documents submitted Presentations this week
July 2004
Supporting Details
Documents submitted
04/140 Merger #2 proposal– most recent version
04/137 Supporting details– most recent version
Presentations this week
Technical contribution Tuesday, July 13 (1:30-3:30 pm)
Proposal update presentation Tuesday, July 13 (4-6 pm)
Welborn , Freescale Semi