Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

PICs….. In spaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaace!.  Cp text  Net benefit  Must be competitive ◦ Uniquely beneficial ◦ Mutually exclusive.

Similar presentations


Presentation on theme: "PICs….. In spaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaace!.  Cp text  Net benefit  Must be competitive ◦ Uniquely beneficial ◦ Mutually exclusive."— Presentation transcript:

1 PICs….. In spaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaace!

2  Cp text  Net benefit  Must be competitive ◦ Uniquely beneficial ◦ Mutually exclusive

3  Write before the round  Grammar  does it accomplish what I need the CP to accomplish?  How could the aff permute the cp text?  How could the aff create a solvency deficit?

4  Internal net benefit  Independent disad  Case turns the cp avoids

5  The CP by itself must be better than the plan or any combination of the plan and all or part of the CP  Uniquely beneficial -CP must do something good or avoid something bad that the plan can’t.  Mutually exclusive -the aff and the cp can not happen at the same time

6  Tests competition of the CP  must have plan first, unaltered in content and timeframe  Many variations on permutations  Even if the perm works, the cp can still function if it is uniquely beneficial (perm still links to politics)

7  Conditionality  Dispositionality  unconditionality

8  Can kick the cp whenever you want  Still have to answer theory  Aff can still try to leverage offense  Very common  Strategic flexibility  Conditionality is okay, multiple contradictory conditional worlds is problematic

9  Can kick the cp unless it is straight turned  Only impact turns, link turns, or theory  Conceding permutations, link or impact defense will make the CP go away  Not much strategic value  Difficult to run with other worlds

10  Will go for in the 2NR  Can’t kick under any circumstances  Good to run 1 off  Everything in 1NR should work together

11  PIC  Consult  Condition  Advantage  Agent  This list is not exhaustive

12  Plan Inclusive Counterplan  Does part of the plan  Removes part of the action or replaces a word  Word PICs  Generally accepted as legitimate

13  Conditions plan action on an additional prior act  “USFG will do X if PRC will do Y”  Theoretically questionable  Strategically sound since it should suck up the affs offense

14  Does an alternative action that seeks to solve one of the advantages of the plan  Puts offense on advantages not solved by the cp  Valuable for affs with 2 or 3 advantages

15  Is also a PIC  Does the plan through an alternative agent (XO, Courts)  Plan action is a good idea, just need to use different actor  Politics is a common NB  agent powers or legitimacy can also be NB

16  Consults another actor on the plan action  Often has relations NB  Theoretically shady, lots of judges hate it  Strategically strong since it literally does all of the aff

17  Permutation  Solvency deficit  Add-ons  Theory  Disads to the cp  Turning the NB


Download ppt "PICs….. In spaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaace!.  Cp text  Net benefit  Must be competitive ◦ Uniquely beneficial ◦ Mutually exclusive."

Similar presentations


Ads by Google