1. ® DODAF CADM/AP233 Interoperability Project David Price OSJTF March 2006

2. ® Our Focus is on SE Standards Enable communication between SAs/SEs and the tools they use –Approach described in white paper : Using Systems Engineering Standards In an Architecture Framework –Influenced by DoD, INCOSE, ISO STEP and OMG communities System-of-systems engineering requires Greater collaboration and tool interoperability, and … Using robust modeling techniques for describing systems architectures Request Response System Model

3. ® MoDAF or UPDM Architecture Repository Request Response System Model DoD Architecture Repository System DOD CADM Operational Systems Technical DODAF Any SE Tool specifies requirements for ISO STEP-enabled Downstream Tool

4. ® ISO TC184/SC4 Industrial Data

5. ® AP233 Systems Engineering On-schedule for AP233 modules to go out for ISO ballot starting in the summer –Committee Draft ballot (July-October 2006) –After ballot completes, workshops are held to address ballot comments –AP233 modules should be published 1Q2007 The complete AP233 Application Protocol that includes Business Use Cases, etc. takes a bit longer Critical Testing Happens Here ISO Ballot

6. ® AP233 Scope requirements text-based property-based breakdowns static structure PDM link to analysis behaviour product structure system sub-system functional breakdown WBS verification & validation function-based model presentation config control security risk measurement person & org Complete Edition 2 Legend state-based rules (moved to AP210)

7. ® AP233 Testing AP233 Development Team is working strategy for critical testing –Includes internal team testing –Includes approaching vendors to participate AP233 Team developing a “test harness” –Fitting into the “test harness” is now the main focus for the DODAF CADM/AP233 demo work –Dwayne made significant contribution to the architecture of this –The bad news though: Previous “cool CADM/AP233 demos” are broken into bits at the moment

8. ® AP233 Test harness Repository Test data creation tools Visio Freemind Excel UML 2/SysML CADM examples … XML AP233 XML Translate via: Import/Export Web Viewers, Graphical Viewers and Available SE Tools XSLT Ruby Java

9. ® DoDAF CADM/AP233 Project

10. ® Purpose –Evaluate feasibility of system architecture data exchange using emerging ISO AP233 Systems Engineering standard Not a fully validated design effort –Provide a body of work that future efforts can build upon

11. ® Proving this path

12. ® CADM/AP233 Process Steps Id CADM vs. AP233 Gaps Complete AP233 Modules for Gaps Produce AP233 Draft Define CADM/AP233 Mappings Create AP233 Test Cases Develop CADM/AP233 Translator Demonstrate CADM/AP233 Translator TOOLS

13. ® Operational Systems Technical Operational Concept Description (OV-1) Node Connectivity Description (OV-2) X Y X Z X Y Y Systems Interface Description (SV-1) Operational Activity Model (OV-5) Information Exchange Matrix (OV-3) Activity to System Function (SV-5) System Functionality Description (SV-4) Organizational Relationships Chart (OV-4) Systems Data Exchange Matrix (SV-6) Operational Activity Sequence and Timing Description (OV-6 a/b/c) Systems Communications Description (SV-2) System - System Matrix (SV-3) Systems Technology Forecast (SV-9) Standards Technology Forecast (TV-2) Technical Architecture Profile (TV-1) Systems Performance Parameters Matrix (SV-7) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -..... Logical Data Model (OV-7) Systems Functionality Sequence and Timing Description (SV-10 a/b/c) Systems Evolution Description (SV-8) Physical Schema SV-11 ABC T1 T2 T3 NODES TIME ABC T1 T2 T3 NODES TIME DoDAF Views Coverage

14. ® Operational Systems Technical Operational Concept Description (OV-1) Node Connectivity Description (OV-2) X Y X Z X Y Y Systems Interface Description (SV-1) Operational Activity Model (OV-5) Information Exchange Matrix (OV-3) Activity to System Function (SV-5) System Functionality Description (SV-4) Organizational Relationships Chart (OV-4) Systems Data Exchange Matrix (SV-6) Operational Activity Sequence and Timing Description (OV-6 a/b/c) Systems Communications Description (SV-2) System - System Matrix (SV-3) Systems Technology Forecast (SV-9) Standards Technology Forecast (TV-2) Technical Architecture Profile (TV-1) Systems Performance Parameters Matrix (SV-7) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -..... Logical Data Model (OV-7) Systems Functionality Sequence and Timing Description (SV-10 a/b/c) Systems Evolution Description (SV-8) Physical Schema SV-11 ABC T1 T2 T3 NODES TIME ABC T1 T2 T3 NODES TIME DoDAF Views Coverage Delivered now

15. ® Operational Systems Technical Operational Concept Description (OV-1) Node Connectivity Description (OV-2) X Y X Z X Y Y Systems Interface Description (SV-1) Operational Activity Model (OV-5) Information Exchange Matrix (OV-3) Activity to System Function (SV-5) System Functionality Description (SV-4) Organizational Relationships Chart (OV-4) Systems Data Exchange Matrix (SV-6) Operational Activity Sequence and Timing Description (OV-6 a/b/c) Systems Communications Description (SV-2) System - System Matrix (SV-3) Systems Technology Forecast (SV-9) Standards Technology Forecast (TV-2) Technical Architecture Profile (TV-1) Systems Performance Parameters Matrix (SV-7) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -..... Logical Data Model (OV-7) Systems Functionality Sequence and Timing Description (SV-10 a/b/c) Systems Evolution Description (SV-8) Physical Schema SV-11 ABC T1 T2 T3 NODES TIME ABC T1 T2 T3 NODES TIME DoDAF Views Coverage Next month

16. ® Operational Systems Technical Operational Concept Description (OV-1) Node Connectivity Description (OV-2) X Y X Z X Y Y Systems Interface Description (SV-1) Operational Activity Model (OV-5) Information Exchange Matrix (OV-3) Activity to System Function (SV-5) System Functionality Description (SV-4) Organizational Relationships Chart (OV-4) Systems Data Exchange Matrix (SV-6) Operational Activity Sequence and Timing Description (OV-6 a/b/c) Systems Communications Description (SV-2) System - System Matrix (SV-3) Systems Technology Forecast (SV-9) Standards Technology Forecast (TV-2) Technical Architecture Profile (TV-1) Systems Performance Parameters Matrix (SV-7) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -..... Logical Data Model (OV-7) Systems Functionality Sequence and Timing Description (SV-10 a/b/c) Systems Evolution Description (SV-8) Physical Schema SV-11 ABC T1 T2 T3 NODES TIME ABC T1 T2 T3 NODES TIME DoDAF Views Coverage May - July

17. ® Delivered as of March 2006 Web site documenting AP233 and CADM/AP233 mapping

18. ® Delivered as of March 2006 (2) New additions to AP233 covering –State machines suite –Assigning descriptions to anything –Some gaps filled in Interface schemas New API for creating the AP233 XML –Ruby is a language for proof-of-concept implementation, not designed for production software support

19. ® CADM/AP233 Testing Fitting into the “AP233 test harness” is current focus of my the DODAF CADM/AP233 demo work –Dwayne made a significant contribution to the architecture of this –Also changing test tools to enabling other AP233 team members to create test data So, earlier “cool CADM/AP233 demos” are broken into bits at the moment –Can show a few test harness components today

20. ® Conclusions Confirmed ideas from white paper that AP233 can support DOD DODAF/CADM data interchange requirements –Will complete DODAF CADM/AP233 Gap Analysis before AP233 ballot ends –Keeping an eye on the OMG SysML, UPDM, etc. to identify gaps in AP233 Positive, direct impact on AP233 completeness by this OSJTF project DOD in a position for future validation to build on these efforts (e.g. AP233, SysML, UPDM)

21. ® Many things are coming together Critical Testing Happens Here ISO Ballot

22. ® Contact Information David Price –David.Price@eurostep.com –+1 336 283-0606 or +44 20 7221 7307 –exff Systems Engineering http://www.exff.org/ap233 AP233 –NASA AP233 Page at http://www.ap233.org DoDAF –DoD NII Archive at http://www.defenselink.mil/nii/doc SysML –OMG SysEng SIG at http://syseng.omg.org/http://syseng.omg.org/ The International Council on Systems Engineering –INCOSE at http://www.incose.org

23. ® Operational Systems Technical Operational Concept Description (OV-1) Node Connectivity Description (OV-2) X Y X Z X Y Y Systems Interface Description (SV-1) Operational Activity Model (OV-5) Information Exchange Matrix (OV-3) Activity to System Function (SV-5) System Functionality Description (SV-4) Organizational Relationships Chart (OV-4) Systems Data Exchange Matrix (SV-6) Operational Activity Sequence and Timing Description (OV-6 a/b/c) Systems Communications Description (SV-2) System - System Matrix (SV-3) Systems Technology Forecast (SV-9) Standards Technology Forecast (TV-2) Technical Architecture Profile (TV-1) Systems Performance Parameters Matrix (SV-7) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -..... Logical Data Model (OV-7) Systems Functionality Sequence and Timing Description (SV-10 a/b/c) Systems Evolution Description (SV-8) Physical Schema SV-11 ABC T1 T2 T3 NODES TIME ABC T1 T2 T3 NODES TIME DoDAF Views Coverage Delivered now Next month May - July

24. ® Delivered as of March 2006 Web site documenting AP233 and CADM/AP233 mapping covering: –SV-1 Systems Interface –SV-2 System Communications –SV-3 System Functionality –SV-4 System-System Matrix –SV-10b, SV-10c System Sequence and States –OV-5 Operational Activity Model –OV-6b, OV-6c Operational Activity Sequence and States –TV-1 Technical Standards Profile See http://www.exff.org/ap233

25. ® NIST Project April – July 2006 (1) DODAF/AP233 Deliverable Set 1 –OV-4 Organizational Relationships Chart –OV-3 Operational Information Exchange Matrix –OV-2 Operational Node Connectivity Description DODAF/AP233 Deliverable Set 2 –SV-5 Operational Activity to Systems Function Traceability Matrix –SV-7 Systems Performance Parameters Matrix –SV-6 Systems Data Exchange Matrix

26. ® NIST Project April – July 2006 (2) DODAF/AP233 Deliverable Set 3 –OV-6a Operational Rules Model –SV-10a Systems Rules Model –SV-8 Systems Evolution Description –SV-9 Systems Technology Forecast –TV-2 Technical Standards Forecast DODAF/AP233 Deliverable Set 4 –AV-2 Integrated Dictionary –AV-1 Overview and Summary Information –OV-1 High-Level Operational Concept Graphic DODAF/AP233 Deliverable Set 5 –OV-7 Logical Data Model –SV-11 Physical Schema