Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byConnor Maiden Modified over 9 years ago
1
The Civic Orientations of Arab Publics: Selected Findings from the Arab Barometer About Country: Governance (democracy, Islam) About Individual: Engagement (interest, trust) Mark Tessler University of Michigan
2
CountryWave OneWave TwoWave Three Algeria N=1300 5-6/2006N=1216 4-5/2011N=1220 3-4/2013 BahrainN=500 1-2/2009 Egypt N=1219 6-7/2011N=1196 3-4/2013 Iraq N=1234 2-3/2011N=1215 6/2013 Jordan N=1143 6/2006N=1188 12/2010N=1795 12/2012 Kuwait N=1000 2-3/2014 LebanonN=1195 10/2007N=1387 11-12/2010N=1200 6/2013 Libya N=1247 4-5/2014 MoroccoN=1277 11-12/2006 N=1196 5-6/2013 Palestine N=1270 5/2006N=1200 12/2010N=1200 12/2012 Saudi Arabia N=1404 1-3/2011 Sudan N=1538 12/2010N=1200 4-5/2013 Tunisia N=1196 9-10/2011N=1196 2/2013 Yemen N=717 10/2007N=1200 2/2011N=1200 11-12/2013 14 countries7 surveys, N=7,40210 surveys, N=12,78212 surveys, N=14,868 Arab Barometer Data 3 Waves since 2006 14 Countries (probability samples) 29 surveys (face-to-face interviews) 35,052 respondents
3
Website: Information, Reports, Data Partners: Designing Interview Schedule
5
A democratic system may have problems, yet it is better than other political systems (9 countries) About 80 Percent in Both Waves Think Democracy Is the Best Political System Continuing Support during a Period of Turbulence
6
But Some Change in Countries that Have Experienced Greatest Level of Turbulence Agree Strongly or Agree that Democracy Is the Best Political System 6-7/ 2011 3-4/ 2013 2-3/ 2011 6/ 2013 9-10/ 2011 2/ 2013 2/ 2011 11-12/ 2013
7
There is a difference in opinion among people regarding the most important features of democracy. If you had to choose one, which of the following features would you say is the most important? Third Wave Second WaveFeature of Democracy 2627 The opportunity to change the government through elections. 1312 Freedom to criticize the government. 1814 Narrowing the gap between rich and poor. 1719 Providing basic items (such as food, housing, and clothing) to every individual. 1112 Equality of political rights between citizens. 1516 Eliminating financial and administrative corruption. 5051Political Process 5049Economic Performance An Imperfect Understanding of Democracy (as elsewhere)
8
To what extent do you strongly agree, agree, disagree or strongly disagree with each of the following statements 1. Religious leaders (imams, preachers, priests) should not interfere in voters’ decisions in elections. 2. [Your country] would be better off if religious people hold public positions in the state. 3. Religious leaders (imams, preachers, priests) should have influence over government decisions. 4. Religious practices are private and should be separated from social and political life. Islam and Its Place in Politics (Algeria, Egypt, Iraq, Jordan, Lebanon, Palestine, Sudan, Tunisia, Yemen) Percent Strongly Agree and Agree
10
Tunisia: More than a Year under an Islamist Government Religious leaders should have influence in government decisions Religious practices NOT should be separated from social and political life 9-10/ 2011 9-10/ 2011 2/ 2013 2/ 2013
11
Men of religion should have influence over the decisions of government Democracy, whatever its limitations, is better than any other political systems Strongly Agree Agree (favor Islamic influence) Disagree/ Strongly Disagree (not favor Islamic influence) Strongly Agree/ Agree Percentage of Column Percentage of Total Democratic with Islam Wave 2 Wave 3 82% 76% 33% 27% Democratic without Islam Wave 2 Wave 3 84% 83% 51% 53% Disagree/ Strongly Disagree Percentage of Column Percentage of Total “Authoritarian” with Islam 18% 24% 7% 9% “Authoritarian” without Islam 16% 17% 9% 11% Democracy With and Without Islam
12
Wave Two Wave Three Democratic with Islam Democratic without Islam Authoritarian with Islam Authoritarian without Islam Algeria20 65 607 148 6 Egypt27 1552 7010 311 12 Iraq44 3043 464 109 14 Jordan36 3845 439 10 Lebanon12 770 782 16 13 Palestine35 3150 6 99 10 Sudan46 3736 4211 7 10 Tunisia22 2367 603 48 13 Yemen52 3631 3710 147 13 Political System Preference by Country and Time Period Decrease Increase
13
Men of religion should have influence over the decisions of government % Supporting Gender Equality Wave Two Wave Three All S. Agree/ Agree (favor Islamic influence) Disagree/ S. Disagree (not favor Islamic influence) A married woman can work outside the home 83 8481 84 85 A university education is more important for a boy than a girl 73 7867 7177 82 On the whole, men make better political leaders than women 26 3420 2530 39 Attitudes toward Women and Gender Equality among Respondents Who Do and Who Do Not Favor a Political Role for Islam
14
Islamic jurists and religious scholars often differ in their interpretations of certain issues in Islam. To what extent you agree or disagree with each interpretation below? Men of religion should have influence over the decisions of government % Supporting “progressive” interpretation Wave Two Wave Three All S. Agree/ Agree (favor Islamic influence) Disagree/ S. Disagree (not favor Islamic influence) In a Muslim country, non-Muslims should enjoy less political rights than Muslims 74 7064 5881 77 In Islam, women should wear modest clothes without needing to wear the hijab 64 6262 5766 Proper Interpretation of Islam Views of Respondents Who Favor and Who Do Not Favor a Political Role for Islam
15
Individual Political Engagement and Assessment National Political Engagement: Vote in last parliamentary election Political Interest Trust in government Personal Civic Engagement Member of civic associations Interpersonal trust Political efficacy
16
How much trust do you have in the government To what extent are you interested in politics Did you vote in last parliamentary election National Political Engagement
18
A Closer Look at Trust in Government Which Countries Experienced the Most Change from Wave Two to Wave Three? What Are Some of the Demographics of Changing Assessments? Example of Yemen What Are Some of the Determinants of Trust in Government? Linear Regression with Wave Three Data
21
Model (OLS – 9 countries)Coefficient (B)Std. ErrorSignificance Constant3.294.063.000 The economic situation of our country is good.472.012.000 Islam should exert political influence -.116.010.000 Our country is very democratic (1-10 scale).108.004.000 Female.037.019.049 Older.003.001.000 Dependent variable: higher trust in government H1. Perceptions of the country’s economic situation H2. Desire for Islam to exert political influence H3. Degree to which Government is perceived to be democratic What Pushes Trust in Government Up or Down?
22
Economic Situation Perceived to be Favorable Opposes Islam Exerting Political Influence Country Perceived to be Democratic AlgeriaYes EgyptYes IraqYesYes ReversedYes JordanYesNoYes LebanonYes PalestineYes SudanYesNoYes TunisiaYes YemenYesNoYes Drivers of Higher Trust in Government Results of Linear Regression with Demographic Control Variables
23
Preview of Coming Attractions Data Release Wave 3 data Prepare merged 3-wave dataset Dissemination Increase number and coverage of short reports Enhance collaboration with Arab Reform Initiative Increase authors from the region Wave 4 Review Interview Schedule Continue fund-raising Explore addition of countries Capacity-Building Expand support for local teams Increase opportunities for Arab social scientists
Similar presentations
© 2025 SlidePlayer.com. Inc.
All rights reserved.