Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byLuis Tunstall Modified over 9 years ago
1
Varices Management: Current State of the Art Atif Zaman, MD MPH Associate Professor of Medicine Director of Clinical Hepatology Oregon Health & Science University Atif Zaman, MD MPH Associate Professor of Medicine Director of Clinical Hepatology Oregon Health & Science University
2
Portal pressure Resistance to portal flow Cirrhosis Splanchnic arteriolar resistance Portal blood inflow Varices Variceal Growth VARICES AND VARICEAL HEMORRHAGE
3
Small varices Large varices No varices 7-8%/year Varices Increase in Diameter Progressively Merli et al. J Hepatol 2003;38:266 VARICES INCREASE IN DIAMETER PROGRESSIVELY
4
Prevalence of Esophageal Varices in Cirrhosis % % 100 60 40 20 0 0 Overall Child A Child B 80 Child C Pagliaro et al., In: Portal Hypertension: Pathophysiology and Management, 1994: 72 PREVALENCE OF ESOPHAGEAL VARICES IN CIRRHOSIS
5
Prevalence and Size of Esophageal Varices in Patients with Newly-Diagnosed Cirrhosis % Patients with varices % Patients with varices 100 60 40 20 0 0 Overall n=494 Overall n=494 Child A n=346 Child A n=346 Child B n=114 Child B n=114 80 Child C n=34 Child C n=34 Large Medium Small Pagliaro et al., In: Portal Hypertension: Pathophysiology and Management, 1994: 72 PREVALENCE AND SIZE OF ESOPHAGEAL VARICES IN PATIENTS WITH NEWLY DIAGNOSED CIRRHOSIS
6
Predictors of hemorrhage: Variceal size Red signs Child B/C Predictors of hemorrhage: Variceal size Red signs Child B/C NIEC. N Engl J Med 1988; 319:983 Variceal hemorrhage Varix with red signs PROGNOSTIC INDICATORS OF FIRST VARICEAL HEMORRHAGE
7
Large Varices Are More Likely To Rupture % Patients without bleeding % Patients without bleeding 100 50 25 0 0 0 0 12 24 75 36 12 24 36 Large Varices * * p<0.01 * 2-year probability of first bleed: Small varices: 7% Large varices: 30% 2-year probability of first bleed: Small varices: 7% Large varices: 30% Time (months) No Varices Small Varices * Merli et al., Hepatol 2003; 38:266, ** Conn et al., Hepatology 1991; 13:902 LARGE VARICES ARE MORE LIKELY TO RUPTURE
8
Screening for Varices Current recommendations for screening AASLD: All patients with mod-severe cirrhosis (Child B/C) Child A with signs of portal hypertension (plts 13mm, or evidence of collaterals) ACG: All patients with cirrhosis upon diagnosis of cirrhosis A number of studies have attempted to determine risk factors for presence of large esophageal varices (LEV) Current recommendations for screening AASLD: All patients with mod-severe cirrhosis (Child B/C) Child A with signs of portal hypertension (plts 13mm, or evidence of collaterals) ACG: All patients with cirrhosis upon diagnosis of cirrhosis A number of studies have attempted to determine risk factors for presence of large esophageal varices (LEV)
9
Prevalence and Predictors of LEV in Patients with Cirrhosis AuthorNo. patientsChild A/B/C (%)LEV (%)Predictors Pagliaro49670/23/79Low plt count Lavergne5249/35/1619Ascites Barcia9534/49/1736 Ascites Advanced CPC Chalasani34622/48/3020 Plts <88,000 Splenomegaly Madhotra18443/34/2325 Splenomegaly, Plts <68,000 Zaman30011/71/1831 Plts <80,000 Advanced CPC
10
Capsule Endoscopy for Screening for Varcies Grade 3 Varices Grade 1 Varices
11
Capsule Endoscopy vs. EGD for Variceal Screening If EGD is the gold standard for variceal detection: Sensitivity of CE = 100% (84%) Specificity of CE = 89% (88%) PPV = 96% (92%) NPV = 100% (77%) If EGD is the gold standard for variceal detection: Sensitivity of CE = 100% (84%) Specificity of CE = 89% (88%) PPV = 96% (92%) NPV = 100% (77%) Eisen et al, Endoscopy 2006 38:31-35 DeFranchis et al, Hepatology 2008;47:1595-1603
12
Treatment of Varices / Variceal Hemorrhage No varices Varices No hemorrhage Varices No hemorrhage Variceal hemorrhage Variceal hemorrhage Recurrent hemorrhage Recurrent hemorrhage Prevention of variceal development PREVENTION OF VARICEAL DEVELOPMENT
13
Pre-Primary Prophylaxis Multicenter, randomized, placebo-controlled trial of timolol (non-selective beta-blocker) vs. placebo in patients Beta-blockers did not prevent the development of varices and were associated with a higher rate of serious adverse events Hepatic venous pressure gradient was the strongest predictor of the development of varices Multicenter, randomized, placebo-controlled trial of timolol (non-selective beta-blocker) vs. placebo in patients Beta-blockers did not prevent the development of varices and were associated with a higher rate of serious adverse events Hepatic venous pressure gradient was the strongest predictor of the development of varices Groszmann, et al., NEJM 2006 NON-SELECTIVE BETA BLOCKERS DO NOT PREVENT DEVELOPMENT OF VARICES
14
Treatment of Varices / Variceal Hemorrhage No varices Varices No hemorrhage Varices No hemorrhage Variceal hemorrhage Variceal hemorrhage Recurrent hemorrhage Recurrent hemorrhage No specific therapy Repeat endoscopy in 2-3 yrs* No specific therapy Repeat endoscopy in 2-3 yrs* * Sooner with cirrhosis decompensation MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITHOUT VARICES
15
Treatment of Varices / Variceal Hemorrhage No varices Varices No hemorrhage Varices No hemorrhage Variceal hemorrhage Variceal hemorrhage Recurrent hemorrhage Recurrent hemorrhage Prevention of first variceal hemorrhage PREVENTION OF FIRST VARICEAL HEMORRHAGE
16
Treated better Treated worse Porto-caval shunt -blockers Sclerotherapy 0.1 1 1 10 * * * * Prevention of First Variceal Hemorrhage * Significantly heterogeneous D’Amico et al., Hepatology 1995; 22;332 Bleeding Death Encephalopathy Relative risk PREVENTION OF FIRST VARICEAL HEMORRHAGE
17
Non-Selective Beta-Blockers Prevent First Variceal Hemorrhage Bleeding rateControlBeta-blockerAbsolute rate (~2 year) difference All varices25%15%-10% (11 trials)(n=600)(n=590)(-16 to -5) Large varices30% 14% -16% (8 trials)(n=411)(n=400) (-24 to -8) Small varices7%2%-5% (3 trials)(n=100)(n=91)(-11 to 2) Bleeding rateControlBeta-blockerAbsolute rate (~2 year) difference All varices25%15%-10% (11 trials)(n=600)(n=590)(-16 to -5) Large varices30% 14% -16% (8 trials)(n=411)(n=400) (-24 to -8) Small varices7%2%-5% (3 trials)(n=100)(n=91)(-11 to 2) D’Amico et al., Sem Liv Dis 1999; 19:475 NON-SELECTIVE BETA-BLOCKERS PREVENT FIRST VARICEAL HEMORRHAGE
18
Variceal Band Ligation (VBL) vs. Beta-Blockers (BB) in the Prevention of First Variceal Bleed Khuroo, et al., Aliment Pharmacol Ther 2005; 21:347 First hemorrhage Survival Chen 1998 Sarin 1999 De 1999 Jutabha2000 De la Mora 2000 Lui 2002 Lo 2004 Schepke 2004 Total Chen 1998 Sarin 1999 De 1999 Jutabha2000 De la Mora 2000 Lui 2002 Lo 2004 Schepke 2004 Total Relative risk 0 0 1 1 10 0 0 1 1 40 Favors VBL Favors BB VARICEAL BAND LIGATION (VBL) VS. BETA-BLOCKERS (BB) IN THE PREVENTION OF FIRST VARICEAL HEMORRHAGE
19
Treatment of Varices / Variceal Hemorrhage Recurrent hemorrhage Recurrent hemorrhage Variceal hemorrhage Variceal hemorrhage Varices No hemorrhage Varices No hemorrhage No varices Management depends on the size of varices MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH VARICES WHO HAVE NEVER BLED
20
Treatment of Varices / Variceal Hemorrhage Recurrent hemorrhage Recurrent hemorrhage Variceal hemorrhage Variceal hemorrhage Medium/ large varices No hemorrhage Medium/ large varices No hemorrhage Small varices No hemorrhage Small varices No hemorrhage No varices 1) -blockers (propranolol, nadolol) indefinitely 2) Endoscopic variceal ligation in patients intolerant to -blockers 1) -blockers (propranolol, nadolol) indefinitely 2) Endoscopic variceal ligation in patients intolerant to -blockers MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH MEDIUM/LARGE VARICES WITHOUT PRIOR HEMORRHAGE
21
Treatment of Varices / Variceal Hemorrhage Recurrent hemorrhage Recurrent hemorrhage Variceal hemorrhage Variceal hemorrhage Medium/ large varices No hemorrhage Medium/ large varices No hemorrhage Small varices No hemorrhage Small varices No hemorrhage No varices ? Prevention of variceal growth MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH SMALL VARICES WITHOUT PRIOR HEMORRHAGE
22
Merkel et al., Gastroenterology 2004; 127:476 Nadolol May Prevent the Growth of Small Varices Nadolol % Probability of variceal growth % Probability of variceal growth 100 60 40 80 10 0 0 Placebo 20 24 36 48 60 p<0.001 Time (months) NADOLOL MAY PREVENT THE GROWTH OF SMALL VARICES
23
Treatment of Varices / Variceal Hemorrhage Recurrent hemorrhage Recurrent hemorrhage Variceal hemorrhage Variceal hemorrhage Small varices No hemorrhage Small varices No hemorrhage No varices Repeat endoscopy in 1-2 years* Beta-blockers? Repeat endoscopy in 1-2 years* Beta-blockers? Medium/ large varices No hemorrhage Medium/ large varices No hemorrhage * Sooner with cirrhosis decompensation MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH SMALL VARICES WITHOUT PRIOR HEMORRHAGE
24
Treatment of Varices / Variceal Hemorrhage Control of hemorrhage Recurrent hemorrhage Recurrent hemorrhage Variceal hemorrhage Variceal hemorrhage Medium/ large varices No hemorrhage Medium/ large varices No hemorrhage Small varices No hemorrhage Small varices No hemorrhage No varices CONTROL OF ACUTE VARICEAL HEMORRHAGE
25
Treatment of Acute Variceal Hemorrhage General Management: IV access and fluid resuscitation Do not overtransfuse (hemoglobin ~ 8 g/dL) Antibiotic prophylaxis (IV ceftriaxone 1gm daily) Specific therapy: Pharmacological therapy: terlipressin, somatostatin and analogues, vasopressin + nitroglycerin Endoscopic therapy: ligation, sclerotherapy Shunt therapy: TIPS, surgical shunt General Management: IV access and fluid resuscitation Do not overtransfuse (hemoglobin ~ 8 g/dL) Antibiotic prophylaxis (IV ceftriaxone 1gm daily) Specific therapy: Pharmacological therapy: terlipressin, somatostatin and analogues, vasopressin + nitroglycerin Endoscopic therapy: ligation, sclerotherapy Shunt therapy: TIPS, surgical shunt TREATMENT OF ACUTE VARICEAL HEMORRHAGE
26
Prophylactic Antibiotics Improve Outcomes in Cirrhotic Patients with GI Hemorrhage ControlAntibioticAbsolute rate (n=270)(n=264) difference (95% CI) Infection45%14%-32% (-42 to –23) SBP / Bacteremia27%8%-18% (-26 to –11) Death24%15%-9% (-15 to –3) ControlAntibioticAbsolute rate (n=270)(n=264) difference (95% CI) Infection45%14%-32% (-42 to –23) SBP / Bacteremia27%8%-18% (-26 to –11) Death24%15%-9% (-15 to –3) Bernard et al., Hepatology 1999; 29:1655 PROPHYLACTIC ANTIBIOTICS IMPROVE OUTCOMES IN CIRRHOTIC PATIENTS WITH GI HEMORRHAGE
27
Probability of Remaining Free of Recurrent Variceal Hemorrhage Hou M-C et al., Hepatology 2004; 39:746 Prophylactic antibiotics (n=59) % free of variceal hemorrhage % free of variceal hemorrhage 1.0 0.6 0.2 0.8 1 1 0 0 No antibiotics (n=61) 0 0 2 2 3 3 12 30 Follow-up (months) 18 24 0.4 PROPHYLACTIC ANTIBIOTICS PREVENT EARLY VARICEAL REBLEEDING
28
Bañares R et al., Hepatology 2002; 35:609 Combination Drug / Endoscopic Therapy is More Effective Than Endoscopic Therapy Alone in Achieving Five-Day Hemostasis Sclero + OctreotideBesson, 1995 Ligation + Octreotide Sung, 1995 Sclero + Octreotide / STSignorelli, 1996 Sclero + Octreotide Ceriani, 1997 Sclero + Octreotide Signorelli, 1997 Sclero + STAvgerinos, 1997 Sclero + Octreotide Zuberi, 2000 Sclero / ligation + VapreotideCales, 2001 TOTAL Sclero + OctreotideBesson, 1995 Ligation + Octreotide Sung, 1995 Sclero + Octreotide / STSignorelli, 1996 Sclero + Octreotide Ceriani, 1997 Sclero + Octreotide Signorelli, 1997 Sclero + STAvgerinos, 1997 Sclero + Octreotide Zuberi, 2000 Sclero / ligation + VapreotideCales, 2001 TOTAL Favors endoscopic therapy alone 1 1 1.6 1.8 2 2 1.2 1.4 0.8 Favors endoscopic plus drug therapy Relative Risk COMBINATION DRUG/ENDOSCOPIC THERAPY IS MORE EFFECTIVE THAN ENDOSCOPIC THERAPY ALONE
29
Endoscopic Variceal Band Ligation Bleeding controlled in 90% Rebleeding rate 30% Compared with sclerotherapy: Less rebleeding Lower mortality Fewer complications Fewer treatment sessions Bleeding controlled in 90% Rebleeding rate 30% Compared with sclerotherapy: Less rebleeding Lower mortality Fewer complications Fewer treatment sessions ENDOSCOPIC VARICEAL BAND LIGATION
30
TIPS in the Treatment of Variceal Hemorrhage TIPS is rescue therapy for recurrent variceal hemorrhage (at second rebleed for esophageal varices, at first rebleed for gastric varices) TIPS is indicated in patients who rebleed on combination endoscopic plus pharmacologic therapy In patients with Child A/B cirrhosis, the distal spleno-renal shunt is as effective as TIPS (dependent on local expertise) TIPS is rescue therapy for recurrent variceal hemorrhage (at second rebleed for esophageal varices, at first rebleed for gastric varices) TIPS is indicated in patients who rebleed on combination endoscopic plus pharmacologic therapy In patients with Child A/B cirrhosis, the distal spleno-renal shunt is as effective as TIPS (dependent on local expertise) TIPS IN THE TREATMENT OF VARICEAL HEMORRHAGE
31
Recurrent hemorrhage Recurrent hemorrhage Medium/ large varices No hemorrhage Medium/ large varices No hemorrhage Small varices No hemorrhage Small varices No hemorrhage No varices Treatment of Varices / Variceal Hemorrhage Variceal hemorrhage Variceal hemorrhage 1) Safe vasoactive drug + endoscopic therapy + antibiotic prophylaxis 2) TIPS / Shunt (rescue therapy) 1) Safe vasoactive drug + endoscopic therapy + antibiotic prophylaxis 2) TIPS / Shunt (rescue therapy) MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS WITH ACUTE VARICEAL HEMORRHAGE
32
Lowest Rebleeding Rates are Obtained in HVPG Responders and With Ligation + -Blockers (19 trials) (26 trials) (54 trials) % % Rebleeding 80 60 40 20 0 0 Untreated -blockers Sclero- therapy Sclero- therapy (18 trials) Ligation (6 trials) HVPG- Responders* (6 trials) -blockers + ISMN -blockers + ISMN (2 trials) Ligation + -blockers Ligation + -blockers Bosch and García-Pagán, Lancet 2003; 361:952 * HVPG 20% from baseline LOWEST REBLEEDING RATES ARE OBTAINED IN HVPG RESPONDERS AND IN PATIENTS TREATED WITH VARICEAL BAND LIGATION + BETA-BLOCKERS
33
Treatment of Varices / Variceal Hemorrhage No varices Varices No hemorrhage Varices No hemorrhage Variceal hemorrhage Variceal hemorrhage Recurrent hemorrhage Recurrent hemorrhage 1) -blockers + ISMN or EVL 2) -blockers + EVL may be preferable 3) TIPS / shunt surgery 1) -blockers + ISMN or EVL 2) -blockers + EVL may be preferable 3) TIPS / shunt surgery PREVENTION OF RECURRENT VARICEAL HEMORRHAGE
34
Evolution of Varices Level of Intervention Management Recommendations Cirrhosis with no varices Repeat endoscopy in 2-3 years No specific therapy Repeat endoscopy in 2-3 years No specific therapy Pre-primary prophylaxis SUMMARY OF MANAGEMENT OF VARICES AND VARICEAL HEMORRHAGE
35
Evolution of Varices Level of Intervention Management Recommendations Cirrhosis with no varices Small varices No hemorrhage Small varices No hemorrhage Medium / large varices No hemorrhage Medium / large varices No hemorrhage Repeat endoscopy in 2-3 years No specific therapy Repeat endoscopy in 2-3 years No specific therapy Small varices Repeat endoscopy in 1-2 years No specific therapy ? beta-blocker to prevent enlargement Medium/Large varices Non-selective beta-blockers EVL in those who are intolerant to drugs Small varices Repeat endoscopy in 1-2 years No specific therapy ? beta-blocker to prevent enlargement Medium/Large varices Non-selective beta-blockers EVL in those who are intolerant to drugs Pre-primary prophylaxis Primary prophylaxis SUMMARY OF MANAGEMENT OF VARICES AND VARICEAL HEMORRHAGE
36
Evolution of Varices Level of Intervention Management Recommendations Cirrhosis with no varices Small varices No hemorrhage Small varices No hemorrhage Medium / large varices No hemorrhage Medium / large varices No hemorrhage Variceal hemorrhage Repeat endoscopy in 2-3 years No specific therapy Repeat endoscopy in 2-3 years No specific therapy Small varices Repeat endoscopy in 1-2 years No specific therapy ? beta-blocker to prevent enlargement Medium/Large varices Non-selective beta-blockers EVL in those who are intolerant to drugs Small varices Repeat endoscopy in 1-2 years No specific therapy ? beta-blocker to prevent enlargement Medium/Large varices Non-selective beta-blockers EVL in those who are intolerant to drugs Endoscopic/pharmacologic therapy Antibiotics in all patients TIPS or shunt surgery as rescue therapy Endoscopic/pharmacologic therapy Antibiotics in all patients TIPS or shunt surgery as rescue therapy Pre-primary prophylaxis Primary prophylaxis SUMMARY OF MANAGEMENT OF VARICES AND VARICEAL HEMORRHAGE
37
Evolution of Varices Level of Intervention Management Recommendations Cirrhosis with no varices Small varices No hemorrhage Small varices No hemorrhage Medium / large varices No hemorrhage Medium / large varices No hemorrhage Variceal hemorrhage Recurrent variceal hemorrhage Pre-primary prophylaxis Primary prophylaxis Secondary prophylaxis Repeat endoscopy in 2-3 years No specific therapy Repeat endoscopy in 2-3 years No specific therapy Small varices Repeat endoscopy in 1-2 years No specific therapy ? beta-blocker to prevent enlargement Medium/Large varices Non-selective beta-blockers EVL in those intolerant to drugs Small varices Repeat endoscopy in 1-2 years No specific therapy ? beta-blocker to prevent enlargement Medium/Large varices Non-selective beta-blockers EVL in those intolerant to drugs Endoscopic/pharmacologic therapy Antibiotics in all patients TIPS or shunt surgery as rescue therapy Endoscopic/pharmacologic therapy Antibiotics in all patients TIPS or shunt surgery as rescue therapy Beta-blockers + nitrates or EVL Beta-blockers + EVL ? TIPS or shunt surgery as rescue therapy Beta-blockers + nitrates or EVL Beta-blockers + EVL ? TIPS or shunt surgery as rescue therapy SUMMARY OF MANAGEMENT OF VARICES AND VARICEAL HEMORRHAGE
38
The Future: Directed Therapy Using Portal Pressure Measurements
39
Portal Pressure Measurements Definitive method to establish the diagnosis of portal hypertension Direct methods (percutaneous, transjugular) are cumbersome and may be associated with complications The safest and most reproducible method is measurement of the hepatic venous pressure gradient (HVPG) Definitive method to establish the diagnosis of portal hypertension Direct methods (percutaneous, transjugular) are cumbersome and may be associated with complications The safest and most reproducible method is measurement of the hepatic venous pressure gradient (HVPG) PORTAL PRESSURE MEASUREMENTS
40
Portal Pressure Measurements The hepatic venous pressure gradient (HVPG) is obtained by subtracting the free hepatic venous pressure (FHVP) from the wedged hepatic venous pressure (WHVP): The FHVP acts as an internal zero to correct for extravascular, intraabdominal pressure increases (e.g. ascites) The hepatic venous pressure gradient (HVPG) is obtained by subtracting the free hepatic venous pressure (FHVP) from the wedged hepatic venous pressure (WHVP): The FHVP acts as an internal zero to correct for extravascular, intraabdominal pressure increases (e.g. ascites) HVPG = WHVP - FHVP PORTAL PRESSURE MEASUREMENTS
41
A Threshold Portal Pressure of ~12 mmHg is Necessary for Varices to Form P<0.01 5 5 10 12 15 25 30 35 20 Hepatic Venous Pressure Gradient (mmHg) Hepatic Venous Pressure Gradient (mmHg) Garcia-Tsao et. al., Hepatology 1985; 5:419 Varices Present (n=72) Varices Present (n=72) Varices Absent (n=15) Varices Absent (n=15) A THRESHOLD PORTAL PRESSURE OF ~12 mmHg IS NECESSARY FOR VARICES TO FORM
42
% Rebleeding % Rebleeding Decrease In Hepatic Venous Pressure Gradient (HVPG) Reduces Risk of Variceal Bleeding 0 0 20 40 60 80 100 HVPG decrease > 20% from baseline HVPG decrease > 20% from baseline HVPG decrease to < 12 mmHg 0% 46-65% 7-13% No change in HVPG No change in HVPG Bosch and García-Pagán, Lancet 2003; 361:952 DECREASE IN HEPATIC VENOUS PRESSURE GRADIENT (HVPG) REDUCES THE RISK OF VARICEAL BLEEDING
43
Abraldes et al., Hepatology 2003; 37:902 Probability of Survival (%) Probability of Survival (%) 100 50 25 0 0 75 Time (months) 96 84 72 60 48 36 24 12 0 0 HVPG non-responders HVPG responders p=0.003 95% 52% Survival Improves in Patients in Whom HVPG Decreases (HVPG Responders) SURVIVAL IMPROVES IN PATIENTS IN WHOM HVPG DECREASES (HVPG RESPONDERS)
Similar presentations
© 2025 SlidePlayer.com. Inc.
All rights reserved.