1. United States Joint Forces Command
Joint After Action Review Resource Library (JAAR-RL) Info Brief
Aug 2009
Ken Goad
USJFCOM- J7
Deputy, Joint Training Solutions Div
PEO STRI
NRL
JITC
JFCOM
AFRL/APL
PMTRASYS
ARI

2. Trainer and Analyst Presentation
What is JAAR - RL?
Live C4I Systems
Trainer and Analyst Presentation
Module
Virtual/Constructive
Simulations
User Outputs
Real Time White Cell
Measures of Effectiveness
Measures of Performance
Ground Truth vs. Perceived truth
Textual/graphical summaries and reports
TENA
HLA
DIS
C4I
VIDEO
COMMS. C2
Range Instrumentation Systems
Data Fusion & Analysis Module
Service Weapon
& Sensor systems
DoD Unique Analysis/Collection Systems
A GOTS integrated product that enables high quality feedback/assessment for the Joint Warfighter 2

3. Why ??
Identified Needs
Training Transformation Implementation Plan (Initial)
High Quality Feedback & Ground Truth
JNTC Accreditation and Certification Shortfalls (validated)
MWTC, MSTP, MAGTF-TC, MAWTS-1, Virtual Flag, Green Flag East , Blue Flag, WPC/USAFE, Air Wing Fallon, JTFEX, FST-J, USAREUR
Multiple training programs have identified Joint AAR shortfalls
Functional needs analysis vetted with stakeholders in FY05 3

4. (Modified JCIDS Process) Initial Production Delivery
How
(Modified JCIDS Process)
FY 05
FY 06
FY 07
FY 08
FY 12
Requirements
Analysis
FNA
Operational
Analysis
CONOPS
Analysis showed that no Service nominated tool provided a Joint data collection and analysis capability
Functional Analysis &
Post Independent Analysis
Service AAR Nominations
FSA
IOC
FOC
DODAF OVs & SVs
System
Architecture
Increments provide greater capabilities with addition of GOTS AAR Tools
Block 0
Technology
Demonstration
Block 1
Prototype Program &
Initial Production Delivery
Army, Navy, Marine Corp
Product Line Integration
Acquisition
Programs
PMP &
SRV
BASELINE CM
LVC-IC/IA - Army
TSTS - Navy
NECC - DISA 4

5. Concept of Operation
1 PLAN: Setup the training objectives and participants.
2 CONDUCT: When required, download the subjective measurements to the PDAs/Notebooks for Instructor(s) and analysts.
8 Analyze Event: Improve the training process & identify DOTMLPF gaps.
5 ASSESS: Near real time feedback
C4I
7 Conduct AAR:
Reports and conclusions presented to training audience.
HLA
Unify the planning, execution and reporting of training exercises
Provide a mechanism to deliver structure, rigor and repeatability to an exercise
Incorporate both objective and subjective exercise measurements into the results
Allow the development of self contained training units for distribution (e.g. for OBT)
TENA
DIS
4 COLLECT: Empirical and subjective data collected and associated during the exercise.
3 CONDUCT: Instructor(s) and analysts, input observations
6 Conclusions: Generate event Reports for the target audience. 5

6. JAAR-RL Enables Collection, Exchange, Analysis and Visualization of Tactical and Operational Data
Site AAR
Weapon Data
JAAR
Service C2
Service Data Base
COMMAND
CENTERS
Perceived Truth
Weapon AAR
RANGE
INSTRUMENTATION
Range Ground Truth
LIVE TRAINING
EXERCISES
Perceived Truth
Service Data Base
JTEN/Service Networks
SIMULATIONS
SIMULATION
RESPONSE CELLS
HLA, DIS,
VIRTUAL, CONSTRUCTIVE
Simulation Ground Truth
Simulation Ground Truth
Sensor Data
C4I Data Collector.
AAR
Intel Data
Collectors
AAR
Service Comms.
Voice Data
Green = Range Ground Truth
Red = Sim Ground Truth
Purple = Perceived Truth
Black = Analysis & Exercise Control 6

7. JAAR-RL Four Views Integrated Analysis Capability
Top COP - C2PC
3D Replay SIMDIS
Top COP
C2PC Feed
3D Display
3D models
Sequential Playback
Analyst Workstation
Report Generation
Presentation Manager
2D Display
MS2525B & NTDS Icons
CDADRG map data
2D Replay DDST
Analyst Workstation

8. Benefits to Warfighter and Analyst
Reuse of existing AAR capabilities
Tactical and Operational Situational Awareness (Real Time and Near Real Time)
Tactical and Operational event recording with 2D and 3D playback
Real Time event adjudication
Pre-defined Hot button and user queried reports
Analyze conclusions & take home packages
Fratricide analysis via automated engagement reporting
Measurements of Effectiveness and Performance
Verifies Warfighter gaps in Tactical Techniques and Procedures (TTP’s).
Tool for staff, unit commanders and pilot/aircrew and ground combat team debrief.
Academic environments to study Lessons Learned.

9. Development and Deployment Schedule
FY 06
FY 07
FY 08
FY 09
FY 10
FY 11
FY 12
Requirements Analysis
Block 2
Initial Automated Reports
Enhance Assessment
Initial Digital Assistant
Block 4
Video & Voice
Planning
Enhanced Reporting & Real-time
Analysis
Block 0
Prototype Demo Program
Architecture Established
Five Service Apps integrated
FOC
IOC
Sustained Capability
Block 5
Multi Network Distributive operations
Human Performance Measures
Mission Thread Analysis
Block 3
Deployable System
Performance Measures
CAOC Analysis
Tactical Communications
Block 2
Production Program
3 Service training programs
Other Programs
JTFEX
FST PAC
Service Joint Training Programs
FST LANT
USAFE
GF – E
BCTP
BLUE FLAG VF
AWF
JKCE
JMRC
MAWTS-1
MAGTF-TC
JRTC
MSTP
USAREUR
LVC-IA?
LVC-IC
Acquisition Training Programs
TSTS?
NECC?
12 Million
Source Lines
of Code
Joint AAR Resource Library Size
6 Million
Source Lines
of Code
Army, Navy, Marine Corp
Product Line Integration
Successfully Leveraging Service Programs/Investments 9

10. Business Model JFCOM J7 funded: Customer funded:
GOTS product development
Product Installation for JNTC assessed Service Training Programs
System software sustainment/upgrades
System logistics support
Initial on-site training and help desk support
Customer funded:
hardware logistics support after 2 years
Event Analyst
Software and H/W specs have been made available to other Service training development program for evaluation (i.e. LVI – IC/IA, TSTS, NECC) 10

11. Summary
Provides the Joint Enterprise near real-time/post event capability
Currently meets needs (291) identified in FNA
36% (104) completed
26% (76) in development
38% (111) remaining
Current fielding of 6 systems
Planned fielding of 16 by FY12
Leverages and integrates existing data collection and AAR capabilities across the Services
Available for Joint and Service specific analysis
Available for utilization by emerging training system development programs (Currently being evaluated by LVC-IC\IA & Delivery Planned for AFRL)
Capturing future product enhancement requirements from customers
Initial setup and fielding provided 11

12. BACKUPS

13. Resource Library Tool Sets
Integrated Source Code Library
GOTS Open Source
JAAR RL Integrated Capabilities
Naval Research
Laboratory
JFCOM
Air Force Research Laboratory
PMTRASYS
USMC
PEO STRI
Army
JFCOM/Air Force Research Laboratory
Jan 2010
JITC
DISA
JMOC-Spotlite
Future Capabilities
GCCS
SIMDIS
CPAS
CAPT
DDST
WARSIM
ONESAF
JLVC-DT
JIMES 13

14. Improved Training AssessmentF
JAAR – RL CAPABILITIES
Improved Training Assessment
Changes
Engineering
Collected Data
Block 4
Service Events
C2 Data Analysis
User Feedback
Block 3
JIMES
Lessons Learned
Measures &
Reports
CAPT
Block 2
CPAS
CPAS
Enhanced Assessments
JMOC
JMOC
JLVCDT
JLVCDT
Block 1
JLVCDT
SIMDIS
SIMDIS
SIMDIS
Initial Production
DDST
DDST
DDST
DDST
GCCS
RAP/VTM
GCCS
GCCS
ONESAF
ONESAF
ONESAF
ONESAF
WARSIM
WARSIM
WARSIM
WARSIM
Service Capability Additions 07 08 09 10 14

15. Documented Program Weekly Engineering Meetings
Review Schedule & Status
Software Problem Reports
Issues
Configuration Management
Maintain all code
SW Version control
System Configuration Documentation
Documentation
User manuals
Software Installation procedures
Startup/shut down procedures
CM documentation
Program Documents
Functional Needs Analysis
Functional Solution Analysis
System Verification Review Specification
Program Management Plan
Concept of Operations
Training
Available in Orlano or/and Site
System admin
User training
Logistic Support
Planning & coordination
Help Desk
Integration/test
Hardware
HW Spec’s
HW Configuration
HW Maintenance – 18 Months
Software
OS SW Licenses
Executables
Security
ATO/SSAA
Operate in multiple environments (Unclassified & Secret)
JTEN and NCTE