Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byReyna Lugar Modified over 10 years ago
1
Ludovico Biagi & Athanasios Dermanis Politecnico di Milano, DIIAR Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Department of Geodesy and Surveying Crustal Deformation Analysis from Permanent GPS Networks European Geophysical Union General Assembly - EGU2009 19 -24 April 2009, Vienna, Austria
2
Our approach - Departure from classical horizontal deformation analysis:
3
- New rigorous equations for deformation invariant parameters: Principal (max-min) linear elongation factors & their directions Dilatation, (maximum) shear strain & its direction
4
Our approach - Departure from classical horizontal deformation analysis: - New rigorous equations for deformation invariant parameters: Principal (max-min) linear elongation factors & their directions Dilatation, (maximum) shear strain & its direction - New rigorous equations for “horizontal” deformation analysis on the reference ellipsoid Attention: NOT for the physical surface of the earth, NOT 3-dimentional !
5
Our approach - Departure from classical horizontal deformation analysis: - New rigorous equations for deformation invariant parameters: Principal (max-min) linear elongation factors & their directions Dilatation, (maximum) shear strain & its direction - Separation of relative rigid motion of (sub)regions from actual deformation: Identification of regions with different kinematic behavior (clustering) Use of best fitting reference system for each region (Concept of regional discrete Tisserant reference system) - New rigorous equations for “horizontal” deformation analysis on the reference ellipsoid Attention: NOT for the physical surface of the earth, NOT 3-dimentional !
6
Our approach - Departure from classical horizontal deformation analysis: - New rigorous equations for deformation invariant parameters: Principal (max-min) linear elongation factors & their directions Dilatation, (maximum) shear strain & its direction - Separation of relative rigid motion of (sub)regions from actual deformation: Identification of regions with different kinematic behavior (clustering) Use of best fitting reference system for each region (Concept of regional discrete Tisserant reference system) - New rigorous equations for “horizontal” deformation analysis on the reference ellipsoid Attention: NOT for the physical surface of the earth, NOT 3-dimentional ! PLUS Study of signal-to-noise ratio (significance) of deformation parameters from spatially interpolated GPS velocity estimates using: - Finite element method (triangular elements) - Minimum Mean Square Error Prediction (collocation) CASE STUDY: Central Japan
7
Deformation as comparison of tw o shapes (at two epochs) x = coordinates at epoch t Mathematical Elasticity: Deformation studied via the deformation gradient local linear approximation to the deformation function
8
Deformation as comparison of tw o shapes (at two epochs) x = coordinates at epoch t u = x - x = displacements Mathematical Elasticity: Deformation studied via the deformation gradient local linear approximation to the deformation function Geophysics-Geodesy: Deformation studied via the displacement gradient and approximation to strain tensor
9
Classical horizontal deformation analysis A short review
10
Classical horizontal deformation analysis Strain tensor E : description of (quadratic) variation of length element
11
Classical horizontal deformation analysis Strain tensor E : description of (quadratic) variation of length element Geodetic data: Discrete initial coordinates x 0i and velocities v i at GPS permanent stations P i Displacements: u i = (t – t 0 ) v i
12
SPATIAL INTERPOLATION for the determination of or Classical horizontal deformation analysis Strain tensor E : description of (quadratic) variation of length element Geodetic data: Discrete initial coordinates x 0i and velocities v i at GPS permanent stations P i Displacements: u i = (t – t 0 ) v i Require: DIFFERENTIATION for the determination of or
13
Discrete geodetic information at GPS permanent stations Classical horizontal deformation analysis
14
Discrete geodetic information at GPS permanent stations Interpolation to obtain continuous information, e.g. displacements at every point Classical horizontal deformation analysis SPATIAL INTERPOLATION
15
Discrete geodetic information at GPS permanent stations Interpolation to obtain continuous information, e.g. displacements at every point Differentiation to obtain the deformation gradient F or displacement gradient J = F - I Classical horizontal deformation analysis SPATIAL INTERPOLATION
16
Analysis of the displacement gradient J into symmetric and antisymmetric part: Classical horizontal deformation analysis
17
Analysis of the displacement gradient J into symmetric and antisymmetric part: = small rotation angle Classical horizontal deformation analysis
18
Analysis of the displacement gradient J into symmetric and antisymmetric part: diagonalization e max, e min = principal strains = direction of e max = small rotation angle Classical horizontal deformation analysis
19
Analysis of the displacement gradient J into symmetric and antisymmetric part: diagonalization = small rotation angle = dilataton = maximum shear strain = direction of Classical horizontal deformation analysis e max, e min = principal strains = direction of e max
20
Analysis of the displacement gradient J into symmetric and antisymmetric part: diagonalization = small rotation angle = dilataton = maximum shear strain = direction of Classical horizontal deformation analysis e max, e min = principal strains = direction of e max
21
SVD Horizontal deformational analysis using the Singular Value Decomposition (SVD) A new approach
22
Horizontal deformational analysis using Singular Value Decomposition from diagonalizations: SVD
23
Horizontal deformational analysis using Singular Value Decomposition
28
Rigorous derivation of invariant deformation parameters without the approximations based on the infinitesimal strain tensor
29
Rigorous derivation of invariant deformation parameters shear along the 1st axis linear scale factordirection of shear additional rotation not contributing to deformation 2 alternative 4-parametric representations
30
Rigorous derivation of invariant deformation parameters shear along the 1st axis linear scale factordirection of shear additional rotation not contributing to deformation 2 alternative 4-parametric representations
31
Rigorous derivation of invariant deformation parameters shear along the 1st axis linear scale factordirection of shear additional rotation not contributing to deformation 2 alternative 4-parametric representations
32
Rigorous derivation of invariant deformation parameters shear along the 1st axis linear scale factordirection of shear additional rotation not contributing to deformation 2 alternative 4-parametric representations
33
Rigorous derivation of invariant deformation parameters shear along the 1st axis linear scale factordirection of shear additional rotation not contributing to deformation 2 alternative 4-parametric representations
34
Rigorous derivation of invariant deformation parameters shear along the 1st axis linear scale factordirection of shear additional rotation not contributing to deformation 2 alternative 4-parametric representations
35
shear along the 1st axis Rigorous derivation of invariant deformation parameters
36
shear along direction Rigorous derivation of invariant deformation parameters
37
additional rotation (no deformation) Rigorous derivation of invariant deformation parameters
38
additional scaling (scale factor s) Rigorous derivation of invariant deformation parameters
39
Compare the two representations and express s, , , as functions of 1, 2, , Rigorous derivation of invariant deformation parameters
40
Derivation of dilatation
41
Use Singular Value Decomposition and replace Rigorous derivation of invariant deformation parameters Derivation of shear , and its direction
42
Rigorous derivation of invariant deformation parameters Derivation of shear , and its direction Compare
43
Rigorous derivation of invariant deformation parameters Derivation of shear , and its direction
44
Rigorous derivation of invariant deformation parameters Derivation of shear , and its direction
45
Horizontal deformation on the surface of the reference ellipsoid
46
Actual deformation is 3-dimensional Horizontal deformation on ellipsoidal surface
47
But we can observe only on 2-dimensional earth surface ! Horizontal deformation on ellipsoidal surface
48
Why not 3D deformation? 3D deformation requires not only interpolation but also an extrapolation outside the surface Extrapolation from surface geodetic data is not reliable – requires additional geophysical hypothesis INTERPOLATION EXTRAPOLATION Horizontal deformation on ellipsoidal surface
49
Standard horizontal deformation: Project surface points on horizontal plane, Study the deformation of the derived (abstract) planar surface Horizontal deformation on ellipsoidal surface
50
Why not study deformation of actual earth surface? Local surface deformation is a view of actual 3D deformation through a section along the tangent plane to the surface. For variable terrain: we look on 3D deformation from different directions ! Horizontal and vertical deformation caused by different geophysical processes (e.g. plate motion vs postglacial uplift) Horizontal deformation on ellipsoidal surface
51
Our approach to horizontal deformation: Project surface points on reference ellipsoid, Study the deformation of the derived (abstract) ellipsoidal surface Horizontal deformation on ellipsoidal surface
52
Use curvilinear coordinates on the surface (geodetic coordinates) Formulate coordinate gradient HOW IT IS DONE: Horizontal deformation on ellipsoidal surface
53
HOW IT IS DONE: F q refers to local (non orthonormal) coordinate bases: Horizontal deformation on ellipsoidal surface
54
HOW IT IS DONE: F q refers to local (non orthonormal) coordinate bases: Change to orthonormal bases: converting metric matrices to identity Horizontal deformation on ellipsoidal surface
55
HOW IT IS DONE: F q refers to local (non orthonormal) coordinate bases: Change to orthonormal bases: Transform F q to orthonormal bases: converting metric matrices to identity Horizontal deformation on ellipsoidal surface
56
HOW IT IS DONE: THEN PROCEED AS IN THE PLANAR CASE
57
Separation of rigid motion from deformation The concept of the discrete Tisserant reference system best adapted to a particular region
58
Separation of rigid motion from deformation SPATIAL INTERPOLATION
59
Separation of rigid motion from deformation
60
BAD SPATIAL INTERPOLATION Separation of rigid motion from deformation
61
GOOD SPATIAL INTERPOLATION PIECEWISE INTERPOLATION INVOLVES DISCONTINUITIES = FAULTS ! Separation of rigid motion from deformation
62
Horizontal Displacements Separation of rigid motion from deformation
63
Horizontal Displacements Separation of rigid motion from deformation
64
Different displacements behavior in 3 regions Apart from internal deformation regions are in relative motion Separation of rigid motion from deformation
65
HOW TO REPRESENT THE MOTION OF A DEFORMING REGION AS A WHOLE ? BY THE MOTION OF A REGIONAL OPTIMAL REFERENCE SYSTEM ! OPTIMAL = SUCH THAT THE CORRESPONDING DISPLACEMENTS (OR VELOVITIES) BECOME AS SMALL AS POSSIBLE Separation of rigid motion from deformation
66
ORIGINAL REFERENCE SYSTEM OPTIMAL REFERENCE SYSTEM Motion as whole ( = motion of reference system) + internal deformation ( = motion with respect to the reference system) Separation of rigid motion from deformation
67
Horizontal motion on earth ellipsoid ( sphere): Rotation around an axis with angular velocity Separation of rigid motion from deformation
68
Horizontal motion on earth ellipsoid ( sphere): Rotation around an axis with angular velocity DEFINITION OF OPTIMAL FRAME: Minimization of relative kinetic energy of regional network Discrete Tisserant reference system Separation of rigid motion from deformation
69
Horizontal motion on earth ellipsoid ( sphere): Rotation around an axis with angular velocity DEFINITION OF OPTIMAL FRAME: Minimization of relative kinetic energy of regional network Discrete Tisserant reference system Separation of rigid motion from deformation SOLUTION: = inertia matrix = relative angular momentum Migrating pole, variable angular velocity versus usual constant rotation (Euler rotation)
70
Spatial interpolation or prediction
71
TRIANGULAR FINITE ELEMENTSMINIMUM MEAN SQUARE ERROR PREDICTION (COLLOCATION) Spatial interpolation or prediction true interpolated true interpolated
72
TRIANGULAR FINITE ELEMENTSMINIMUM MEAN SQUARE ERROR PREDICTION (COLLOCATION) Spatial interpolation or prediction Deterministic interpolationInterpolation by stochastic prediction true interpolated true interpolated
73
TRIANGULAR FINITE ELEMENTSMINIMUM MEAN SQUARE ERROR PREDICTION (COLLOCATION) Spatial interpolation or prediction Piecewise linear displacements Piecewise constant deformation parameters Continuous displacements Continuous deformation parameters Deterministic interpolationInterpolation by stochastic prediction true interpolated true interpolated
74
TRIANGULAR FINITE ELEMENTSMINIMUM MEAN SQUARE ERROR PREDICTION (COLLOCATION) Spatial interpolation or prediction Piecewise linear displacements Piecewise constant deformation parameters Continuous displacements Continuous deformation parameters Observation errors completely absorbed in deformation parameters estimates Observation errors partially removed by interpolation smoothing Deterministic interpolationInterpolation by stochastic prediction true interpolated true interpolated
75
TRIANGULAR FINITE ELEMENTSMINIMUM MEAN SQUARE ERROR PREDICTION (COLLOCATION) Spatial interpolation or prediction Piecewise linear displacements Piecewise constant deformation parameters Continuous displacements Continuous deformation parameters Observation errors completely absorbed in deformation parameters estimates Observation errors partially removed by interpolation smoothing Deterministic interpolationInterpolation by stochastic prediction Accuracy estimates of deformation parameters reflect only data uncertainty Accuracy estimates of deformation parameters reflect both data and interpolation uncertainty true interpolated true interpolated
76
Principal linear elongation factors vs principal strains A comparison
77
Linear elongations and strains StrainsLinear elongation factors Definitions
78
Linear elongations and strains StrainsLinear elongation factors Definitions Computation from diagonalizations
79
Linear elongations and strains StrainsLinear elongation factors Meaning ? clear meaning ! Definitions Computation from diagonalizations Interpretation
80
Linear elongations and strains StrainsLinear elongation factors Meaning ? clear meaning ! Definitions Computation from diagonalizations Interpretation Relation
81
Case study: National permanent GPS network in Central Japan
83
Case study: Central Japan Original velocities
84
Reduced velocities (removal of rotation) Case study: Central Japan
85
Reduced velocities
86
Case study: Central Japan Division in 3 regions. Relative velocities w.r. region R2 after removal of rigid rotations
87
Linear elongation factors max = 1, min = 2 FINITE ELEMENTS SEPARATE COLLOCATIONS IN EACH REGION
88
Dilatation and shear FINITE ELEMENTSCOLLOCATION
89
SNR = Signal to Noise Ration FINITE ELEMENTS COLLOCATION
90
FINITE ELEMENTS COLLOCATION SNR = Signal to Noise Ration
91
Linear trends in each sub-region ( max -1) 10 6 0.002 0.006 ( min -1) 10 6 0.044 0.008 57.1 6.0 10 6 0.043 0.010 10 6 0.046 0.010 12.1 6.0 ( max -1) 10 6 0.004 0.007 ( min -1) 10 6 0.072 0.008 89.6 3.9 10 6 0.068 0.011 10 6 0.076 0.011 134.6 3.9 ( max -1) 10 6 0.001 0.013 ( min -1) 10 6 0.116 0.021 69.5 5.8 10 6 0.117 0.024 10 6 0.116 0.026 24.5 5.8 R1 R2 R3 R1 R2 R3
92
Conclusions Minimum Mean Square Error Prediction (collocation) has the following advantages: - Produces continuous results for any desired point in the region of application -Provides smooth results where the effect of the data errors is partially removed - Provides more realistic variances-covariances which in addition to the data uncertainty reflect also the interpolation uncertainty
93
THANKS FOR YOUR ATTENTION A copy of this presentation can be downloaded from http://der.topo.auth.gr/
Similar presentations
© 2025 SlidePlayer.com. Inc.
All rights reserved.