1. 1 September 2003 IEEE 802.17 Draft 2.5 OAM Comment Resolution Las Vegas, NV - September 2003 Section Editor: Glenn Parsons Technical Editors: Leon Bruckman, Gal Mor

2. 2 September 2003 RPR OAM Met in 1 session (3 long hours) for: 72 comments reviewed Did not deal with most Editorials –Will ask for editorial license for 41 remaining editorials Punted 2 comments to WG Punted 2 comments to clause 0 Highlight of CRG resolutions Response to IETF on MIB

3. 3 September 2003 OAM Comments Summary Clause 11: OAM41 –Accepted17 –Rejected3 –Withdrawn1 –Remaining Editorial22 Annex L: Echo & Flush OAM5 –Accepted2 –Remaining Editorial3 Clause 12: Management18 –Accepted12 –Withdrawn1 –Remaining Editorial5 Annex D: MIB26 –Accepted17 –Withdrawn1 –Rejected1 –Remaining Editorial3 All Technical done

4. 4 September 2003 Clause 11 & L Highlights Fix RPR alarms references Fix PICS Various binding editorials Various wording clarifications Fix state machine routines Align frame/payload format with new clause 0 resolution

5. 5 September 2003 Clause 12 Highlights Complete parameters Clarify & add reference for HC Various clarifications

6. 6 September 2003 Clause D Highlights Various binding editorials Clarify security section Delicate text on clearing intervals Table D.2 improvements Change running counters back to counter64

7. 7 September 2003 Rejected Clause 11 –391 - Table 11.2 Delete This table is useful clarification of a complex figure. It should stay. Annex D –Editorial rejection

8. 8 September 2003 Punt to WG 415 - EUI vs OUI –Topology & OAM Organization specific protocol identifiers –Was OUI, currently EUI, comment to make OUI –EUI rejected for similar use in 802.3ah –Propose liaison to IEEE RAC 467 - DELAY_TO_CHECK, DELAY_TO_RESTORE –Clause 6 uses as constant –MIB uses as read/write

9. 9 September 2003 Ongoing review Issues OAM Editors need some extra time at the end of the draft writing to align the MIB cross-references IETF MIB experts will be informed of the disposition of their comments and continue to be offered to provide comments on future WG ballots