Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byMargaretMargaret Harrington Modified over 9 years ago
1
Welcome to PLDI 2009 General chair: Michael Hind Program chair: Amer Diwan Tutorial chair: Kim Hazelwood Workshops chair: Ranjit Jhala FIT chair: Rodric Rabbah Student research chair: Marco Pistoia Local arrangements chair: David Gregg
2
Attendance Trends (as of June 18, 2009)
3
PLDI Attendance Breakdown Regular vs. Student
4
Program Committee Ali-Reza Adl-Tabatabai, IntelChandra Krintz, UCSB Steve Blackburn, ANUDoug Lea, SUNY Oswego Hans Boehm, HPOndrej Lhotak, Waterloo Karl Crary, CMUTamiya Onodera, IBM Pedro Diniz, ISTJens Palsberg, UCLA Lieven Eeckhout, GhentBill Pugh, UMD David Grove, IBMShaz Qadeer, Microsoft Matthias Hauswirth, LuganoJeremy Siek, Colorado Laurie Hendren, McGillYannis Smaragdakis, UMass Wilson Hsieh, GoogleLinda Torczon, Rice Jens Knoop, TU ViennaXiangyu Zhang, Purdue Analyzed recent trends to identify areas; picked top people in proportion to the areas
5
New in PLDI 2009 External Review Committee (ERC) –51 members (printed proceedings are missing names) –Nominated by program committee as experts in their own areas –Bid on papers—just like the program committee Inspired by ISMM 2008
6
Paper Submission Double blind without compromising paper –Authors could submit TRs etc. which I forwarded to reviewers as needed –Authors could reveal their identity in their rebuttal if needed Authors indicated conflicts with PC and ERC members
7
Paper Reviewing 196 paper submissions (a record!) 3 PC and 1 ERC members reviewed each paper –X reviews: 310 –Y reviews: 371 –Z reviews: 110 Obtained additional external reviews if a paper had too few X/Y reviews
8
Rebuttal/Discussion Period 10 days between rebuttal due date and PC meeting I acted on three categories: 1.Not enough expert reviews Obtained additional reviews 2.Strongly conflicting reviews (AD) Initiated online discussion ~180 messages total 3.Strong review was external Initiated online discussion
9
PC Meeting (1) 2 full days in Boulder, CO 100% attendance Accepted 41 papers
10
PC Meeting (2) Used “Identify the Champion” Discussed every paper with an “A” PC members could resurrect any paper –And did! Michael Hind and Todd Mytkowicz took detailed notes, managed time, … Jens Palsberg subbed for me or Mike
11
Acceptance Statistics
12
Acceptance by Area
13
Special Thanks Lisa Tolles at Sheridan Paolo and Rich, start submission software Mike Hind and Todd Mytkowicz PC and ERC members Authors
14
Announcements Distinguished paper award after last session Enjoy
Similar presentations
© 2024 SlidePlayer.com. Inc.
All rights reserved.