1. 1 Energy Star Commercial Refrigerator & Freezer Deemed Calculation Analysis

2. 2 Issues Current “base case” specifications for Solid Door Refrigerators and Freezers appear to be set too low Current Energy Star specifications for Solid Door Refrigerators and Freezers also appear to be set too low Deemed Savings Calculator may be estimating savings that are too optimistic No Energy Star specifications for “transparent” door products

3. Share of CEC Listed Models Qualifying for Energy Star & CEE Tiers Product Class Meet Energy Star Meet CEE Tier 1 Meet CEE Tier 2 Refrigerators – Solid Door65% 13% Refrigerators – Transparent DoorNo Spec31%9% Freezers – Solid Door88% 11% Ice Cream Freezers – Solid Door33%No Spec Refrigerator/Freezers – Solid Door28%No Spec Refrigerator/Freezers – Transparent DoorNo Spec

4. 4 Current Deemed Savings Calculation Baseline Efficiency Assumptions Product Definition Baseline Use Assumption Energy Star/ CEE Tier 1 Refrigerators – Solid Door0.125V + 2.760.10V + 2.04 Refrigerators – Transparent Door0.172V + 4.770.12V + 3.34 Freezers –Solid Door0.398 V + 2.280.40V + 1.38 Refrigerator-Freezers – Solid Door0.273 AV + 1.650.27AV - 0.71 Ice Cream Freezers – Solid Door0.398 V + 2.830.39V + 0.82

5. 5 Energy Use of Energy Star and CEE Qualifying Models vs. All Available Models of Solid Door Refrigerators

6. 6 Energy Use of Energy Star and CEE Qualifying Models vs. All Available Models of Transparent Door Refrigerators

7. 7 Energy Use of Energy Star and CEE Qualifying Models vs. All Available Models of Solid Door Commercial Freezers

8. 8 Energy Use of Transparent Door Refrigerators/Freezers

9. 9 Energy Use of Energy Star Models vs. All Available Models of Solid Door Refrigerators/Freezers

10. 10 Energy Use of Energy Star and CEE Qualifying Models vs. All Available Models of Reach-In, Roll-In & Pass Through Solid Door Refrigerators

11. 11 Energy Use of Energy Star and CEE Qualifying Models vs. All Available Models of Milk and Beverage Coolers Solid Door Refrigerators

12. 12 Energy Use of Energy Star and CEE Qualifying Models vs. All Available Models of Undercounter and Wine Coolers Solid Door Refrigerators

13. 13 Energy Use of Energy Star and CEE Qualifying Models vs. All Available Models of Reach-In, Roll-In and Pass Through Transparent Door Refrigerators

14. 14 Energy Use of Energy Star and CEE Qualifying Models vs. All Available Models of Milk or Beverage Coolers Transparent Door Refrigerators

15. 15 Energy Use of Energy Star and CEE Qualifying Models vs. All Available Models of Solid Door Reach-In, Roll-In & Pass Through Freezers

16. 16 Energy Use of Energy Star and CEE Qualifying Models vs. All Available Models of Transparent Door Reach-In, Roll-In & Pass Through Freezers Y = 0.83x + 5.77

17. 17 Energy Use of Energy Star and CEE Qualifying Models vs. All Available Models of Solid Door Ice Cream Freezers

18. 18 Energy Use of Transparent Door Refrigerators/Freezers

19. 19 Energy Use of Energy Star Models vs. All Available Models of Solid Door Refrigerators/Freezers

20. 20 Revised Baseline Recommendations – Solid Door Refrigerators Product Definition Current Baseline Assumption Proposed Baseline Assumption Reach-In, Roll-In, Pass-Through Refrigerators – Solid Door0.125V + 2.76 0.079V + 2. 90 0.100V + 2.04 Milk or Beverage Cooler – Solid Door Refrigerators0.125V + 2.76 0.068V + 1.22 0.060V + 1.22 Undercounter & Wine Cooler – Solid Door Refrigerators0.125V + 2.76No Change

21. 21 Revised Baseline Recommendations – Transparent Door Refrigerators Product Definition Current Baseline Assumption Proposed Baseline Assumption Reach-In, Roll-In & Pass Through Refrigerators – Transparent Door0.172V + 4.770.118V + 5.44 Milk or Beverage Cooler – Transparent Door0.172V + 4.77 0.133V + 2.40 0.120V + 3.34

22. 22 Revised Baseline Recommendations – Freezers Product Definition Current Baseline Assumption Proposed Baseline Assumption Reach-In, Roll-In & Pass Through Solid Door Freezers0.398 V + 2.28 0.31V + 3.50 0.40V + 1.38 Reach-In, Roll-In & Pass Through Transparent Door Freezers0.940 V + 5.100.76V + 5.29 Ice Cream Freezers – Solid Door0.398 V + 2.280.38V + 2.24 Ice Cream Freezers – Transparent Door0.940 V + 5.10

23. 23 Revised Baseline Recommendations – Refrigerator/Freezers Product Definition Current Baseline Assumption Proposed Baseline Assumption Reach-In, Roll-In & Pass Through Solid Door Refrigerator/Freezers0.273AV + 1.650.10AV + 6.85 Reach-In, Roll-In & Pass Through Transparent Door Refrigerator/ FreezersNot Covered0.047AV - 0.087

24. Share of Existing RTF Baseline Refrigerator Models Above Proposed Revised RTF Baselines Product Class Revised Baseline Reach-In, Roll-In & Pass-Through Refrigerators – Solid Door71%/63% Milk or Beverage Coolers – Solid Door75%/65% Undercounter & Wine Coolers – Solid Door100% Reach-In, Roll-In & Pass-Through Refrigerators – Transparent Door53% Milk or Beverage Coolers – Transparent Door62%/71%

25. Share of Existing RTF Baseline Freezer Models Above Proposed Revised RTF Baselines Product Class Revised Baseline Reach-In, Roll-In & Pass-Through Freezers – Solid Door63% Reach-In, Roll-In & Pass-Through Freezers – Transparent Door26% Ice Cream Freezers – Solid Door76% Ice Cream Freezers –Transparent Door100%

26. Share of Existing RTF Baseline Refrigerator/Freezer Models Above Proposed Revised RTF Baselines Product Class Revised Baseline Reach-In, Roll-In & Pass-Through Refrigerator/Freezers – Solid Door96% Reach-In, Roll-In & Pass-Through Refrigerator/Freezers – Transparent Door24%

27. Share of Models Meeting RTF Baseline Efficiency That Would Qualify for Alternative Efficiency Improvement Levels Appliance Type10% Better15% Better Milk Milk or Beverage Cooler w/Solid Doors or Beverage Cooler w/Solid Doors 44%32% Milk or Beverage Cooler w/Transparent Doors29% Reach-In, Roll-In & Pass-Through Refrigerators w/Solid Doors37%19% Reach-In, Roll-In, Pass-Through & Undercounter Refrigerators w/Transparent doors 27%23% Undercounter Refrigerator or Wine Cooler w/Solid Doors35% Qualify for Energy Star Ice Cream Freezers w/Solid Doors72%38% Ice Cream Freezers w/Transparent Doors53%29% Reach-In, Roll-In & Pass-Through Freezers w/Solid Doors26%22% Reach-In, Roll-In & Pass-Through Freezers w/Transparent doors 75%67% Reach-In, Roll-In & Pass-Through Refrigerator-Freezers w/Solid Doors 89%