Download presentation
1
Canadian Chartered Banks – Example of RBC
Cora Wong Boerge Hernes Lutz Firnkorn Thursday, 17 March 2005
2
Overview Structure of Industry Royal Bank of Canada
Risk and Risk Management Use of Derivatives Stock Compensation Plans Capital Requirements Summary
3
Chartered Banks A type of financial institution
Take deposits, issue personal and corporate loans, and invest in marketable securities Schedule I Banks Schedule II Banks Schedule III Banks Schedule I bank- widely held, domestic Canadian bank chartered by act of Parliament or letters patent of the Ministry of Finance to conduct banking as defined in the Bank Act Schedule II bank- closely held, authorized to conduct banking, most are subsidiaries of non-Canadian FIs Schedule III bank- Branch of foreign bank, can only take wholesale deposits
4
Chartered Banks (Cont.)
Mature industry Consolidating but highly competitive Traditional division into 4 Pillars Banks Trust Companies Insurance Companies Investment Dealers Now own each other and cross-sell each others’ services moving towards a universal banking system
5
Chartered Banks (Cont.)
19 domestic banks, 29 foreign bank subsidiaries, 22 foreign branches Industry dominated by “Big 6” Royal Bank of Canada Bank of Montreal Canada Imperial Bank of Commerce National Bank of Canada Scotia Bank Toronto-Dominion Bank
6
Chartered Banks (Cont.)
Big 6 hold over 92% of total assets in industry Canada’s Schedule I Banks= Big 6 Laurentian Bank of Canada Canadian Western Bank 11 other domestic banks
7
Regulatory Environment
The Bank Act Central Bank The Bank of Canada Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI) Canada Deposit Insurance Corporation (CDIC) Bank Act- All banks incorporated under bank Act , sets out structure, powers standards, method of incorporation and dissolution of banks, each have limited life (sunset clause). Traditionally limits each Bank Act’s life to 10 yrs so gov’t have to pay periodic attention to changes in banking industry, reset to 5 yrs, now moving towards ongoing assessment and change Bank of Canada takes deposits from and make loans to the clearing Fis, Sell T-bills and places gov’t deposits with Fis on daily basis. lies at center of payments system, fiscal agent for federal gov’t by shifting gov’t balances, have control over interest rates and money supply Requires detailed periodic reports from Fis Lender of last resort for Fis facing liquidity crisis OSFI- Regulating and supervising all Fis, acts for CDIC in conducting bank audits and coordinates with provincial securities commissions and FI regulators Set capital adequacy, accounting, auditing, and board-of-director responsibility standards CDIC- insure retail deposits (up to $60,000 per account) of member Fis, all deposit-taking institutions legally must be CDIC members, receives insurance premiums from members, delegates regular supervisory function to OSFI, only becomes actively involved when FI in danger of being unable to repay depositors
8
Regulation in Global Context
Bank for International Settlements (BIS) Basel Committee on banking Supervision International group of banking supervisors Basel II Revision of 1988 Basel Capital Accord (Basel I) BIS- Owned by various central banks, effecting payments between central banks, arrange periodic meetings among central bankers Formulated Basel II 3-pillar approach, offers a new set of standards for establishing minimum capital requirements for banking organizations worldwide (Pillar 1). Sets standards for the supervisory review process (Pillar 2) and for disclosure practices (Pillar 3).
9
Royal Bank of Canada Schedule I Bank
Canada’s largest bank as measured by assets and market capitalization 1300 domestic locations 40 offices in Caribbean Branches in more than 30 other countries around the world
10
Royal Bank of Canada
11
Net Income 2004 - Geographic Segment
12
Net Income 2004 - Business Segment
13
RBC- Products Offered Divided into 5 business segments RBC Banking
RBC Investments RBC Insurance RBC Capital Markets RBC Global Services
14
RBC- Banking Serves individuals, small and medium-sized business, and mid-market commercial clients Financial planning and advising on deposit accounts, investments, mutual funds, credit and debit cards, business and personal loans, residential and commercial mortgages RBC Royal Bank, RBC Centura, RBC Mortgage, RBC Builder Finance, RBC Royal Bank of Canada
15
RBC- Insurance Creditor, life, health, travel, home, auto and reinsurance products and services Offered through telephone, brokers, travel agents, the sales force and the internet
16
RBC- Investments Wealth management services
Brokerage, financial planning, investment counseling, personal trust, private banking, investment management products and services RBC Investments, RBC Dain Rauscher, RBC Global Private Banking
17
RBC- Capital Markets Wholesale financial services to large corporations, government and institutions
18
RBC- Global Services Specialized transaction processing services to corporations and institutions Global custody, investment administration, correspondent banking, cash management, payments, trade finance
19
Royal Bank of Canada A bank is exposed to a lot of different types of risks, and it needs a good organizational structure to control these risks. The RBC’s main purpose of having risk management is to build and secure the shareholders value. The risk management groups work in partnership with each business segment This is to try and measure, monitor and manage all the risk that the bank is exposed to Reports goes all the way up to the board of directors who can make appropriate strategic decisions based on their risk exposure
20
Stock Price 2004-Today
21
Stock Price 2004-Today
22
Economic Capital Average Economic Capital by Risk Type [2004]
Economic capital is the RBC management’s estimate of the amount of common equity required to underpin all their risks. Based on desired solvency and to maintain their current rating. The total EC takes into account the diversification benefits between differnt business segments and types of risks These benefits are also used in the calculation of the return to equity for each business segment This chart shows the proportions of EC for each risk type in 2004 (unchanged from 2003) Credit risk is the biggest Goodwill and intengibles large due to US aquisitions over the last several years
23
The Risk Pyramid Risk Pyramid
Used as a tool to identify and assess risk across the organization Risks are shown within the pyramid according to the level of control and influence that they can exert to mitigate or manage each specific risk type We have focused on the 5 risks at the bottom the most controlable types of frisk
24
Credit Risk Definition: Risk of default on given loans
Credit risk management: Credit scoring models For consumer and small business credit Applicant scoring model Behavioral scoring model For commercial and corporate clients Risk limits Credit derivative contracts Loan sales Its the type of risk that demands the most of their regulatory capital through Basel requirements Credit risk: Risk of loosing money due to a counterparty‘s inability to fulfill its payment obligations Credit risk management: Started todays risk measurement method in 2002 has decreased loss on loans They are using credit scoring models For cunsumer and small business loans Applicant scoring is used to anylize the credit history and present economic situation of new borrowers to determined the risk of loan default Behavioural scoring is used to analize allready made loans For commercial and corporate clients Industry sector trends Market competiveness Company strategy Financial strenght Access to funds Financial management And other risks facing the organization So when the RBC tries to manage its credit risk it has to monitor the risk of all its customers Risk limits is diversifying. Ex.: make sure their not overexposed to one sector or geographic area Diversifying is still their main activity on minimizing credit risk Regularly reporting for individiual loans concern, monitor or good. 4% of consumer and small business portfolio was concern at year end 2004 Reports on whole portfolios To monitor shifts in portfolio indicated as declining, stable or improving These reports are ment to give the risk managers an early warning so that actions can be made to prevent losses They also use credit derivative contracts to reduce risk on portions of their portfolio (in 2004 a position to cover $1 billion in credit risk exposure was in place) Loan sales they sell of any loans that no longer satisfy their requirements. Risk reward profiles and borrower ratings ($6B was sold off in 2004)
25
Market Risk Definition: Loss due to environmental changes
Types of market risk: Equity risk Foreign exchange rate and commodity price risk Interest rate risk Debt specific risk Credit spread risk Market risk management: VaR Sensitivity analyses Stress tests Market risk risk of loss that results from changes in interest rates, foreign exchange rates, equity prices and commodity prices Different components of market risk; Equity risk Risk of impact on earnings caused by movements in individual equity prices and in the level of the stockmarket Exposed through investment banking activities (buying and selling equities) Through other trading activities such as offering tailored derivative products to clients, arbitrage trading and propriatary trading Foreign exchange rate and commodity price risk Potential adverse impact on earnings and economic value due to currency rate and commodity price movements and volatilities Through their proprietary positions they are exposed to the spot and forward exchange market, derivatives markets and commodities markets Interest rate risk Most of their holdings in financial instruments gives exposure to interest rate risk Debt specific risk Used to be included in interest rate risk prior to 2004 Risk exposure due to creditworthiness and credit rating of issuers of bonds and money market instruments, or the names underlying credit derivatives Credit spread risk Risk from changes in credit spread associated with issuers of bonds and money market instruments or the names underlying credit derivatives They are exposed to debt specific and credit spread risk through their positions in bonds, money market instruments and credit derivatives Credit derivatives are used to manage credit risk, but results in a increased market risk! Monitoring and managing Market Risk Have their own Market Risk Group which operates independently from trading operations It is responible for daily monitoring of their market risk exposure. To do so they use: Value at Risk Give a worst case loss expectation over a period of time They use a 99% confidence interval model The VaR for 2004 showed an average of $8M for Equity, $2M for Forex and commodity, $9M for interest rate and $1M for debt Added up is $20M, but total was only $13M. This has to do with their diversification strategy Sensitivity analyzis Measures the impact of small changes in interest rates, forex, and other risk factors Stress tests Measures the impact of extreme market changes, such as political and economical events. The market risk group report to senior management about adverse trends or positions
26
Liquidity Risk Definition: Not to be able to meet financial commitments as they fall due Liquidity risk management Structural liquidity risk management Tactical liquidity management Contingent liquidity risk management Funding strategy Credit ratings Liquidity risk the risk of not going to generate or obtain sufficient cash to meet their commitments as they fall due Liquidity management Protecting their capital, maintaining market confidence and ensuring they have the cash to expand into profitable business opportunities. The liquidity risk management is divided into 3 different groups Structural liquidity risk management Monitoring the balance sheet and looking for mismatch in maturities in assets and liabilities Use a cash capital model to compare their illiquid assets to their funding This is ment to make sure they can still pay their commitments even if they for instance suffer an unexpected withdrawal by the depositors Tactical liquidity risk management Adresses their day-to-day funding requirements and is managed by imposing limits on net fund outflows They do a scenario analysis to determine their need of cash. Then the mentioned limits are adjusted acordingly. Contingent liquidity risk management In this part they have action plans that would be implemented in case of general market disruptions or adverse economic developments that would jeopardize their ability to meet their commitments They use 4 different market scenarios of varying duration and severity to see what these action plans should be A liquidity crisis team meets regularly to review, test and update the action plans and consider the need to implement them in view of recent developments in Canada and globally They have a pool of segregated and unencumbered marketable securities, which in the implementation of their action plans would be sold off in order to restore their liquidity Funding strategy As for the credit risk, diversification is their most important tool in managing liquidity risk Diversification expands funding flexibility, minimizing funding consentration and dependency and also generally lowers financing costs Credit ratings Thier ability to access unsecured funding markets and to engage in certain collateralized business activities on a cost-effective basis is primarily dependent on their credit rating. They say that a minor downgrade in their rating would not effect their funding access. However a major downgrade in their rating would influence their funding access. They therefor have an action plan that would be implemented to restore their financial strenght and rating. THEY DON‘T SAY WHAT THE PLAN ARE!
27
Insurance Risk Definition: Risk associated with design and underwriting of insurance policies Sources of insurance risk Product design risk Product pricing risk Insurance underwriting risk Insurance risk management Experience studies Scenario testing Diversification Reinsurance Insurance risk RBC has insurance risk cause they have a an insurance company 3 main sources of insurance risk Product design risk Product pricing risk Comes from differences in assumptions made in pricing the insurance contract and the actual expence Greater for long term insurance because they can not adjust the premiums the same way as in the short term contracts Managed through experience studies and scenario testing, actuarial science They keep a portion of the premiums on the balance sheet so they can adjust for misestimations Insurance underwriting risk Is the mis-selection of risks to be insured or incorrect expected amount of claims to be made in the future This is managed by diversification and reinsurance They monitor every insurance business and rate them in 3 categories; concern, monitor or good. In 2004 none were rated concern. They also monitor market trends and give the different insurance portfolios 3 different categories; declining, stable or improving.
28
Operational Risk Definition: Relates directly or indirectly to inadequate or failed processes, technology, and human performance or from external events Operational risk management framework: Risk and Control Self-Assessment (RCSA) Loss Event Database (LED) Key Risk Indicators (KRIs) Operational risk: Its the risk of direct or indirect loss resulting from inadequate or failed processes, technology, and human performance or from external events. The RBC experienced two notable operational losses in 2004 from a failure in their computer systems. To monitor and control this risk they have developed an; Operational Risk Management Framework Risk and Control Self-Assessment Every small division throughout the organization is responible for determining their operational risk. If the exposure is to big they have to identify the root causes and agree on an action plan and timeline Loss Event Database They collect information of every loss exceding $ due to operational risk in a sentralized database. They then use this to better understand the root causes of operational failures, hoping this will make them more capable of managing operational risk. Key Risk Indicators Are used to assist in recognizing and addressing their operational risk exposure and potential losses.
29
Off Balance Sheet Risk Definition: Items that don't occur or not with the full amount on the balance sheet Derivatives Special Purpose Entities Often not consolidated, they are also used as vehicles to take over risk Undertaken normally for Risk, Capital and/or funding management purposes Guarantees Cause Market, Credit and Liquidity Risk Exposure Off balance sheet risk arrangements pp Page 68/69 and 104 SPE not employeesl, one purpose Guarantees Maximum potential amount of future payments (important or not may be a good exampl, compare it to cash position/Short term assets or all assets Maximum amount of future payments p. 104
30
The Risk Pyramid Risk Pyramid
Used as a tool to identify and assess risk across the organization Risks are shown within the pyramid according to the level of control and influence that they can exert to mitigate or manage each specific risk type We have focused on the 5 risks at the bottom the most controlable types of frisk
31
Derivative types Interest Rate derivatives
Foreign exchange Derivatives Credit Derivatives Equity Derivatives Other Page 106/107 Whole range of derivatives Interest Rate derivatives – interest rate futures and forwards and swaps and options – obligation to buy or sell interest rate Foreign exchange Derivatives - futures and forwards and swaps and options – exchange one currency for another Credit Derivatives – over the counter contracts or swaps – transfer credit risk from one party to another Equity Derivatives - futures and forwards and swaps and options – equity index, basket of stock or single stock Other – metal, commodity – both OTC and exchange market – certain warrents and loan commitments that meet the derivative definition are in there as well
32
Derivative types (cont.)
For sale and trading Sales to clients, those can then hedge against risks Trading involves market making, positioning and arbitrage activities Also used for hedging Fair Value Hedge Cash Flow Hedge Hedge of Net Investment in foreign operations Economical Hedge Off balance sheet risk arrangements pp Pqage 80 Maximum amount of future payments p. 104 Page 107 They use basically interest rate swaps to hedge Derivative related credit risk (see Note 23) Sales is structuring and marketing of derivatives
33
Derivative types (cont.)
34
Limits for stock holdings
Bank officers are given three years to achieve these minimum stock holdings and newly employed officers are given five years.
35
Remunerations Stock Options /SAR (Stock appreciation rights)
Executives Employees Employee share ownership plan Deferred shares units DSUs Performance based deferred shares
36
Stock Option overview May be compare to current stock price
Exercisable 41-29 (kurs) * 15 * 1000 = =165 million transfer von alten an neue Bei shares outstanding =25 cent pro share weniger = 0,25/29 = 1%
37
Influence on EPS Pretty subjective (we will buy x back)
Ignore Time value (not“in the money“) Outstanding are Then EPS 4.13$
38
Equity & Regulatory Requirements
Share capital Economic capital : Target Equity Level for Rating Regulatory capital Tier 1 4% / Tier 2 8% Basel II from 2007 on requires a more detailed rating and risk access system Page 96/97 Page 58 Page 63/64 Kind of „external risk management“, to avoid that the bank takes willingly or unwillingly too much risk Balance sheet Depends on the risk taken by the bank What are the requirements? Analysis of the structure (tier one/two)
39
Regulatory Requirements-Risk Adjusted Assets
40
Regulatory Requirements-Equity
I have to look up the requirements (like tier 2 <= 1,5*tier1 etc)
41
Summary Bank are risk takers Many sources of Risk
Highly complex Risk Management Align risk appetite and corporate strategy
42
Thank you for your attention
Similar presentations
© 2025 SlidePlayer.com. Inc.
All rights reserved.