Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
1
Texas Large Commercial and Industrial Standard Offer Program Brown Bag Teleconference May 23, 2003 1
2
Overview of Today’s Topic Over $20 million in incentive funds remain available for qualifying energy efficiency projects through Texas’ Large Commercial and Industrial Standard Offer Programs! 2
3
Outline Brief overview –Jay Zarnikau, Frontier Associates LLC Waltz Across Texas –An Introduction to each of the service areas by program managers at each of the utilities Project Sponsor Eligibility –Billy Berny, AEP Eligible Measures –Doug Maxey, Xcel Energy 3
4
Outline cont. Application Process –George Smith, CenterPoint Energy Measurement and Verification –Mike Stockard, Oncor Example Incentive Calculations –Karen Radosevich, Entergy 4
5
TEXAS Electric Retail Service Area Map Investor-Owned Utilities Legend AEP Texas Central Company (AEP - Central) El Paso Electric Company (EPE) Entergy Gulf States, Inc. (EGS) CenterPoint Energy (CenterPoint) Xcel Energy (Xcel) AEP Southwestern Electric Power Company (SWEPCO) Texas-New Mexico Power Company (TNMP) Oncor (Oncor) AEP Texas North Company (AEP - North) EPE Oncor TNMP Xcel CenterPoint SWEPCO Oncor TNMP EGS WTU TNMP Xcel AEP-North AEP- North AEP-North AEP-Central April 2003 5
6
Entergy - Gulf States, Inc. Karen Radosevich 6
7
Entergy - Gulf States, Inc. Serves 350,000 customers in Southeast Texas Industrial (Beaumont & Port Arthur) Residential (The Woodlands & Conroe) Goals and Budget Goal2003 Budget Remaining Funds 3.1 MW $ 1,305,940 $ 1,239,549 Contact Information: Terry Swan (409) 981-3245 tswan@entergy.com 7
8
Xcel Energy Doug Maxey 8
9
Xcel Energy Serve 269,000 customers on the high plains of Texas –Amarillo- Lubbock Goals and Budget Goal 2003 Budget Remaining Funds 3.1 MW $ 1,305,940 $ 1,239,549 Contact Information: 806-378-2887 doug.maxey@xcelenergy.com 9
10
Texas-New Mexico Power Tony Thompson 10
11
Texas-New Mexico Power Goals and Budgets Goal2003 Budget Remaining Funds 0.64 MW$ 240,000 $ 192,000 Contact Information: 817-377-5579 tthompson@tnpe.com 11
12
AMERICAN ELECTRIC POWER Billy Berny AEP TEXAS CENTRAL AEP TEXAS NORTH AEP SWEPCO AMERICAN ELECTRIC POWER 12
13
American Electric Power Program Incentive Budgets Go to www.aepefficiency.com for program details and application procedures. FOR MORE INFO... Total Incentive Budget Available Funds as of April 28, 2003 based on approved Contracts AEP - Texas Central $ 2,587,279 $ 2,083,621 AEP – SWEPCO $ 589,500 $ 589,500 AEP - Texas North $ 596,841 $ 596,841 $ 3,773,620 $ 3,269,962 Contact Information: 325-674-7293 bgberny@aep.com 13
14
CenterPoint Energy George Smith 14
15
CenterPoint Energy Statistics Houston metropolitan area 1.8 million customers System peak demand of 15,000 MW Cities: Houston, Galveston, Baytown, Richmond/Rosenberg Load is 40% residential, 30% commercial, 30% industrial 15
16
CenterPoint Goals and Budgets Goal2003 Budget Remaining Funds 10.2 MW$ 6,252,000 $ 2,600,000 Contact Information: 713-207-3488 george.smith@centerpointenergy.com 16
17
Oncor Mike Stockard 17
18
Oncor Service Area Statistics Provides distribution service to 2.64 million premises. Provides distribution service to 370 cities in 92 counties. Serves: Dallas, Fort Worth, Tyler, Waco, Midland, Odessa, Lufkin, Temple, Round Rock Peak system demand of 22,000 MW 2004 Incentive Budget - $ 17.3 million Contact Information: 214-486-5626 mstocka1@oncorgroup.com 18
19
AEP - www.aepefficiency.com Entergy - www.ENTERGYefficiency.com Oncor - www.oncorgroup.com/efficiency CenterPoint - centerpointefficiency.com Texas-New Mexico Power - www.tnpeefficiency.com Xcel Energy - www.Xcelenergyefficiency.com Websites for Specific Utilities 19
20
Quick Overview Jay Zarnikau Frontier Associates LLC 20
21
Background and Introduction Texas Senate Bill 7 requires distribution utilities in Texas to meet 107 of their load growth by offering and administering energy efficiency programs. Each of the States affected distribution utilities offer a Large Commercial and Industrial Standard Offer Program to help satisfy this goal. The legislation requires incentive programs to be market neutral and non-discriminatory, so the C&I Standard Offer Program is available to all of the utilities distribution customers on a “first come, first served” basis. 21
22
Standard Offer Program Program administrator (electric utility) offers set incentive payment to participants for each kWh or kW saved through installation and operation of an energy efficiency measure. Program administrator signs a standard contract with participants outlining their responsibilities under the program. Applications considered on per-project basis; first- come, first-served. Number of participants limited only by available incentive dollars. Project Sponsor and customer determines efficiency measures to be installed—program measure/technology neutral. Contact Information: 512-372-8778 jayz@frontierassoc.com 22
23
Project Sponsor Eligibility Billy Berny AEP TEXAS CENTRAL AEP TEXAS NORTH AEP SWEPCO AMERICAN ELECTRIC POWER 23
24
Program Administrator (Utility) Responsibilities Perform outreach to energy services community. Review project applications. Sign contracts with Project Sponsors. Perform pre- and post-installation inspections. Make incentive payments to project sponsors. Report results to Public Utility Commission. 24
25
Who Can Be a Project Sponsor? Equipment distributors or manufacturers Energy service companies Community based organizations Mechanical or lighting contractors Any other entity providing energy efficiency services Large commercial or industrial energy consumers Project sponsors must meet standard qualifications (work experience, financial capability, insurance, proper licensing, etc.) 25
26
Market and sign contracts with individual Utility transmission and distribution customers Apply for funding from program Sign Standard Agreement with Utility Design, procure, and install energy efficiency measures Measure and verify energy savings Sponsor Responsibilities 26
27
Participants must have the following: Evidence of good credit rating (10K or Financial Statement) List of references Must hold all applicable licenses Evidence of all building permits Evidence of necessary insurance Project Sponsor Qualifications 27
28
Eligible Measures Doug Maxey 28
29
Produces measurable demand and energy savings Retrofit measures, in most cases Useful life is greater than ten years Permanently installed Fuel switching from electric to non-electric only Exceeds minimum efficiency standards Measure Eligibility 29
30
Constant air volume to VAV conversion Chiller replacement Packaged cooling unit replacement Fan and pump VSD and efficiency projects Lighting efficiency and controls Air cooling and refrigeration compressor projects Industrial process measures Eligible Measures 30
31
Measures with life less than 10 years Removable measures (generally includes plug loads) Exterior lighting Cogeneration or self generation (except renewables) Fuel switching to electric New construction (some exceptions) Measures that require no capital investment Measures that receive incentives from other Utility programs Thermal energy storage (unless part of a larger project) Ineligible Measures 31
32
Project requirements: Utility T&D customers Total demand at project site(s) is at least 100 kW Minimum savings per project: 20 kW Similar customers/sites may be aggregated to meet this requirement Project Eligibility 32
33
Any number of project sites may be submitted as a project if they are similar. Contingent on having the same: Sponsor Measure Occupancy schedule Functional use Energy consumption patterns M&V Plan Project Aggregation 33
34
Application Process George Smith 34
35
Sponsor submits one Initial Application (IA) per project First IA includes Sponsor qualifications Identifies customers and intended measures (20 kW savings minimum) Estimated kW/kWh savings and incentive payments Approximately 15 day review period Utility reviews the IA for participant and measure eligibility Upon IA approval, Utility reserves funds for the project for a limited time. IA FA IR SR Contract Initial Application 35
36
Sponsor has up to 100 days from IA approval for submittal of FA (varies by utility) Information required in the Final Application (FA) Detailed project description Savings calculations and incentive estimates Equipment surveys (use standard forms) Proposed M&V plan Site plan and 1-line drawings where applicable Agreement between Project Sponsor and Host Customer IA FA IR SR Contract Submittal 2: Final Application 36
37
One FA submitted per project FA forms available on Web site Utility reviews each FA Fulfillment of submittal requirements Technical review of measure savings and M&V plan Utility conducts a pre-installation inspection Approximately 45 day review FA approval IA FA IR SR Contract Final Application (cont.) 37
38
Includes project specific information Estimated kW & kWh savings and incentives Approved M&V plan Security deposit may be required Installation of approved measures may proceed after FA approval, after both parties sign the C&I SOP Agreement, and pre-installation inspection is completed IA FA IR SR Contract Agreement (Contract) 38
39
Due within 30 days of completion for all projects Submitted information similar to FA, except: Reports actual retrofit equipment installed Updates savings calculations, incentive estimates and M&V Plan to reflect as-built condition Includes Host Customer certification that measures were indeed installed IA FA IR SR Contract Submittal 3: Installation Report 39
40
Utility reviews each Installation Report (IR) Review of final savings estimates and M&V plan Post-installation inspection to confirm equipment installation Approximately 45 day review period Upon IR approval, Utility pays Project Sponsor 40% of contracted incentive IA FA IR SR Contract Installation Report (cont.) 40
41
Submitted after M&V activities completed Provides actual project kW & kWh savings Submittal will include Raw data collected in M&V activities Analysis used to calculate savings Actual savings achieved Review period approximately 45 days Remaining incentive payment based on actual savings achieved (up to 60% of contracted amount) IA FA IR SR Contract Submittal 4: Savings Report 41
42
Measurement and Verification Mike Stockard 42
43
Measure-specific M&V guidelines Stipulated values for data such as operating hours, fixture wattages and equipment efficiencies Pre-derived savings calculations for some measures Minimize project sponsor M&V costs and utility administration, while producing justifiable energy savings Streamlined M&V Procedures 43
44
Appropriate M&V Approach depends mainly on: –Type of retrofit and equipment –Operational predictability –Project complexity Main categories of M&V for C&I program: –Deemed savings (in select applications) –Simplified M&V methods –Full M&V methods –Alternate M&V methods may be proposed by Sponsor, but must adhere to IPMVP and be approved by Utility C&I Program M&V 44
45
Simplified Lighting Example Typical Small Office Building Sponsor submits full lighting survey, detailing existing and proposed fixtures 3,760 stipulated operating hours for office buildings 80% coincidence factor for office buildings 45
46
Savings Calculations Lighting Demand Savings: 38.6 kW – 18.7 kW = 19.9 kW Interactive Demand Savings: 19.9 kW * 0.10 = 2.0 kW Total Demand Savings: (19.9 kW + 2.0 kW) * 0.80 = 17.7 kW Lighting Energy Savings: 19.9 kW * 3,760 hrs = 74,824 kWh Interactive Energy Savings: 74,824 kWh * 0.05 = 3,741 kWh Total Demand Savings: 74,824 kWh + 3,741 kWh = 78,565 kWh Simplified Lighting Example (cont.) 46
47
Chiller Replacement in Office Building Retrofit Description:1-for-1 300 Ton Water-Cooled Centrifugal Chiller Replacement Existing Chiller Efficiency:COP=5.0 (0.70 kW/ton) New Chiller Efficiency:COP=6.6 (0.53 kW/ton) Baseline Chiller Efficiency (ASHRAE 90.1-1989): COP=5.2 (0.68 kW/ton) Spot kW measurement of existing chiller at peak conditions: 135 kW 12-months post-retrofit measured chiller kWh: 334,200 kWh Simplified Cooling Example 47
48
Savings Calculations Simplified Cooling Example (cont.) 48
49
Baseline must account for minimum state and federal standards Standard forms must be used M&V reports must be complete and properly documented before any payments will be made “Service quality” must be maintained For example - lighting levels Metering Calibration required All collected data must be submitted with reports Must be adequate to capture full range of operating conditions General M&V Rules 49
50
Example Incentive Calculations Karen Radosevich 50
51
Pricing for programs is based on a cost effectiveness standard Based on avoided cost of a new gas turbine: –$400 per kW capacity –2.5 cents per kWh off-peak energy Incentives for large commercial and industrial projects can be up to 35% of avoided cost. Incentives vary by utility: –$150 to $200 per kW reduction –5.0 to 6.9 cents per annual kWh saved Lighting Cap -- kW and kWh savings derived from lighting measures are capped at 65% of the total savings. Load Factor Cap -- Utilities may place a limit on the ratio of kWh payment to kW payment. 51
52
Example 1 - Simple Calculation A commercial HVAC project saves 25 kW of summer peak demand and 50,000 annual kWh. 25 kW x $175/kW + 50,000 kWh x $0.06/kWh = $7,375 52
53
Example 2 -- Load Factor Cap An industrial variable-speed motor retrofit saves 20 kW of summer peak demand and 150,000 annual kWh. The unadjusted incentive payment for this project would be: (20 x$175) + (150,000 x $0.06) = $12,500 The utility is utilizing a load factor cap that limits combined kW and kWh payment to $600 per kW. 20 x $600 = $12,000 This project would be subject to the load factor cap. Incentive would not exceed $12,000. 53
54
Example 3 - Lighting Cap A commercial office project saves 15 kW and 60,000 kWh from lighting measures and 4 kW and 8,000 from HVAC. % of kW savings from lighting = 15/19 = 79% % of kWh savings from lighting = 60,000/68,000=88% Adjusted kW = (19 x 0.65) + 4 = 16.35 kW Adjusted kWh = (68,000 x 0.65) + 8,000 = 52,200 kWh (16.35 x $175) + (52,200 x $0.06) = $5,993 54
55
In conclusion… A new generation of energy efficiency programs are up and running. For energy services companies, equipment distributors and manufacturers, installers of energy-efficient equipment, and others, these programs provide new business opportunities. The state’s utilities and the PUCT are counting on your ideas and efforts to help ensure that we meet our goal for energy efficiency! 55
56
Questions? 56
Similar presentations
© 2025 SlidePlayer.com. Inc.
All rights reserved.