Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Ethical Theories High-level account of how questions about morality should be addressed. Similar to engineering models? V=IR: a tool to solve many engineering.

Similar presentations


Presentation on theme: "Ethical Theories High-level account of how questions about morality should be addressed. Similar to engineering models? V=IR: a tool to solve many engineering."— Presentation transcript:

1 Ethical Theories High-level account of how questions about morality should be addressed. Similar to engineering models? V=IR: a tool to solve many engineering problems. V=IR is not a law of nature; neither is F=ma: think about scale Ethical theories also do not describe the world – only some good answers to moral dilemmas  Ethical problems are not clear and people and society are unpredictable and messy Many ethical theories to choose from

2 Some traditional ethical theories
Consequentialist: Evaluate acts, policies and institutions according to consequences. Right action is the one that has the best consequences  Utilitarianism: Only happiness is good in itself. Everything else is a means to happiness. (pain, suffering == - happiness) An act is right if it tends to increase the sum of human happiness; wrong if reverse. (Or RULE utilitarianism … ) Most decision-making strategies and models originate with utilitarianism: cost-benefit analysis, game theory, risk-benefit analysis  What is the chief problem these theories face? Various forms: ethical egotism, nationalism, (altruism? – really maximizes total happiness? Gift of the Magi (O. Henry))

3 Other traditional ethical theories
Deontological theories  Certain actions are right or wrong regardless of consequences Immanuel Kant: Follow universal principles that require respect for persons – absolute value of persons. Categorical Imperative: (for example, truth telling) Act only according to that maxim that you could at the same time will to become a universal law Kant formulated DUTY ethics – saying how persons have the DUTY to act Another deontological theory: Theory of rights (of persons). E.g. right to life, right of choice. John Locke: natural rights – life, liberty, property. We exchange our natural state of anarchy for the liberty and security of the society – social contract.

4 Kant’s Perfect and Imperfect Duties
When violating a “maxim” would, under the Categorical Imperative (first form): lead to a logical contradiction (if universalized), we have a “perfect duty” not to violate the maxim (example – universalizing stealing  meaninglessness of “property”) lead to an undesirable condition (if universalized), we have an “imperfect duty” not to violate the maxim (example – universalizing not helping others except for one’s own good  wouldn’t ever want to ask anyone for help one couldn’t then repay, so we SHOULD help others without regard for our own repayment, when possible)

5 A Second Form of Kant’s Categorical Imperative
"Act in such a way that you treat humanity, whether in your own person or in the person of any other, always at the same time as an end and never simply as a means" -- Kant, Immanuel; trans. Ellington, J.W. [1785] (1993), p.36

6 KCI – Third Formulation
"Therefore, every rational being must so act as if he were through his maxim always a legislating member in the universal kingdom of ends." Ibid., p. 43


Download ppt "Ethical Theories High-level account of how questions about morality should be addressed. Similar to engineering models? V=IR: a tool to solve many engineering."

Similar presentations


Ads by Google