Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

LIGO-G030251-01-M Advanced LIGO Cost, Schedule and Management Gary H Sanders NSF Review of Advanced LIGO Caltech, June 11, 2003.

Published by Modified over 9 years ago

Similar presentations

Presentation on theme: "LIGO-G030251-01-M Advanced LIGO Cost, Schedule and Management Gary H Sanders NSF Review of Advanced LIGO Caltech, June 11, 2003."— Presentation transcript:

1

2 LIGO-G030251-01-M Advanced LIGO Cost, Schedule and Management Gary H Sanders NSF Review of Advanced LIGO Caltech, June 11, 2003

3 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory2 Main Points Experienced LIGO Lab team has planned and estimated Advanced LIGO with the LSC LIGO Lab and LSC have formed a strong partnership Design and development process is already underway in a “project” setting Most of the elements of a formal project are in place Costs are estimated in detail Schedule planning is thorough and will support definition of the final negotiated project Performance measurement infrastructure is in place International partnerships are already being exercised Project Management Plan can be made definitive when financial commitments are complete

4 LIGO-G030251-01-M Organization

5 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory4 No change in structure required

6 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory5 A Development Project Across the LSC Since late 1999, we have planned the Advanced LIGO development program as if it was part of a construction project »Work Breakdown Structure »Cost estimate »Schedule »Management structure »Requirements documented and systems engineering and modeling »Design process established This “projectized” development program has been operating in a serious collaborative manner across the LSC »LSC Working Groups –Advanced detector configurations working group –Core optics working group –Laser working group –Suspensions working group

7 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory6 LIGO Organization & Support LIGO Laboratory MIT + Caltech ~170 people LIGO Scientific Collaboration 44 member institutions > 400 scientists U.S. National Science Foundation UK Germany Japan Russia India Spain Australia $ SCIENCE Detector R&D DESIGN CONSTRUCTION OPERATION Saulson

8 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory7 LSC “Project” Participation Lab and LSC scientists/engineers share in leadership roles in the project LSC working groups already coordinate progress in monthly meetings and at LSC face-to-face meetings LSC Executive Committee involved in discussions of all major design choices and decisions Advanced LIGO has become a shared Lab/LSC project

9 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory8 Advanced LIGO Resource Model Current FY2002 – FY2006 Cooperative Agreement »LIGO Lab operating resources provide staff and support for Advanced LIGO development through Final Design/prototype stage »LIGO Lab R&D resources support Advanced LIGO equipment, procurements, incremental staff This request supports fabrication and construction, and very little incremental staff for construction and installation »From MREFC or R&RA NSF accounts as NSF determines We assume LIGO Lab renewal Cooperative Agreement FY2007 – FY2011 supports staff and infrastructure support for fabrication, construction, installation, commissioning of Advanced LIGO LSC/international partner resources support their development programs International partner capital budgets support portions of the fabrication, construction, installation All of these elements are properly included in the plan shown at this review

10 LIGO-G030251-01-M Work Breakdown Structure (WBS)

11 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory10 l 1.0 Initial LIGO Construction l 2.0 LIGO Laboratory Operations l 3.0 LIGO Laboratory Advanced R&D l 4.0. Advanced LIGO Project (Advanced LIGO) »4.1. Facility Modifications (FAC) »4.2. Seismic Isolation Subsystem (SEI) »4.3. Suspension Subsystem (SUS) »4.4 Prestabilized Laser Subsystem (PSL) »4.5. Input Optics Subsystem (IO) »4.6. Core Optics Components (COC) »4.7. Auxiliary Optics Subsystem (AOS) »4.8. Interferometer Sensing and Controls Subsystem (ISC) »4.9. Data Acquisition, Diagnostics, Network & Supervisory Control (DAQ) »4.10. Support Equipment (SUP) »4.11. Advanced LIGO Construction Project Research and Development (R&D) »4.12. Data Analysis and Computing Subsystem (COMP) »4.13. Installation and Commissioning Task (INS) »4.14. Project Management (PM) Advanced LIGO WBS Based upon existing LIGO Laboratory WBS/account structure

12 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory11

13 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory12 Current status of Advanced LIGO organization – Org follows WBS Project Manager just hired

14 LIGO-G030251-01-M Project Planning

15 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory14 Basic Elements of Project Planning Are in Place Elements of the PMCS (EVMS) Estimates / Budget Generation Accounting / Procurement Planning, Scheduling, and Performance Measurement Doc. Control / QAQC / Change Requests ActualsChanges

16 LIGO-G030251-01-M Cost Estimate

17 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory16 Estimates Performed To a Standard Guidance provided to estimators on »Basis of Estimate (BOE) »Work Breakdown Structure (WBS) »Costing Methodology »Cost Database »Collection of Information »Confidence of Cost Estimate »Cost Book »Schedule Integration »Direct Labor Rates »Contract Labor »Risk Analysis »Risk Assessment Methodology »Escalation

18 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory17

19 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory18 Note: the value “40111” is common.

20 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory19 This value is used as a unique resource ID and populates the resource dictionary for planning. This value is used as a FTE value for making head counts and evaluating resource usage.

21 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory20

22 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory21

23 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory22

24 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory23

25 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory24

26 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory25

27 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory26

28 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory27 Activity Sheet Header

29 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory28 Activity Sheet Takeoff Area

30 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory29 Cost Extension Area

31 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory30 Risk and Cost Totals

32 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory31 Labor Summary (FTEs)

33 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory32

34 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory33

35 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory34

36 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory35 Summary (Base Year Estimate)

37 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory36 Total Cost Profile

38 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory37 Request Profile

39 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory38 Bottom Up and Top Down Staffing Model

40 LIGO-G030251-01-M Schedule

41 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory40 Level 1 Level 2 Level 3

42 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory41 Level 4

43 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory42 Level 5

44 LIGO-G030251-01-M Performance Measurement

45 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory44 Planning for Performance Measurement At what level do you cost load the schedule? »WBS Level is where we collect actual cost. »Cost Book Activity Sheet is where we load the estimate. »Schedule Activity level is where we measure progress that determines the earned value. Performance Evaluation is executed at the rollup level for the WBS. »BCWS – baseline plan »BCWP - performance »ACWP – actual costs »Schedule Variance »Cost Variance WBS Grouping { { { WBS Level Cost Book Activity Sheet Level Schedule Task Level

46 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory45 Planning for Performance Measurement

47 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory46 Planning for Performance Measurement

48 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory47 Planning for Performance Measurement

49 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory48 Progress Data Collection Primavera Project Planner Post Office. »A built in feature within the application creates a mail attachment that contains the activities to be updated. Excel spreadsheets can be easily imported.

50 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory49

51 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory50 Milestone Model

52 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory51 Major Milestones MilestoneDate at End of Quarter Per Calendar Year NSF Early Funding for Core Optics Available5 Apr 2004 NSF Funding for Advanced LIGO Construction Available4 Apr 2005 Installation begins at Livingston8 Mar 2007 Installation begins at Hanford15 Nov 2007 Commissioning begins at Livingston15 Jun 2009 Commissioning begins at Hanford30 Sep 2009 Livingston Operational6 Jan 2010 Hanford Operational22 Sep 2010

53 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory52

54 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory53

55 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory54

56 LIGO-G030251-01-M Support of PPARC Proposal

57 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory56 Real World Example – PPARC Proposal Support

58 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory57 PPARC Proposal Example Using the schedule, we coded the tasks that represent the collaborator’s scope. Using the cost book Access database, we cost loaded the schedule and generated cost profiles.

59 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory58 PPARC Proposal Example Using the cost loaded schedule, we exported the cost profile data to a spread sheet in base year dollars. Using MS Excel, we generated a cost profile by GB Fiscal Years and applied an escalation rate.

60 LIGO-G030251-01-M Partners and Management

61 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory60 Partners and Management Principal fiduciary management will come from the LIGO Laboratory Advanced LIGO will be implemented with full LSC participation Capital partners (UK GEO, German GEO, ACIGA) will have a role in the project management »Possible Institutional Board »Details to be worked out as commitments defined »Discussions between LIGO Lab and UK GEO/PPARC regarding nature and level of formal agreement Basic project management methods will follow the LIGO model

62 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory61 Summary Experienced LIGO Lab team has planned and estimated Advanced LIGO LIGO Lab and LSC have formed a strong partnership Design and development process is already underway in a “project” setting Most of the elements of a formal project are in place Costs are estimated in detail Schedule planning is thorough and will support definition of the final negotiated project Performance measurement infrastructure is in place International partnerships are already being exercised Project Management Plan can be made definitive when financial commitments are complete

63 LIGO-G030251-01-M LIGO Laboratory62 Advanced LIGO In Context LIGO construction is complete »NSF investment in LIGO now totals about $400 million »Construction cost $292 million »LIGO facilities represent ~ 2/3 of the construction investment and are intended to support successive detectors Initial LIGO detectors are operating and have carried out early scientific running »Initial LIGO should accomplish its sensitive observation goal by late 2006 Advanced LIGO development is defining the detailed design and retiring risks The experienced LIGO team will be ready to install Advanced LIGO in 2007 Observations for probable gravitational wave detection can commence in 2010

Download ppt "LIGO-G030251-01-M Advanced LIGO Cost, Schedule and Management Gary H Sanders NSF Review of Advanced LIGO Caltech, June 11, 2003."

Similar presentations

NSF Experience with Management of Research Infrastructure

NSF Experience with Management of Research Infrastructure
LIGO-G020279-00-M Advanced LIGO Construction Proposal Submission Gary Sanders LIGO Laboratory PAC 12 June 2002, Cambridge.

LIGO-G M Advanced LIGO Construction Proposal Submission Gary Sanders LIGO Laboratory PAC 12 June 2002, Cambridge.
Project Cost Management Estimation Budget Cost Control

Project Cost Management Estimation Budget Cost Control
Cost, Schedule & Funding Closeout Jan. 29-31 Joint DOE/NSF CD2/3a Review 1 DOE/NSF Review of the Dark Energy Survey (DES) Project SC 6/7 Cost, Schedule.

Cost, Schedule & Funding Closeout Jan Joint DOE/NSF CD2/3a Review 1 DOE/NSF Review of the Dark Energy Survey (DES) Project SC 6/7 Cost, Schedule.
LIGO-G030288-00-M LIGO Laboratory1 Adv. LIGO Program Management (PM) Plans, Schedule, Costs, Team Plan, Schedule Costs Team.

LIGO-G M LIGO Laboratory1 Adv. LIGO Program Management (PM) Plans, Schedule, Costs, Team Plan, Schedule Costs Team.
LIGO-G030287-00-M LIGO Laboratory1 Adv. LIGO Installation (INS) Plans, Schedule, Costs, Team Plan, Schedule Costs Team.

LIGO-G M LIGO Laboratory1 Adv. LIGO Installation (INS) Plans, Schedule, Costs, Team Plan, Schedule Costs Team.
Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory Who? Presented By: Bonnie Wooley.

Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory Who? Presented By: Bonnie Wooley.
LIGO-G010034-00-M Overview of LIGO R&D and Planning for Advanced LIGO Detectors David Shoemaker NSF Operations Review Hanford, 26 February 2001.

LIGO-G M Overview of LIGO R&D and Planning for Advanced LIGO Detectors David Shoemaker NSF Operations Review Hanford, 26 February 2001.
LIGO-G010242-00-D partial ADVANCED LIGO1 Development Plan R&D including Design through Final Design Review »for all long lead or high risk subsystems »LIGO.

LIGO-G D partial ADVANCED LIGO1 Development Plan R&D including Design through Final Design Review »for all long lead or high risk subsystems »LIGO.
LIGO-G030006-00-M GWIC16-Dec-02 LIGO Status Barry Barish GWIC 16-Dec-02.

LIGO-G M GWIC16-Dec-02 LIGO Status Barry Barish GWIC 16-Dec-02.
LIGO-G030557-00-M Status of LIGO Barry Barish PAC Meeting Caltech 3-June-04 Upper limits on known pulsar ellipticities.

LIGO-G M Status of LIGO Barry Barish PAC Meeting Caltech 3-June-04 Upper limits on known pulsar ellipticities.
LIGO-G060210-00-M April 5, 2006 Interferometer Sensing and Control (ISC) Cost and Schedule Breakout Presentation NSF Review of Advanced LIGO Project Richard.

LIGO-G M April 5, 2006 Interferometer Sensing and Control (ISC) Cost and Schedule Breakout Presentation NSF Review of Advanced LIGO Project Richard.
LIGO- GXXXXXX-XX-X Advanced LIGO Data & Computing Material for the breakout session NSF review of the Advanced LIGO proposal Albert Lazzarini Caltech,

LIGO- GXXXXXX-XX-X Advanced LIGO Data & Computing Material for the breakout session NSF review of the Advanced LIGO proposal Albert Lazzarini Caltech,
U.S. ATLAS Physics and Computing Budget and Schedule Review John Huth Harvard University DOE/NSF Review of U.S. ATLAS and CMS Computing Projects Brookhaven.

U.S. ATLAS Physics and Computing Budget and Schedule Review John Huth Harvard University DOE/NSF Review of U.S. ATLAS and CMS Computing Projects Brookhaven.
October 24, 2000Milestones, Funding of USCMS S&C Matthias Kasemann1 US CMS Software and Computing Milestones and Funding Profiles Matthias Kasemann Fermilab.

October 24, 2000Milestones, Funding of USCMS S&C Matthias Kasemann1 US CMS Software and Computing Milestones and Funding Profiles Matthias Kasemann Fermilab.
LIGO-G020514-00-P 1 Case Study of PMCS Implementation/Tools - Advanced LIGO An Example Of Implementation In Progress Prepared by Thomas Frey, CCC, PMP.

LIGO-G P 1 Case Study of PMCS Implementation/Tools - Advanced LIGO An Example Of Implementation In Progress Prepared by Thomas Frey, CCC, PMP.
NCSX Management Overview Hutch Neilson, NCSX Project Manager NCSX Conceptual Design Review Princeton, NJ May 23, 2002.

NCSX Management Overview Hutch Neilson, NCSX Project Manager NCSX Conceptual Design Review Princeton, NJ May 23, 2002.
LIGO-G060207-00-M May 31-June 2, 2006 Input Optics (IO) Cost and Schedule Breakout Presentation NSF Review of Advanced LIGO Project David Reitze UF.

LIGO-G M May 31-June 2, 2006 Input Optics (IO) Cost and Schedule Breakout Presentation NSF Review of Advanced LIGO Project David Reitze UF.
Introduction- Project Management By Ctrl+C & Ctrl+V 1.

Introduction- Project Management By Ctrl+C & Ctrl+V 1.
Software Project Management Lecture # 7. What are we studying today? Chapter 24 - Project Scheduling  Effort distribution  Defining task set for the.

Software Project Management Lecture # 7. What are we studying today? Chapter 24 - Project Scheduling  Effort distribution  Defining task set for the.

Similar presentations

Ads by Google