Download presentation
1
In Paris with You & Quickdraw
2
Both poems use figurative language to describe emotional feelings
‘Wounded’ love can cause emotional pain – violent metaphors are used ‘You’ve wounded me’ (Q) ‘‘I’m one of the talking wounded’ (Paris) Also...’blast me through the heart’ ‘pellet’ ‘silver bullets’ Extended metaphor in Quickdraw
3
In both poems, the language of suffering is used
‘hostage’ (P) – trapped, accepted his miserable circumstance- held hostage by ex partner. Lonely, fearful, powerless. He has trapped himself in memories. ‘Down on my knees’ – desperation, begging for what? Love? Another chance? Mercy? Both appear powerless but are not?
4
Both poets reject romantic cliches, and write amusingly about the experience of love
(Q) the extended metaphor of the gun fight is a comic device – it dramatises, fictionalises the domestic dispute. Over-exaggerating the scale and consequences – hilarious! Masks the real pain? (P) 1. amusing – different facets of speaker’s attitude ( angry and then more cooperative) 2. rejects cliched romantic break activities ‘Louvre’ etc . Use of colloquialism ‘sleazy..sodding’ contrasts romance – gritty and irreverent. Unromantic language
5
Both poems use the first person viewpoint and the second person address
(P) frequent assertion of ‘I’ ‘I’m in Paris..’ anaphora at end of poem – shows self-centredness? Spoken to the partner in Paris with him – direct and personal involvement for the reader. (Q) more even usage of ‘I ‘ and ‘you’ to show even battle and reciprocated aggression? ‘You’ve wounded me’ – accusative tone
6
In both poems, the theme of betrayal is explored
(P) – cynical speaker ‘Don’t talk to me of love’ implies former suffering? Unable to use the word ‘love’ and replaces it by ‘Paris’ (Q) – you’ve wounded me’ – been deliberately hurt – victim. When they thought they were part of same side.
7
Both poets use structural device to show closeness or separation
(Q) –line break ‘then blast me/through the heart’ the literal breaking of the line mimics the breaking of the relationship. Duffy subverts the conventional sonnet structure of 14 lines to create 16 – she challenges the idealised love that sonnets are supposed to portray. (P) –indented stanza changes the tone – slightly more honest? More considerate? SO the break in structure signifies a glimpse into his vulnerability?
8
Both poets reject a regular rhyme scheme
9
Timed essay on Monday 5th March
Compare how Duffy and Fenton present the themes of love, pain and conflict Timed essay on Monday 5th March You can create a plan and use it in the exam What are your targets from the last timed essay?
Similar presentations
© 2024 SlidePlayer.com. Inc.
All rights reserved.