1. Institute of Foresters
of Australia

2. Forest Management and the impact on Water Management

3. Science History Future

4. Forest Management and Water Management
All land is in a catchment
Warning: Science Content
All land is in a catchment
The water cycle is well understood.
Evaporation leads to atmospheric moisture that returns to the land as rain.
The land surface determines the fate of that rain and the amount of evaporation before the water reached streams and rivers.
Landscape level environments affect the water cycle.
Forest have a role at this scale in determining the amount of evaporation.
At a local scale individual stands of trees have very little measurable impact on stream flow

5. Forest Management and Water Management
Forests and trees do play a key role in catchment behaviour
Forests have a major impact on the water cycle within a catchment.
Forest ecosystems provide for a major filter on water flow within the catchment.
Infiltration processes provide clean water for streamflow.
Interception and evapotranspiration use large amounts of the rainfall.
Forest type and forest age do determine the amounts of water used and the runoff.

6. Forest Management and Water Management
Forest Hydrology Research has given some answers
Rainfall is an important variable that is ignored in the current debate.
Trees use proportionally more water when it is drier and can yield more water when it is wet and there is an excess to tree requirements.
Naturally water is more scarce in drought conditions.

7. Forest Management and Water Management
Forest Hydrology Research has given some answers
Tree age is an important variable and is the only focus in the current debate.
It is not just the tree age that determines the amount of runoff but interrelationships between understorey, soil Litter and interception.

8. Forest Management and Water Management
Forest Hydrology Research has given some answers
This is the now famous relationship between forest age and stream flow yield.
It has been misused by applying it to all forests and plantations in all environments. The original research was in 8 calibrated sub catchments dominated by Mountain Ash on deep krasnozem soils.
It explained the lower stream yields observed after the 1939 forests turned much of some catchments into regrowth forests.
It shows that if water yield is your only objective and it must be maximised then you must avoid having young forests in your catchments.

9. Forest Management and Water Management
How do Mountain Ash Forests grow and flourish?
The life cycle of a mountain ash tree is attuned to the natural environment it occurs in.
The life cycle starts with bud initiation and then bud development.
Flowering is in Autumn with pollination by insects and birds.
The fruit matures over winter and ripens in summer. Seeds are retained in the fruit for a number of years and in the absence of a wildfire progressively open or fall from the tree.
Seed germinates in bare soil and ash beds. Seed does nor germinate in litter or in shade. Germination is in Autumn and Spring.
Early growth of dense seedlings is rapid.
Trees exhibit regrowth properties of rapid height growth and pointy crowns for more than 60 years.
Mature trees produce a secondary crown of large branches from the trunk.
Over mature trees begin losing crown elements and develop hollows essential for many wildlife species.
The life expectancy of dominant trees is 200 to 400 years.
The 400 year old trees we need in 400 years time are germinating today.

10. Forest Management and Water Management
The trigger for Mountain Ash forest renewal is wildfire
Wildfire provides
Heat to open fruit capsules immediately after the fire
Ash bed seed bed with access to mineral soil
Removal of competing vegetation
Removal of canopy to allow additional light to soil surface
Removal of aleopathic responses
Flush of nutrients in ash for early growth
Wildfires are a key part of the cycle of life for mountain ash forests.
Wildfires in the natural state start when lightning strikes a tree.
The old fire killed stages are a common target.
During drought conditions there are large amounts of dry fuel available.
Fires spread rapidly. This is the Ash Wednesday 1983 Warburton fire shortly after ignition and then spreading rapidly up Mt Little Joe.
This is the same fire later the same day from Warburton.

11. Forest Management and Water Management
The History of the Mountain Ash forests in
Melbourne’s Water Catchments
Black Thursday
A great fire sweeps across a thinly populated Victoria
1933
Furmston’s Tree Discovered
Wildfires burn through the ranges east of Melbourne and a seedling forest of Mountain Ash is established. One of these seedlings will become the giant Furmston’s Tree.
Red Tuesday
12 people die and 1500 homes lost as fire sweep through the Gippsland forests
Wildfires burn through Wallaby Creek. The resultant forest of Mountain Ash is now known as the “Big Ash” containing some of the tallest trees in Victoria.
1600
1730
1800
1851
1898
1939
2006
Melbourne sources its water from the
Yarra River above Dight’s Falls
Melbourne establishes a series of forested closed catchments where all uses other than water production are banned. Wallaby Creek, Maroondah, O’Shannassy and Upper Yarra.
Melbourne builds its first dam
at Yan Yean

12. Harold Furmston discovers a magnificent mountain ash on Mount Monda, near Healesville.
It is carefully measured and found to have a girth of 19.5 metres. The tree is named after its discoverer: Furmston’s Tree.
The Healesville Shire President soon leads an excursion to the base of the celebrated giant, and bushwalkers make pilgrimages to it.
Not only are the mountain ash forests greatly admired for their awesome beauty – they have now become the most economically valuable forest tree in Victoria.

13. Forest Management and Water Management
The History of the Mountain Ash forests in
Melbourne’s Water Catchments
2000
The Furmston Tree collapses
at the end of its life
Great Dividing Range Fires burn to the edge of the catchments and strategic firebreaks established to prevent fires entering the catchments.
Period of successfully excluding wildfire from Melbourne’s water Catchments
Black Thursday
A great fire sweeps across a thinly populated Victoria
Black Friday
Massive fires sweep through the catchments killing large areas of Mountain Ash and establishing regrowth forests
Wildfires burn through Wallaby Creek. The resultant forest of Mountain Ash is now known as the “Big Ash” containing some of the tallest trees in Victoria.
Red Tuesday
12 people die and 1500 homes lost as fire sweep through the Gippsland forests
Wildfires burn through the ranges east of Melbourne and a seedling forest of Mountain Ash is established. One of these seedlings will become the giant Furmston’s Tree.
1600
1730
1800
1851
1898
1939
2006
It is inevitable that the catchments will burn at some stage over the next 100 years.
Melbourne builds its first dam
at Yan Yean
Melbourne sources its water from the
Yarra River above Dight’s Falls
Catchments declared as National Parks giving water and conservation objectives.
Only Thomson and Yarra Tribs. remain with multiple use objectives and are open for visitors.
Melbourne Board of Works notice reduced water yield from catchments.
Commission major hydrological studies and catchment monitoring network.
Relationship between water yield and forest age determined and policies adopted to exclude fire from all catchments.
Melbourne establishes a series of forested closed catchments where all uses other than water production are banned. Wallaby Creek, Maroondah, O’Shannassy and Upper Yarra.

14. Forest Management and Water Management
Future of Melbourne’s Water Catchment Management
The forests contain a range of age classes resulting form the wildfires or harvesting . They range from 277, 156, 109, 68 and 26 or less.
Periodic catastrophic Wildfires are a natural part of the ecosystem.
Forests in the open age catchments have a broader range of age classes providing greater diversity.

15. Forest Management and Water Management
Future of Melbourne’s Water Catchment Management
The Thomson catchment is dominated by 1939 regrowth.
68 year old forests are beginning to increase water yield.
120 ha per year is harvested and regenerated.
It will take a further 100 years to harvest the 40% that is available.
The average age and the water yields are increasing.
The water yields lost due to harvesting are the potential gains not realised.

16. Forest Management and Water Management
Future of Melbourne’s Water Catchment Management
The next big wildfire will:
Drastically reduce water quality for a 2 to 3 month period where water from burnt catchments will need to be stored or diverted. Additional water treatment may be required.
Provide large areas of regrowth forest that will reduce water yields over the next 10 to 70 years.
The catchment research has shown that thinned regrowth can increase water yields.
Thinning would normally not be allowed in National Parks and would only be an option in the open catchments.

17. Forest Management and Water Management
What is being done elsewhere?
WA Water Corporation has adopted Security through Diversity water supply policy.
Wungong catchment is 13,000 ha of dry sclerophyll forest.
By Spending $20M on active forest management including thinning and ecological burning water yields can be increased.
Water yields will be monitored and are expected to increase by 4 to 6 Gl per year. This is a 25% increase.
The cost of treatment is very competitive at 23 cents per kilolitre compared with desalination at $1.15 per kilolitre.
Forest Management is not just about timber harvesting.
It is about knowing what the forest needs and managing it so that it can provide what we as a community need and that includes water, biodiversity and timber.

18. Forest Management and Water Management
Sources
Dr Rob Campbell Fire Cycle Booklet (unpublished)
Dr Rob Campbell Streamflow Booklet (unpublished)
ABC Black Friday - Online documentary about 1939 Victorian bushfires.
At abc.net.au/blackfriday/
Batani Frank, Bradshaw Jack, Roger Underwood. (2007) Managing forested catchments for water, timber and biodiversity.
ANZIF Conference Proceedings