1. November 2014 Joint BEREC – RSPG Workshop “Facilitating access to radio spectrum lessons learnt after 20 years of awards” PANEL 2 Brussels – 11 November 2014 ----------- Gabriela Galvano ANACOM Portugal

2. 3.4-3.6 / 3.6-3.8 GHz Band Auction A’ABB’ 3400 MHz 3600 MHz DD’CC’ 3600 MHz 3800 MHz 2 x 28 MHz 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 9 Regions, 224 MHz, 36 lots Facilitate market entry & Avoid Spectrum hoarding Two phases: 1st – closed to new entrants 2nd – open to all operators Sealed Bid Cominatorial, two stages, Second Price Auction Facilitate market entry & Avoid Spectrum hoarding Two phases: 1st – closed to new entrants 2nd – open to all operators Sealed Bid Cominatorial, two stages, Second Price Auction

3. Multiband Auction – SMRA (~390 MHz) 2 x 10 MHz 2 lots of 2 x 5 MHz 2 x 57 MHz 9 lots of 2 x 5 MHz + 3 lots of 2 x 4 MHz DOWNLINK 2 x 30 MHz 6 lots of 2 x 5 MHz 10 MHz 2 lots of 5 MHz 2 x 140 MHz + 50 MHz 14 lots of 2 x 5 MHz + 2 lots of 25 MHz

4. Multi-Band Auction Measures to facilitate market entry Sub-1 GHz: 800/900 MHz 1800 MHz/2.6 GHz General : Large amount of spectrum; Spectrum caps & Set Asides; 50% discount in spectrum fees during first 3 years; Spectrum trading; Market analysis - 2 years after the auction. Large amount of spectrum; Spectrum caps & Set Asides; 50% discount in spectrum fees during first 3 years; Spectrum trading; Market analysis - 2 years after the auction. Network access obligation (MVNO & national roaming) and infrastructure sharing agreements. 25% price reduction in the 900 MHz; Joint Cap for 800/900 MHz from 2016; Delayed payment. Low coverage obligations Network access obligation (MVNO & national roaming) and infrastructure sharing agreements. 25% price reduction in the 900 MHz; Joint Cap for 800/900 MHz from 2016; Delayed payment. Low coverage obligations Set aside (1800 MHz and 2.6 GHz); Large amount of spectrum (1800 MHz: 2 x 57 MHZ 1800 + 2.6 GHz). Set aside (1800 MHz and 2.6 GHz); Large amount of spectrum (1800 MHz: 2 x 57 MHZ 1800 + 2.6 GHz).

5. 3.4-3.6 GHz 3.6-3.8 GHz Indicators per region: GDP, population, population density, broadband penetration. Rights of use: Regional, 15 years, renewables, Obligations, Annual fees (20K€-16K€/lot - regional). Low reserve prices (100K-300K€/lot - regional) 3.4-3.6 GHz 3.6-3.8 GHz Indicators per region: GDP, population, population density, broadband penetration. Rights of use: Regional, 15 years, renewables, Obligations, Annual fees (20K€-16K€/lot - regional). Low reserve prices (100K-300K€/lot - regional) Reserve Prices Multi-band auction Rights of use: National, 15 years, renewables, Obligations (coverage, rollout, access) Annual spectrum fees (82K€/MHz), Benchmarking Public Consultation Multi-band auction Rights of use: National, 15 years, renewables, Obligations (coverage, rollout, access) Annual spectrum fees (82K€/MHz), Benchmarking Public Consultation

6. Results 3 bidders 2 winners 50% of spectrum was awarded (18 lots) Beginning 2014, Onitelecom returned the spectrum to ANACOM 3 bidders 2 winners 50% of spectrum was awarded (18 lots) Beginning 2014, Onitelecom returned the spectrum to ANACOM 4 candidates/3 bidders 3 winners (no new entrants) 75% of spectrum was awarded Restriction on 800 MHz band (Spanish DTT) Network access and coverage obligations still not applicable Too soon to evaluate the effectiveness of obligations Definition of data rates for perishes with coverage obligations 4 candidates/3 bidders 3 winners (no new entrants) 75% of spectrum was awarded Restriction on 800 MHz band (Spanish DTT) Network access and coverage obligations still not applicable Too soon to evaluate the effectiveness of obligations Definition of data rates for perishes with coverage obligations 3.4-3.6/3.6-3.8 GHz Multiband