1. 1 Final Discussion Class User Interfaces

2. 2 Discussion Classes Format: Question Ask a member of the class to answer Provide opportunity for others to comment When answering: Give your name. Make sure that the TA hears it. Stand up Speak clearly so that all the class can hear

3. 3 Question 1: Authors The authors of this paper are: Don Byrd W. Bruce Croft Ben Shneiderman (a)Who are they? (b)What biases would you expect them to bring to the discussion?

4. 4 Question 2: Thomas One of the examples is the Library of Congress's Thomas system. (a) What is the purpose of this system? Who are the users? (b) What is the Congressional Record? Another example is the Library of Congress's American Memory system. (c) What is the purpose of this system? Who are the users?

5. 5 Question 3: The four steps Describe the following four steps. What are the objectives of the step? What are the issues? What are the options? (a) Formulation (b) Action (c) Review of the Results (d) Refinement

6. 6 Question 4: User Interfaces It is frequently recommended that there should be separate user interfaces for different categories of users. (a) What features might be included? (b) What are the practical issues in implementing such a choice?

7. 7 Question 5: Xinquery (a) What is good about this user interface? (b) What suggestions would you make to improve this user interface?

8. 8 Question 6: WInquery (a) What do the authors claim are the benefits of this user interface? (b) Do you agree with them?

9. 9 Question 7: Success or Failure? "Zero-hit outcomes occur on 30% of searches at some services,..." (a) Why do you think that this happens? (b) Is it necessarily bad? (c) What can be done to reduce the bad aspects? "Every time I search, I get 10,000 hits..." (d) Why do you think that this happens? (e) Is it necessarily bad? (f) What can be done to reduce the bad aspects?