1. + UCSB LEED EB:O&M Recertification A Decade of Sustainability Success and Leadership Innovative Workshop Consulting, LLC Ackerstein Sustainability Sustainable Operations Leaders in Energy Efficiency Healthy Lifestyle June 18, 2014

2. + 2008 '06 – '07 2005 History of LEED-EB: O&M at UCSB Over a Decade of Sustainable Commitment Girvetz Hall LEED-EB Silver Recreation Center LEED-EB Silver 2012 Recertification LEED-EB:O&M v2009 Gold Signed with USGBC for Portfolio Program 25 by 2012

3. + Initial Benchmark in 2005 Sent email out to Green Schools listserv Used UC Berkeley, Colorado State, and Bard College Gyms21 data set Received 15 complete data sets Numerous calls with USGBC/GBCI Provided 3 LEED points for the project Gyms21 Development

4. + Gyms21 Success!

5. + Energy Benchmarking in EBOM - Meter Data - 12 month period - All energy consumption - Apples to Apples!

6. + Energy Benchmarking in EBOM - Three Standard Compliance Paths 1. Energy Star 2. CBECS 3a. Historic Baseline 3b. Comparable Building Dataset

7. + Energy Benchmarking in EBOM - Thinking About ‘Comparable Buildings’ a. Can your building be deconstructed? b. Where might analogues exist? c. How do those analogues differ? d. Can I get data? e. Can I normalize/adjust for differences?

8. + Gyms21 - Energy Benchmarking - The model: Labs21 a. Energy use intensity for laboratories b. Accounts for a variety of complex variables - lab type, climate, operating hours, LAR c. Can we do the same for University Rec Centers?

9. + Gyms21 - Energy Benchmarking - Collaboration with USGBC a. In principle, EBOM is for all building types b. USGBC/GBCI motivated to solve these problems and accommodate solutions c. Universities are a huge and important market sector

10. + Gyms21 - Energy Benchmarking -Collaboration with UC & CSU campuses a. Who has rec centers? b. Who has energy data? c. Who needs to benchmark buildings?

11. UCSB Recreation Center Gyms21 Benchmarking and LEED Gold Certification

12. 15 UC/CSU recreation facilities CSULB Student Recreations and Wellness Center SDSU Aztec Center Sonoma State Recreation Center UC Davis Recreation Center UCI Anteater Recreation Center UCLA Wooden Center UC Merced Gallo Center UCR Student Recreation Center UCSC East Fitness Complex UCSD Main Gym UCSD RIMAC UCSF Milberry Union UCSF Rutter Center The Gyms21 Dataset

13. The Gyms21 Data Collection Form

19. UCSB Recreation Center LEED EB:OM USEPA/DOE Energy Star Portfolio Manager created ‘Gyms21 Portfolio’ and gave access to all participants input all data from data collection forms site and source EUIs calculated for all buildings in dataset benchmarking datasets easily selectable from 15 included buildings generate Statement of Energy Performance for each facility – basis of LEED EB:OM submittal

20. Statement of Energy Performance - UCSB

21. Statement of Energy Performance - UCSD

22. Statement of Energy Performance - SDSU

23. Gyms21 Areas for Improvement additional years of complete data needed normalization based on pool parameters central plant efficiencies mostly default-calculated

24. Thank You perrin@iworkshopconsulting.com dackerstein@gmail.com jordan.sager@pf.ucsb.edu