1. Summary: Disposition of Comments for PDTR3 20943-5 SMMP Taesul SEO/Sungjoon LIM KISTI/KDB, Korea 2012-06-061 Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5 WG2N1668

2. Overview PDTR3 of 20943-5 SMMP obtained substantial support (32N2225) Comments to be resolved –Canadian : 36 –Japanese : 1 –United States : 33 (Non-official) 2012-06-062 Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5

3. Summary of Canadian Comments (1) Comments for errors in transforming MS Word file into PDF format –11 cmmnts : CA01, CA13~18, CA30~31, CA34~35 Editor’s action : To request SC32 Secretariat special care while transforming word to pdf 2012-06-063 Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5

4. Summary of Canadian Comments (2) Structure of the manuscript –5 cmmnts : CA04~05, CA09, CA25, CA27 Editor’s action : Restructure the relevant parts of the manuscript reflecting the comments 2012-06-064 Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5

5. Summary of Canadian Comments (3) Unclear words or inconsistency of some words –6 cmmnts : CA07~8, CA11, CA20~21, CA32 Editor’s action : Make the unclear words clear and use some inconsistent words consistently Data, data element, metadata element set, primary/secondary data element, mapping, … 2012-06-065 Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5

6. Summary of Canadian Comments (3) CA02 : The text doesn’t includes semantics and many-to-one/one-to-many mapping. Proposals : Remove “semantic” from the title or add more description on semantics. Editor’s action : Remove “semantic” from the title. 2012-06-066 Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5

7. Summary of Canadian Comments (4) CA03 : Define heterogeneity, add why it is important, and explain the relationship with factoring Editor’s action : Accept all 2012-06-067 Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5

8. Summary of Canadian Comments (5) CA10 : Add DE and DEC to Abbreviation Clause Editor’s action : Accept all 2012-06-068 Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5

9. Summary of Canadian Comments (6) CA12, CA19 : Change “semantic mapping” to “data element concept mapping” Editor’s action : Change “semantic mapping” to “data element mapping” because mapping is performed at data element level under same data element concept. 2012-06-069 Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5

10. Summary of Canadian Comments (7) CA22~24 : Increase the completeness of the examples Proposals : Modify some table field names and add DC as primary data elements Editor’s action : Improve the example reflecting the comments 2012-06-0610 Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5

11. Summary of Canadian Comments (8) CA26 : Questions about value mapping Editor’s action : Improve the relevant parts reflecting the comments 2012-06-0611 Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5

12. Summary of Canadian Comments (8) CA06, CA28~29 : Some advices for improvement Proposals : Adopt heterogeneity type number and add/complete bibliographies Editor’s action : Accept all 2012-06-0612 Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5

13. Summary of Canadian Comments (9) CA33 : Necessity of Annex B Proposals : Remove or add explanation Editor’s action : Enhance Annex B and the text to include clear explanation about the relationship with factoring 2012-06-0613 Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5

14. Summary of Canadian Comments (10) CA36 : General comments No specific action is needed. 2012-06-0614 Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5

15. Summary of Japanese Comments (1) JP01 : Comments for errors in transforming MS Word file into PDF format Editor’s action : To request SC32 Secretariat special care while transforming word to pdf 2012-06-0615 Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5

16. Summary of US Comments (1) Typing errors and English problems –10 cmmnts : US05~07, US09, US12~13 US29~32 Editor’s action : Accept all 2012-06-0616 Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5

17. Summary of US Comments (2) US01~03 : Make the scope simple and rewrite the content Editor’s action : Rewrite the scope reflecting the comments 2012-06-0617 Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5

18. Summary of US Comments (3) US10~11, 26 : Structure of the manuscript Editor’s action : Restructure the relevant parts of the manuscript reflecting the comments 2012-06-0618 Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5

19. Summary of US Comments (4) US14, US16~17, US19 : Make unclear words clear Proposals : Explain “less important” and “primary data element” Editor’s action : Change “less important” to “to expect not to be used” and explain 2012-06-0619 Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5

20. Summary of US Comments (5) US18 : Remove the sentence including “standardization” Proposals : Same as above Editor’s action : Remove “standardization” from the sentence because the sentence is important part of this TR 2012-06-0620 Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5

21. Summary of US Comments (6) US33 : Change the title Proposals : Change title to “Semantic Mapping Procedure” Editor’s action : Change title to “Metadata Mapping Procedure” (cf. CA02) 2012-06-0621 Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5

22. Summary of US Comments (7) Need discussion to resolve –US04, US08, US15, US20~25, US28 2012-06-0622 Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5

23. 2012-06-06 Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5 23 CONCEPTUAL DOMAIN VALUE MEANING PERMISSIBLE VALUES VALUE DOMAIN (1:N)(1:1)(N:1) DECCD DEVD (1:N) (N:1) Conceptual Level Representational Level Mapping is performed at representational level, DE and PV.