Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Editing in a multimedia environment What research shows about how news consumers use the Web Laura Ruel Assistant Professor, UNC-Chapel Hill

Published byArline Butler Modified over 9 years ago

Similar presentations

Presentation on theme: "Editing in a multimedia environment What research shows about how news consumers use the Web Laura Ruel Assistant Professor, UNC-Chapel Hill"— Presentation transcript:

1 Editing in a multimedia environment What research shows about how news consumers use the Web Laura Ruel Assistant Professor, UNC-Chapel Hill lauraruel@gmail.com

2 Editing is editing Are there significant differences in how a story should be edited for online consumption? Are there significant differences in how a story should be edited for online consumption?

3 First, your thoughts…

4 Today’s plan Survey Survey Your thoughts about online editingYour thoughts about online editing Overview of research in online editing Overview of research in online editing EyetrackingEyetracking Recall/comprehensionRecall/comprehension Group discussion Group discussion Survey resultsSurvey results

5 Research exists about Writing style and comprehension Writing style and comprehension What types of editing changes make a difference in what readers remember? How/should content be broken up?What types of editing changes make a difference in what readers remember? How/should content be broken up? Headlines Headlines How are they read online?How are they read online? Photo editing Photo editing Should images be edited/selected differently for online?Should images be edited/selected differently for online? How to users view slideshows? What does that mean for photo editing?How to users view slideshows? What does that mean for photo editing? Font choices and readability Font choices and readability Which ones work best online?Which ones work best online? Form and reader satisfaction/comprehension Form and reader satisfaction/comprehension When should an editor recommend an HTML vs. a Flash presentation of information?When should an editor recommend an HTML vs. a Flash presentation of information?

6 What is eyetracking? Why use it?

7 Research methods Eyetracking Eyetracking

8 Research Watch videoWatch videoWatch videoWatch video

9 Research Eyetracking Eyetracking

10 Research

11 Hotspot: Number of Fixations Hotspot data

12 Hotspot: Length of Fixations Hotspot data

13 Research Eyetracking Eyetracking

14 Research methods Usability and effects Usability and effects

15 Editing content for online  Recent eyetracking research from the Nielsen/Norman group

16 Editing content for online  Recent eyetracking research from the Nielsen/Norman group

17 Editing content for online  Recent eyetracking research from the Nielsen/Norman group

18 Editing content for online  Recent eyetracking research from the Nielsen/Norman group

19 Editing content for online  Recent eyetracking research from the Nielsen/Norman group

20 Editing content for online  Recent eyetracking research from the Nielsen/Norman group

21 Editing content for online  Recent eyetracking research from the Nielsen/Norman group

22 Editing content for online  Recent eyetracking research from the Nielsen/Norman group

23 Editing content for online  Recent eyetracking research from the Nielsen/Norman group

24 Editing content for online  Eyetrack III results:  Eyetrack III results: Stories with shorter paragraphs got more than twice as many overall eye fixations than those with longer paragraphs.

25 Editing content for online  Eyetrack III results

26 Editing content for online  Eyetrack III results

27 Editing content for online  Eyetrack III results 0 50 100

28 Editing content for online  Eyetrack III results 0 50 100

29 Editing content for online Eyetrack III: What’s best for a home page: Headlines + blurbs? …

30 Editing content for online … or just headlines?

31 Editing content for online Eyetrack III: Test pages

32 Editing content for online Eyetrack III: Heatmaps of test pages 0 50

33 Editing content for online Heatmaps of test pages Headlines only ^ Headlines + blurbs > 0 50 100

34 Editing content for online Eyetrack III: Home page viewing sequence

35 Viewing photos online  Poynter Eyetrack III results: Faces in photos on home pages and in multimedia generated the most eye fixations. Size matters!

36 Viewing photos online  Poynter Eyetrack III results and DiSEL results: Text on photos received little attention.

37 Viewing photos online  Online images get fixations if they:  Relate to surrounding content  Are clear  Feature “approachable” people  Faces are clear  People are smiling / looking at the camera  Feature “real people”  Models denote ads, and are avoided  Feature areas of private anatomy Nielsen/Norman Study

38 Viewing photos online  Nielsen/Norman results

39 Viewing photos online  Nielsen/Norman results

40 Viewing photos online  Nielsen/Norman results http://www.ojr.org/ojr/stories/070312ruel/

41 Slide shows: How do users’ navigate them?

42 Viewing photo slide shows  DiSEL research: Navigation possibility: thumbnail view http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/photo/galleries/091506/korda/index.html

43 Viewing photo slide shows  DiSEL research: Navigation possibility: arrows and next http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/photo/galleries/091506/korda/index.html

44 Viewing photo slide shows  DiSEL research: Navigation possibility: autoplay http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/photo/galleries/091506/korda/index.html

45 Viewing photo slide shows  DiSEL research: Navigation possibility: numbers and thumbnails http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/photo/galleries/091506/korda/index.html

46 Viewing photo slide shows Number of Slides Viewed (out of 40) Next 28 (70%) Arrow 25 (62%) Numbers 12 (30%) Time Spent Next 2:34 Arrow 3:31 Numbers 2:16 *aver. 2:49 Navigation Style Used Next 56% Numbers 23% Arrows 15% Autoplay 6% View Thumbs 0%

47 Linearity  Two “non-linear” navigation methods available  Click randomly in the numbers  Thumbnails  Eight used “numbers”  Four clicked in order (viewed 20 slides)  Four clicked randomly (viewed 6 slides ) What does this tell us?

48 Editing content for online From: Software Usability Research Laboratory Department of Psychology,Wichita State UniversitySoftware Usability Research Laboratory Department of Psychology,Wichita State University

49 Editing content for online From: Software Usability Research Laboratory Department of Psychology,Wichita State UniversitySoftware Usability Research Laboratory Department of Psychology,Wichita State University

50 Editing content for online From: Software Usability Research Laboratory Department of Psychology,Wichita State UniversitySoftware Usability Research Laboratory Department of Psychology,Wichita State University

51 Editing content for online DiSEL: Form (HTML vs. Flash and motivation)

52 Editing content for online DiSEL: Form (HTML vs. Flash and motivation) Link to article

53 Editing content for online DiSEL: Form (HTML vs. Flash and motivation) Link to presentation

54 Editing content for online DiSEL: Form (HTML vs. Flash and motivation) Link to DiSEL

55 Editing content for online DiSEL: Form (HTML vs. Flash and motivation) Link to DiSEL

56 Discussion…differences exist  Some rules are different  Some AP and print style rules don’t work online. Sentences and paragraphs have to be kept a lot shorter.  There are some style variances from print to account for worldwide readership (we have to be sensitive to datelines, time zones, etc.)  Headlines have different rules online than in print  Style is different  Our standards for grammar, punctuation and syntax are generally the same but the process is not. We do believe in creating a different style and have been working on delineating what that should be.  Information from Nora Paul, Institute for New Media Studies Information from Nora Paul, Institute for New Media Studies Information from Nora Paul, Institute for New Media Studies

57 Discussion…differences exist  How is the process is different?  Style is the same, but the editing process is not.. On the print side, a story gets written, looked at by a desk editor, then worked over in minute detail by a copy editor. Then it is checked by the managing copy editor, and gets final approval by the chief copy editor. Once laid out, it gets printed off and re- checked on hard copy by another copy editor for errors in headlines, breakers, etc. On the print side, a story gets written, looked at by a desk editor, then worked over in minute detail by a copy editor. Then it is checked by the managing copy editor, and gets final approval by the chief copy editor. Once laid out, it gets printed off and re- checked on hard copy by another copy editor for errors in headlines, breakers, etc. Online there is no formal copy editing staff whatsoever. In most cases an assignment / site editor will look at the story quickly either just before it is posted or, if it is a quick-breaking piece, immediately after it goes up online. But in some cases where nobody is available to check the copy, the person writing the story posts it directly once it is ready to go. If there is nobody available to look at it (due to chronic under-staffing), nobody in editorial buy the writer sees the story before it is posted. Online there is no formal copy editing staff whatsoever. In most cases an assignment / site editor will look at the story quickly either just before it is posted or, if it is a quick-breaking piece, immediately after it goes up online. But in some cases where nobody is available to check the copy, the person writing the story posts it directly once it is ready to go. If there is nobody available to look at it (due to chronic under-staffing), nobody in editorial buy the writer sees the story before it is posted.  Information from Nora Paul, Institute for New Media Studies Information from Nora Paul, Institute for New Media Studies Information from Nora Paul, Institute for New Media Studies

58 Discussion…differences exist  Experience level is different  We use the same editing guidelines, but we aren’t nearly as familiar with them.  Volume is different  Because the online site has more copy and additional resources, there is more editing to do with online material  Information from Nora Paul, Institute for New Media Studies Information from Nora Paul, Institute for New Media Studies Information from Nora Paul, Institute for New Media Studies

59 Discussion…differences exist  BIGGEST ISSUES  Lack of time and staff  Scheduling: Most original copy is made during the day, but copy editors work at night. Trying to staff around the clock to match the continuous online news cycle is a challenge.  Deadline pressure is double  Writing promos  Forgetting the adage: “Get it first, but first get it right.”  Information from Nora Paul, Institute for New Media Studies Information from Nora Paul, Institute for New Media Studies Information from Nora Paul, Institute for New Media Studies

60 Discussion…differences exist  COMMUNICATION BETWEEN PRINT AND ONLINE:  They don’t understand how online works  Getting them to flag final version for online  Changes made to print text but online is not told  Culture clash – online is urgent, copyeditors are methodical  Set in their workflow, not available to online  Getting print editors to give it to online now, not just when they get a chance

61 Discussion…differences exist  WHAT THE NEXT GENERATION NEEDS TO KNOW:  How to work like a wire service  How to work online and in print  How to balance speed and accuracy  How online writing differs from print and broadcast  How to edit different Web presentation forms

Download ppt "Editing in a multimedia environment What research shows about how news consumers use the Web Laura Ruel Assistant Professor, UNC-Chapel Hill"

Similar presentations

MODULE 13: EDITING. 12 3 Editing The collaboration of writer and editor improves CONTENT. WHEN EDITOR AND WRITER WORK TOGETHER FROM THE BEGINNING, CONTENT.

MODULE 13: EDITING Editing The collaboration of writer and editor improves CONTENT. WHEN EDITOR AND WRITER WORK TOGETHER FROM THE BEGINNING, CONTENT.
A Media Study Unit. Understand the basic ethical principles and responsibilities of journalists Experience the writing process from a journalists perspective.

A Media Study Unit. Understand the basic ethical principles and responsibilities of journalists Experience the writing process from a journalists perspective.
Overview Frank Cervone. Overview Web site design and redesigns –Usability testing techniques –Designing for “ scent ” Web site design and redesigns –Usability.

Overview Frank Cervone. Overview Web site design and redesigns –Usability testing techniques –Designing for “ scent ” Web site design and redesigns –Usability.
ANIMOTO Project Step by Step Directions. Getting Started… How to get your pictures ready in Powerpoint First step- Open Powerpoint (duh)

ANIMOTO Project Step by Step Directions. Getting Started… How to get your pictures ready in Powerpoint First step- Open Powerpoint (duh)
1 Making Your Content Count An Invitation to Your Audience Nancy DuVergne Smith MIT Alumni Association Editorial Director.

1 Making Your Content Count An Invitation to Your Audience Nancy DuVergne Smith MIT Alumni Association Editorial Director.
Web Printing Continue on Web Usability It is a good idea that web sites can provide a printing version and browsing version for the same document.

Web Printing Continue on Web Usability It is a good idea that web sites can provide a printing version and browsing version for the same document.
Website: Best Practices. Sources: The World Wide Web Consortium the main international standards organization for the World Wide Web Research-Based Web.

Website: Best Practices. Sources: The World Wide Web Consortium the main international standards organization for the World Wide Web Research-Based Web.
Web Page Design J. Richard Stevens. Basic Grid Design

Web Page Design J. Richard Stevens. Basic Grid Design
A cluey freelance copywriters presentation © Copyright Cluey Consulting 2007 - 2010.

A cluey freelance copywriters presentation © Copyright Cluey Consulting
Dreamweaver 8 Concepts and Techniques Introduction Web Site Development and Macromedia Dreamweaver 8.

Dreamweaver 8 Concepts and Techniques Introduction Web Site Development and Macromedia Dreamweaver 8.
Editing in a multimedia environment What research shows about how news consumers use the Web Laura Ruel Assistant Professor, UNC-Chapel Hill

Editing in a multimedia environment What research shows about how news consumers use the Web Laura Ruel Assistant Professor, UNC-Chapel Hill
Journalism Today Chapter 1 “Reporting for the Media” Text

Journalism Today Chapter 1 “Reporting for the Media” Text
Digital Storytelling Tell me a fact and I’ll learn

Digital Storytelling Tell me a fact and I’ll learn
What Research Tells us About Designing Online Content Judith Norton Chief Instructional Architect B.E.S.T. Coffee Program El Camino College MERLOT International.

What Research Tells us About Designing Online Content Judith Norton Chief Instructional Architect B.E.S.T. Coffee Program El Camino College MERLOT International.
Magazine Journalism Stages of Magazine Production.

Magazine Journalism Stages of Magazine Production.
Writing and Editing for the Web. What We Do Have a strategy first, what’s yours? Build affinity audiences in our core silos To be the “best of the Twin.

Writing and Editing for the Web. What We Do Have a strategy first, what’s yours? Build affinity audiences in our core silos To be the “best of the Twin.
SEO & Content Marketing | April 2015 bradforster.org Winning at SEO & Content Marketing.

SEO & Content Marketing | April 2015 bradforster.org Winning at SEO & Content Marketing.
Parts of a Newspaper.

Parts of a Newspaper.
Review of last Session Adding custom html Adding custom html HTML is the language that web servers understand, all web pages are created using HTML. HTML.

Review of last Session Adding custom html Adding custom html HTML is the language that web servers understand, all web pages are created using HTML. HTML.
Using research to improve your site’s design and effectiveness Nora Paul, Director, Institute for New Media Studies, University of Minnesota Laura Ruel,

Using research to improve your site’s design and effectiveness Nora Paul, Director, Institute for New Media Studies, University of Minnesota Laura Ruel,

Similar presentations

Ads by Google