1. IPv6 Readiness Measurement BoF Report 4 March, 2015@APNIC 39 1

2. APNIC 39 IPv6 Readiness Measurement BoF Date : 4 March 2015, 16:00-17:00 (UTC +9) Location: Room 501 Chair: Shian-Shyong Tseng Agenda – Welcome, Shian-Shyong Tseng (TWNIC, Chair of BoF) – Japan IPv6 Measurement, Tomohiro Fujisaki (NTT) – Thailand IPv6 Measurement, Prof. Sinchai Kamolphiwong (Prince of Songkla University) – Vietnam IPv6 Measurement, Nguyen Tien Dzung (VNNIC) – Taiwan IPv6 Measurement, Ai-Chin Lu (TWNIC) – RIPE IPv6 measurement, Vesna Manojlovic (RIPENCC) – CISCO IPv6 measurement, Shishio Tsuchiya (CISCO)

3. User availability Service availability Common Criteria DNS query from ccTLD Network Traffic DNS query from ccTLD ccTLD Workflow for IPv6 Readiness Measurement BoF IPv6 allocation and BGP advertisement DATA AcquisitionDATA AnalysisDATA Visualization Post Processing Ready logo products The 1 st BoF at APNIC 36 and workshop in 2013 Discussed Measuremet criteria Made consensus for three common measurement criteria Created a Mailing list and Website The 2 nd BoF at APNIC 37, workshop and The 3 rd BoF at APNIC 38 in 2014 Data acquisition about common criteria Developed the tool for the IPv6 server detection function Discussed the service availability and analyzed the outcome of the criteria

4. Current Japan Status presented by Tomohiro Fujisaki (NTT) Many fixed-line ISPs have started their commercial IPv6 service for both enterprise and consumer users. IPv6 ready Government’s services are increasing. Large contents providers do not support IPv6 yet. In Japan, IPv6 Internet connectivity has deployed smoothly, but need to tackle to improve Content services and Cellular services. 4

5. Current Thailand Status presented by Prof. Sinchai Kamolphiwong (Prince of Songkla University) Introduced the National IPv6 Thailand Master Plan for 2014-2016 (3-year plan) including IPv6 Infrastructure, Human Development, Services and Supports, and Public Awareness Thailand developed its own monitoring system based upon a five-color labeling. Good progress in Ministry of Finance, Ministry of ICT and Ministry of Science and Technology. Some users experienced that IPv6 is faster than IPv4. 5

6. Current Vietnam Status presented by Nguyen Tien Dzung (VNNIC) Introduced the three-phased National IPv6 Master Plan, and the Key activities in 2014. Showed Survey results of their ISPs using 3 dimensions with 16 criteria 43 local ISP and CP participated (3 ISPs with full 16 criteria ready: VNPT, VIETTEL, NETNAM; 6 others with 10/16 criteria ready; The remaining with very low ready percentage) 6

7. Current Taiwan Status presented by Ai-Chin Lu (TWNIC) Updated the status of 3 common measurement criteria: IPv6 allocation and BGP advertisement, User Availability, Service Availability. Introduced new Measurement Criteria: Access router/gateway availiability, Home Gateway availiability. Showed Survey results of ISP Internet access service device IPv6 availiability. By analyzing the home gateway devices from 15 major vendors, over 50% vendors provide IPv6-available home gateway devices. 7

8. Structure of IPv6 Readiness USER Availability Home Gateway Availability Service Availability IPv6 allocation and BGP advertisement(Border,Core) USER Service (ICP, IPP) ICP, IPP: DNS, WEB, Email, FTP IASP, IDC: FTTx, ADSL, Cabel, WiFi, 3G, 4G, co- location Access Router/Gateway Availability Network (IASP)

9. RIPE IPv6 measurement, Vesna Manojlovic (RIPENCC) Introduced IPv6 RIPEness and RIPE Atlas IPv6 Measurements RIPE Atlas can be used for: –IPv6 reachability testing –IPv6 traceroute visualisation –Investigating IPv6 filtering based on packet size –Researching IPv6 extension headers filtering

10. CISCO IPv6 measurement, Shishio Tsuchiya (CISCO) 10 CISCO used public existing data: Whois DB of RIR,APNIC Lab, Alexa, Google, etc. Color indicates relative deployment index. Overall IPv6 ratio depends on IPv6 Transit AS/contents/user

11. Different methods to compute Service Availability 1. Data acquisition from the public existing data sources – Data acquizition from Alexa’s top 500 websites for each country – Data acquizition from Alexa’s top 1 million websites 2. Data Collection from ccTLD DBs (NZ, SG, TW, VN, CN)

12. Report of the IPv6 Readiness Measurement in Asia Pacific IPv6 Allocation and BGP Advertisement 12

13. Report of the IPv6 Readiness Measurement in Asia Pacific User Availability 13

14. Report of the IPv6 Readiness Measurement in Asia Pacific Service Availability(WEB)- Data Collection from Alexa’s top 1 million websites 14

15. Report of the IPv6 Readiness Measurement in Asia Pacific Service Availability(DNS)- Data Collection from Alexa’s top 1 million websites 15

16. Report of the IPv6 Readiness Measurement in Asia Pacific Service Availability(Email)- Data Collection from Alexa’s top 1 million websites 16

17. Conclusion 17 In addition to measurement results from the public existing data sources, the results from ccTLD DBs are also presented. More than 30 organizations have given presentation in previous meetings. We will invite more ccTLD registries to participate in the future BoF meetings. IPv6 Access Router/Gateway Availability and IPv6 Home Gateway availability have been proposed. Different methodologies and criteria of readiness measurement are very welcome.

18. 18 Thank you Please join us: Mailing list: ap-v6readiness@ap-v6readiness.orgap-v6readiness@ap-v6readiness.org Website: http://www.ap-v6readiness.orghttp://www.ap-v6readiness.org