Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byDylan Ralph Cobb Modified over 9 years ago
1
Houston Marine Insurance Seminar “Overview of Excess Casualty and Other Lines” September 23, 2002
2
-21.05% -26.12% -13.04% -13.84% -7.10% -7.66% -30 -25 -20 -15 -10 -5 0 NasdaqS&P 500Dow Jones 2001 6 Mos. 2002 U. S. Equity Markets 2001-02
3
P/C Insurer Financial Strength 2001 q 6 companies ratings were raised q 209 companies ratings were lowered q 24 companies became insolvent - all of which were rated below S&P “BBB” Source: Standards & Poor’s, March 27, 2002
4
Growth in U.S. P&C NPW ( All Lines) Source: A.M. Best, Insurance Information Institute *Estimate based on III 2002 Earlybird Survey 2000: 5.1% 2001 Estimate: 10.3%* 2002 Forecast: 15.1%*
5
Underwriting Gain (Loss) 1975 - 2001 *2001 estimate based on first 9 months including assumptions for WTC losses. Source: A.M. Best, Insurance Information Institute 2001*
6
World’s costliest property catastrophe insurance losses, 1970 to 2001 Insured Loss ($millions) Date Event Country 140-60 BN*11/9/01 Terrorist attack on WTC, Pentagon United States 2 20,185 23/8/92 Hurricane Andrew United States, Bahamas 3 16,72017/1/94 Northridge Earthquake United States 4 7,338 27/9/91 Typhoon Mireille Japan 5 6,22125/1/90 Winterstorm Daria France, GB, B 6 6,164 25/12/99 Winterstorm Lothar France, CH 7 5,990 15/9/89 Hurricane Hugo Puerto Rico, United States 8 4,674 15/10/87 Storms and floods Europe 9 4,32325/2/90 Winterstorm Vivian Western/Central Europe 10 4,293 22/9/99 Typhoon Bart Japan 11 3,833 20/9/98 Hurricane Georges United States, Caribbean 12 3,150 5/6/01 Tropical Storm Allison United States 13 2,994 6/7/88 Piper Alpha oil platform explosion Great Britain 14 2,872 17/1/95 Great Hanshin earthquake, Kobe Japan 15 2,551 27/12/99 Winterstorm Martin France, Spain, CH 16 2,508 10/9/99 Hurricane Floyd, flooding United States 17 2,440 1/10/95 Hurricane Opal United States, Mexico 18 2,144 10/3/93 Blizzard, tornadoes United States 19 2,019 11/9/92 Hurricane Iniki United States 20 @2,000Aug ‘02European Floods Source: Swiss Re, Sigma. At 2001 prices WTC property losses alone estimated at $19BN.
7
Energy Property Losses $110M $950M $440M $1.35BN $300M $0 $200M $400M $600M $800M $1BN $1.2BN $1.4BN '98'99'00'01'02* * 02 Loss Exceeding $50M include: Gas, plant fire, Kuwait $150M Refinery fire, Japan$ 75M Power station flood, Washington State$ 70M
8
Percent of Awards Greater Than $1 Million By Liability Type 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 Products Liability Business Negligence Medical Malpractice Premises Liability Vehicular Liability* 1994- 1996 1999- 2000 * Includes Personal Auto Source: Current Award Trends in Personal Injury 2001 Jury Verdict Research
9
Impact of Loss Cost Trends on Excess Casualty q Attachment points have not kept pace with loss cost trends q Frequency - More claims now penetrating excess layer q Severity Ù More severity losses Ù Excess layer receives the bulk of severity increases Higher attachment points would offset, in part, the effect of new losses trending into the excess layer
10
Workers Compensation Post 9/11/01 “Employee concentration” issues long existed, but 9/11 made the potential real with catastrophic results. 9/11 brought new analytic, catastrophic modeling into common use: Ý Aggregation analysis: identifying substantial numbers of employees at a single location or in a single area Ý Geo-coding: quantifying high-risk geographic zones exposures across multiple lines of insurance Heightened emphasis on material risk information, including review of insured’s disaster and business continuity plans.
11
Vehicular Liability Jury Awards (including Personal Auto) %Change 1994 2000 2005? 1994-2000 Top Award $20,625,000 $46,000,000 ?123% Mean Award $187,152 $268,648 ? 44% Underwriters are pricing risks today for possible events which will not be adjudicated until 2005. The U.S. Department of Transportation estimates the average costs of an auto fatality in the year 2000 was $977,000. The average cost of a critical injury was $1,100,000. U.S. Department of Transportation, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), May 2002.
12
Asbestos, MTBE & Mold Asbestos Ý Unparalleled loss estimates Ý 300,000 court cases in U.S, and rising Ý Unveiling of “unimpaired cases” premise MTBE Ý Energy insurance sector liability concerns Mold Ý Unchartered territory Ý Congressional intervention
13
Average Settlement Values 0 5M 10M 15M 20M 25M All CasesAccounting CasesNon Accounting Cases '96-'00 2001
14
Restatements Filed 1997 - 2001 116 158 216 233 270 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 19971998199920002001
15
Energy Industry and Insurance Events in both industries have impacted the risk financing strategies of energy companies. Energy sector consolidation and downwards credit rating trends influencing risk assessment by insurers. P&C hard market dynamics adding pressure on enterprise risk spend.
16
Looking Ahead Collective responsibility to ensure marketplace viability. Reinforcement of long-term relationships. Adjust perception of opportunistic enticements. Importance of insurer credit-worthiness. Value of insurance companies track record. Listening and understanding what is important to each other - insurers, reinsurers, brokers and insureds.
Similar presentations
© 2024 SlidePlayer.com. Inc.
All rights reserved.