1. ECOOP Consensus Meeting, Erdemli, March 2005 ECOOP WP13: Demonstration & Evaluation of ECOOP Monitoring Forecasting and Information System  Goals:  Demonstration of overall ECOOP Services  System Assessment and Evaluation  User Consultation  Socio – Economic evaluation  Education

2. ECOOP Consensus Meeting, Erdemli, March 2005 Proposed Tasks 1.Services / Products Specification 2.Services Demonstrator 3.ECOOP system Assessment 4.Services Evaluation from User Perspectives 5.Education & Training 6.Socio-economic evaluation A bit of history ……….

3. ECOOP Consensus Meeting, Erdemli, March 2005 11 demonstration cases – 8 different systems Oil Spills Eutrophi cation HAB IMR+ HCMR FIMR DFMR PML+ MF MetNo MF + DMI From: Mersea_S1 Final meeting, Bergen, June 2004

4. ECOOP Consensus Meeting, Erdemli, March 2005 Oil - Spill Ecosystem Eutrophication Ecosystem HAB WEB Presentation R/S and in-situ Data Output From SYS 1-6 End Users Evaluation of strengths and weaknesses WP2 WP3 WP6 Outline of WP5 From: Mersea_S1 Final meeting, Bergen, June 2004

5. ECOOP Consensus Meeting, Erdemli, March 2005 Web demonstration Deliverable D5.2 – D5.3Live Service Interface http://env1.ncmr.gr/oilSpill/ http://www.poseidon.ncmr.gr/mersea/ From: Mersea_S1 Final meeting, Bergen, June 2004

6. ECOOP Consensus Meeting, Erdemli, March 2005 5-10 “converging” regional/coastal system (national efforts; need for European perspective; share experience + products) Mersea_S1 identified differences + (mainly) common problems / needs Pre-operational ocean application services are already there !!!! Need to: Optimize downscaling from global to coastal Improve – extend regional monitoring systems. Link-improve global R/S products (SLA, Ocean Color) Improve ecosystem models / adapt to local needs Assimilation of ecosystem data Parameterization of fresh water input + atmospheric deposition – link to operational (?) systems Improve atmospheric forcing / coupling to H.R. LAMs ……………………………………………………… Need to keep the Mersea_s1 momentum …….. FP6-FP7 (+ continue pre-operational coupling / use of global products) WP5 Conclusions – forward look From: Mersea_S1 Final meeting, Bergen, June 2004

7. ECOOP Consensus Meeting, Erdemli, March 2005 13.5 Education 13.4 ECOOP Users Group Evaluation 13.2 ECOOP Serv. Demonstrator ECOOP service portfolio 13.3 System Assessment WP5/8 Outline of WP13 WP1WP..WP5 13.1 Service Specifications Internal - External Users 13.6 Socio-Economic Evaluation WP1-12 WP6WP..WP12

8. ECOOP Consensus Meeting, Erdemli, March 2005 Task 13.1: ECOOP products specifications  Define the services / products to be included in the demonstration - evaluation procedure (ECOOP Portfolio or Product Catalogue)  In collaboration with service developers / providers (and production WP)  Possibly with key users (“internal” vs “external”)  Taking into account present and planned needs  Deliverables: Specifications V1 / V2 (m12-m24)

9. ECOOP Consensus Meeting, Erdemli, March 2005 Task 13.2: Services Demonstrator  Disseminate products to ECOOP users through WEB / FTP services  Setup an ECOOP service portal  Include all items of product catalogue  Distributed architecture with contribution of all service developers

10. ECOOP Consensus Meeting, Erdemli, March 2005 Task 13.3: ECOOP System Assessment  Provide continuous assessment of ECOOP system performance through specific indicators  Technical indicators; applied to integrated products (not individual modules); monitor performance with reference to specifications  Quality (scientific) indicators; giving to end users and estimate of the confidence level for the different products; based on standard scientific indicators (forecasting skill; data qc …) but presented in a synthetic way

11. ECOOP Consensus Meeting, Erdemli, March 2005 Task 13.4: Evaluation from user perspectives  Formulate an ECOOP users group (geographical and services representation)  Evaluate how ECOOP improves the quality and extends the range of user applications  Map their current modus operandi, needs and gaps  Update according to project developments  Compile a list of recommendations (initial, intermediate, final)

12. ECOOP Consensus Meeting, Erdemli, March 2005 Task 13.5: Education - Training  Provide advanced training through summer schools  Contribute to Operational Oceanography courses  Produce dedicated education material  Increase the use of operational products for BSc, MSc, PhD thesis

13. ECOOP Consensus Meeting, Erdemli, March 2005 Task 13.6: Socio-economic evaluation  Applied on specific services  In collaboration with selected users  Non-market economic evaluation  Using cost-benefit analysis  Social and environmental benefits of produced services

14. ECOOP Consensus Meeting, Erdemli, March 2005 Links to other WPs  WP6-12: collect specifications from service developers  WP1 – 2 – 3: Definition of data to be included in demonstration - evaluation  WP5: demonstrator (production) – assessment (technical indicators)  WP8: assessment (quality indicators - validation)  WP4: downscaling – links to local users

15. ECOOP Consensus Meeting, Erdemli, March 2005 13.5 Education 13.4 ECOOP Users Group Evaluation 13.2 ECOOP Serv. Demonstrator ECOOP service portfolio 13.3 System Assessment WP5/8 Outline of WP13 WP1WP..WP5 13.1 Service Specifications Internal - External Users 13.6 Socio-Economic Evaluation WP1-12 WP6WP..WP12

16. WP.. IN-SITU PRODUCTION WP.. ECOSYS. SER. PRODUCTION WP.. R/S PRODUCTION WP.. MODELS PRODUCTION WP.. ?? SERVICE PRODUCTION WP.. ECOOP INFORMATION SYSTEM Data – model fields WP.. ECOOP SERVICES structured info products, indicators WP.. EVALUATION – USERS - EDUCATION STANDARDIZATION, QA, QC, PRODUCTION-PUBLICATION DATA PROVIDERS + ~10 EXISTING TARGETED SYSTEMS WP.. CAPACITY BUILDING FILLING GAPS WP.. ?? SERVICE PRODUCTION WP.. ADVANCED RESEARCH APPLICATIONS ~5 NEW SYSTEMS ~3-4 APPLICATIONS R&D + standardization