1. David Noble Supervisory Board Director Boston 29 th October, 2003

2. Introduction 1The Food Retail Market in Russia 2A Brief History of Pyaterochka 3Questions and Answers 2

3. An Overview of the Russian Food Retail Market in 2003 Overview

4. AT Kearney Global Retail Development Index Source: AT Kearney GRDI 2003-( EDS) Go Now Go 4 AT Kearney

5. Institute of Grocery Distribution’s (UK) Market Index CountryRank% ScoreStatus China170% Priority 1 markets Italy170% Russia170% Japan468% Priority 2 markets Hungary566% India566% United States566% Poland865% Canada962% France962% United Kingdom962% Germany1261% Turkey1361%

6. Top 5 European Grocery Markets (2001) Source: Institute of Grocery Distribution (IGD) 6 CountryGrocery Market (€ bn) Germany204 France176 United Kingdom162 Italy134 Russia99

7. Western food retailers in Eastern Europe 7 Source: IGD, M+M Planet Retail

8. Food retail spending in Moscow by outlet type Source: Moscow City Hall 8 Supermarkets and hypermarkets 12% Traditional small shops and kiosks 58% Outdoor markets 30%

9. Major food retailers in Russia Source: Company data, UFG 9 Chain / Company Number of storesGross turnover, $m 200020012002200020012002 Pyaterochka 388013575212501 Perekrestok 283846156252333 Ramstore 9915125250308 Sedmoy Continent 152231124201301 Kopeika 16232760116182 Dixi 2328402070n/a Bin n/a263270100120 Paterson 41016124082

10. Share of top 3 food retailers Source: ACNielsen, Company estimate for Russia 10

11. Why international retailers have not come (Yet!) shortage of suitable retail properties the difficulty of getting access to land and necessary permits lack of long-term leases underdeveloped supply infrastructure huge distances between major urban centers shortage of qualified retail staff BUT IKEA, METRO, AUCHAN, AVA/EDEKA have taken the plunge

12. Market Summary Russia is among the world’s top 10 grocery markets with over $100 bn turnover in 2002 Share of open markets and small shops is still high Domestic food retail chains enjoy strong growth, but share of top 3 retailers is only 1.1% Foreign competition is insubstantial 12

13. Pyaterochka Overview

14. Pyaterochka: Introduction Pyaterochka is the leading grocery chain in Russia by sales and number of stores 162 own stores and 20+ franchised Pyaterochka was formed after 1998 financial crisis from two food wholesale operations First store opened in February 1999 Positioned as a soft discounter with 3500 products Average store size 585 sq m Mostly located in residential districts EBRD has been a shareholder since 2001 14

15. New store openings in 1999-2003E: Rapid Growth 15

16. 16 Pyaterochka stores in St. Petersburg and Moscow

17. Pyaterochka Proposition OUR CUSTOMER STORE CHARACTERISTICS Low to middle income group Convenient location Average basket ~ $4.5 Competitive prices Frequent shoppers Guaranteed quality of products Majority do not have cars Well-chosen range of products Live within 1,5 km Always in stock 17

18. One of Pyaterochka stores in St. Petersburg 18

19. Inside the store 19

20. Pyaterochka Phase One Strategy Build Pyaterochka brand as fast as possible Lease all stores rather than buy or build Increase range from 600 to 3500 SKU’s Build reputation for low cost quality branded goods Concentrate on supply chain issues Introduce best practices throughout organisation 20

21. Pyaterochka Phase Two Strategy Continue aggressive roll out strategy Buy well located stores Build stores when the opportunity arises Introduce a number of own label products Leverage buying power to keep prices low Build consolidated warehouses Introduce best of breed IT solutions across the supply chain Develop larger format 21

22. Pyaterochka Critical Success Factors Keep it simple –Limited Promotional Activity –No Internet Home Delivery –No Credit and Loyalty Cards Every day low prices –Same price in every store in each region Well trained employees –Pyaterochka training school 3 week course Source products locally –2000 50% of all products imported –2003 95% of all products bought locally Always in stock –Very high sales per sq m on a range of 3500 products 22

23. Pyaterochka as a Proxy for Russia - Positives Rapid growth in all forms of organised retail Stock market up by over 50% av for each of last three years Increasing interest from Multi Nationals in setting up local operations All big 4 accountants present and very busy (and expensive) EBRD and IFC very active Top Law Firms and Investment Banks returning since 1998 financial crisis 23

24. Pyaterochka as a Proxy for Russia - Negatives St Petersburg and Moscow reasonably easy places to do business- regions less so A bit of a bubble again with high real estate prices. Leases still short 5-6 yrs common Infrastructure Road & Rail need investment Little sale/ lease back activity No 3 rd Party Logistics Operators- Do it all yourself! Red tape does mean you need a local partner 24

25. Pyaterochka Key Challenges Finding appropriate locations –2 teams of people in St Pete & Moscow Keeping highly trained employees –Continual learning at training school –Above average compensation Keeping costs low –Re-investing supplier discounts into lower prices for customers Fight competition –Outdoor markets, other discounters, Western operators 25

26. Financials and operating data 26 Key performance measures in 2002: Inventory turnover: 11 days Average purchase bill: $4.5 Average daily number of purchases: 296,228 Sales/sq. metre of selling area: $8.986 Long term debt/equity: 0.05 (as of end 2002)

27. Benchmarking Analysis: European Comparables 27 Source: SSSB, Company data (audited IAS)

28.  Continue rapid organic growth of existing format in Moscow & St. Petersburg  Increase purchasing power with suppliers; enhance gross margins and volume  Increase share of owned and purpose built stores to 50/50  Expand into the regions (through franchising)  Develop larger format  Be well positioned to fight eventual competition from other Russian and foreign retailers  Become a strong candidate for an IPO 28 Pyaterochka Plans

29. Conclusion 29 Growth in consumer spending in Russia will further boost development of all retail chains Food retail industry is very fragmented, but entering stage of fast consolidation Suppliers need to set up shop in Russia to do business Excellent opportunities for western Suppliers prepared to invest in Russia Logistics and IT services companies in short supply but translation issues must be tackled Own label manufacturers will have massive demand over next 5 years

30. Contact details 30 Any questions? E mail David Noble Supervisory Board Director Pyaterochka e-mail: dnoble@e5.ru