Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byAsher Gregory Modified over 9 years ago
2
Prefatory comments I am not an expert. I hold degrees in political science and communication, not theoretical physics. The only morally permissible space jokes are Star Wars related.
3
The Resolution Resolved: The United States federal government should substantially increase its exploration and/or development of space beyond the Earth’s mesosphere.
4
Mesosphere Who are the ad wizards who came up with that one? What it is: the zone of the Earth’s atmosphere between the stratosphere and the thermosphere. What it is not (at least not now): a subterranean section of the Earth’s mantle.
5
Mesosphere, cont’d.
6
So, what is out there? Planets Stars Nebulae Galaxies Orbitals and NEOs Dark matter and black holes Solar System
7
The Solar System Terrestrial planets Jovian planets Trans-Neptunian region Asteroid belt Oort cloud
8
American Space Policy Cold War origins (Mercury, Gemini, Apollo) Space Shuttle Space Dominance (Reagan/Bush) End of crewed space flight (Obama)
9
America’s Space Infrastructure NASA DOD NOAA/OSC
10
International Space Context Russia China European Union Japan India ISS OST
11
Space policy at a Cross-Roads Cost, cost, cost Physics Human space flight Private Sector Leadership or Dominance
12
Global space issues Debris Appropriation Finite resources Equitable development Environmental factors
13
Affirmatives 7 Major categories: Colonization Resources Military Space access technology Propulsion Technology Space science Pseudo-topical mechanisms
14
Extra-solar colonization. Inter-generational flight. Von Neumann probes Life-seeding.
15
Inner-solar Colonization Mars: A) Robotic B) Manned C) One-way/Two-way Moon Titan
16
Resources Asteroid/NEO mining Lunar mining Lunar solar power Space Based Solar Power
17
Military affirmatives Space weaponization SBI/BMD ASATs SBL KEWs
18
Space Technology Constellation Reusable launch vehicle Rail-guns Space elevator
19
Propulsion technology Solar sails Nuclear detonations Ion engines Anti-matter
20
Remote exploration Asteroid mapping/defense Deep space/origins research ISS (expand or new) Remote sensing Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI)
21
Pseudo-topical Mechanisms Property rights recognition. Consortiums New international regimes
22
Impact/advantage controversies The Lifeboat Hegemony/Leadership Economy Energy/Environment Space weapons Space debris Whacky stuff Contamination/Viruses International law International relations
23
Aff Cases: Development Colonization Cases Extra-solar colonization Generational star ships Panspermia Von Neumann probes Solar colonization Lunar colonization Martian colonization Orbital colonization
24
Aff Cases: Dev’t [cont’d] Resource Extraction Cases Asteroid mining (NEAs) Lunar mining (He3) Lunar solar power Space solar power (PowerSats)
25
Aff Cases: Dev’t [cont’d] Military Cases Doctrine Forces (Space Forces) Weapons systems/types Missile Defense/SBI Space-Based Lasers (SBL) STEW/Rods from God
26
Aff Cases: Dev’t [cont’d] Space Access Cases Constellation Railgun Reusable launch vehicle Small booster rockets Space elevator Space junk removal Transorbital railroad
27
Aff Cases: Exploration [cont’d] Propulsion development Anti-matter Nuclear/Project Orion Solar sails
28
Aff Cases: Exploration Asteroid mapping/defense Deep space/origins research ISS (expand or new) NEA mission (robotic, crewed) Remote sensing Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI)
29
Aff Cases: Cooperation Joint missions with… China India South Korea
30
Aff Cases: Other (policy) Export controls/ITAR Private space—promote/remove barriers Space Tourism
31
Aff Cases: Other (weird) Astral projection Inner space/transcendental meditation U.S. off the Planet (Churchill) Worm holes/time travel
32
Disadvantage Areas Budget DAs Fiscal discipline Tradeoffs Politics DAs Elections Presidential agenda
33
Disad Areas [cont’d] Space-y DAs Diseases Launch accidents Overcrowding (GSO) Ozone Space junk Space regime credibility/Space law Space weaponization
34
Counterplan Areas Domestic Agents NASA New agency Department of Defense Executive Congress Multilateral Cooperation Private Actor/Prizes
35
Counterplan Areas [cont’d] International Agents (net benefits can be written as disads) China EU Japan Russia Emerging space powers—Brazil, India, South Korea Bilateral Cooperation—same list Advantage CPs
36
Kritik Ground The usual suspects [See: France, philosophy; Germany, philosophy] Capitalism Objectivism Anthropocentrism Escapism Technologism (Heidegger et al.) Space Colonialism Space Security Transhumanism Virilio/Speed
Similar presentations
© 2025 SlidePlayer.com. Inc.
All rights reserved.