Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Money and Direct Democracy in California Professor Richard L. Hasen Loyola Law School, Los Angeles Prepared for presentation at 2010.

Published byMervyn Hodge Modified over 9 years ago

Similar presentations

Presentation on theme: "Money and Direct Democracy in California Professor Richard L. Hasen Loyola Law School, Los Angeles Prepared for presentation at 2010."— Presentation transcript:

1 Money and Direct Democracy in California Professor Richard L. Hasen (rick.hasen@lls.edu) Loyola Law School, Los Angeles Prepared for presentation at 2010 Global Forum on Modern Direct Democracy, San Francisco, CA, August 1, 2010

2 Outline of presentation 1. No era of “hybrid democracy” in California. 2. The connection between candidate elections and ballot measure elections in California 3. The importance of disclosure in California ballot measure elections

3 “Hybrid democracy”  Some predicted era of “hybrid democracy” after 2003 recall election, where initiatives would play greater role in governance  Gov. Schwarzenegger tried to use initiative process to bypass legislature  Over $1.3 billion spent on ballot-measure related activity between 2000 and 2006

4 Passage Rates of California Initiatives Time periodPercentage approved 1912-200234.5% 1970s29% 1980s48% 1990s40% 2000s (through June 2010) 31%

5 California government seen as dysfunctional during period  Perennial budget battles (disagreement over effect of initiatives on budget process)  Record deficits  Divisive fight over Prop. 8  Lots of government reform (open primaries, redistricting), but no constitutional convention

6 Candidate controlled ballot measure committees  No limits on contributions in ballot measure elections because no candidate to corrupt (U.S. Supreme Court CARC case)  Ignores reality of California politics

7 California Elected officials and the Ballot Measure Process  Extensive party involvement  At least 43 candidate-controlled ballot measure committees 1990- 2004, raising at least $84 million  63% of ballot measures feature argument or rebuttal in pamphlet signed by elected official

8 Top Donors to California Recovery Team (controlled by Gov. Schwarzenegger) as of Nov. 1, 2004 NAME OF CONTRIBUTORAMOUNT AMERIQUEST CAPITAL CORPORATION/LONG BEACH ACCEPTANCE CORP$750,000.00 JERRY PERENCHIO LIVING TRUST$750,000.00 MR. ALEX G. SPANOS$500,000.00 WILLIAM LYON HOMES, INC.$250,000.00 AG SPANOS COMPANIES$250,000.00 WILLIAM A. ROBINSON TTEE$250,000.00 AMERICAN STERLING CORPORATION$250,000.00 PAUL F. FOLINO$250,000.00 HEWLETT - PACKARD COMPANY$250,000.00 ROBIN P. ARKLEY II$250,000.00 TWENTIETH CENTURY FOX FILM CORPORATION$200,000.00 TARGET CORPORATION$200,000.00

9 Importance of Disclosure of Funders in Ballot Measure Elections  Prop. 16: would have protected private electrical utility from public utility competition  Total contributions to “Yes” campaign: $40.6 million (amount from PG&E: approximately $40.5 million)  Total contributions to “No” campaigns: approximately $80,000

10 Measure went down to defeat 47% - 53%. Why?

11 Disclosure

Download ppt "Money and Direct Democracy in California Professor Richard L. Hasen Loyola Law School, Los Angeles Prepared for presentation at 2010."

Similar presentations

Political Campaigns: Running for Office

Political Campaigns: Running for Office
A New Century The Progressive Movement p. 465 - 468.

A New Century The Progressive Movement p
Political Parties  Political participation is an important duty of citizens in a democracy.  Political parties are one way for citizens to participate.

Political Parties  Political participation is an important duty of citizens in a democracy.  Political parties are one way for citizens to participate.
Interest Groups and the Political Process Post-Citizens United

Interest Groups and the Political Process Post-Citizens United
Special Interests Have Too Much Power In Sacramento The Result: failed government and a state in crisis Multi-billion dollar budget deficits year after.

Special Interests Have Too Much Power In Sacramento The Result: failed government and a state in crisis Multi-billion dollar budget deficits year after.
ELECTING THE PRES. CHAPTER 10. I. The Preliminaries (4 years) A.All Candidates have to do three things 1. Establish record 2. Develop power base 3. Strategy.

ELECTING THE PRES. CHAPTER 10. I. The Preliminaries (4 years) A.All Candidates have to do three things 1. Establish record 2. Develop power base 3. Strategy.
Campaign Finance. In FAVOR of raising taxes on orphanages Took year-long vacation Proposed a bill that would give TREES the right to vote Is, in fact,

Campaign Finance. In FAVOR of raising taxes on orphanages Took year-long vacation Proposed a bill that would give TREES the right to vote Is, in fact,
California Groups Political Parties in California Interest Groups in California General trends compared –Parties in California versus the nation –Interest.

California Groups Political Parties in California Interest Groups in California General trends compared –Parties in California versus the nation –Interest.
Federal Campaign Finance Law. Federal Election Commission  Established by Congress in 1974, the FEC in an independent agency in the executive branch.

Federal Campaign Finance Law. Federal Election Commission  Established by Congress in 1974, the FEC in an independent agency in the executive branch.
California Voters, Candidates, Campaigns... u Voters u Candidates u Campaigns u Money u Media u Elections, Campaigns, and the Media.

California Voters, Candidates, Campaigns... u Voters u Candidates u Campaigns u Money u Media u Elections, Campaigns, and the Media.
Money and Politics Reference Ch 7.3.

Money and Politics Reference Ch 7.3.
Primary Elections Lecture 6.7. A.A primary election is an election in which voters decide which of the candidates w/in a party will represent the party.

Primary Elections Lecture 6.7. A.A primary election is an election in which voters decide which of the candidates w/in a party will represent the party.
Homework: PP and IGs test on Friday FrontPage: OL on your desk. Describe two ways that interest groups can influence public policy.

Homework: PP and IGs test on Friday FrontPage: OL on your desk. Describe two ways that interest groups can influence public policy.
Government for Sale The Crisis of Money in Politics Aquene Freechild Director, Democracy Is For People Campaign Public Citizen.

Government for Sale The Crisis of Money in Politics Aquene Freechild Director, Democracy Is For People Campaign Public Citizen.
Campaign Finance. 1972/1974 Federal Election Campaign Act (FECA) Creates the FEC –federal election commission to regulate, oversee and enforce campaign.

Campaign Finance. 1972/1974 Federal Election Campaign Act (FECA) Creates the FEC –federal election commission to regulate, oversee and enforce campaign.
Section 1—The Nominating Process Money and the Election Process  The great paradox of modern elections: Money is a corrupting influence but candidates.

Section 1—The Nominating Process Money and the Election Process  The great paradox of modern elections: Money is a corrupting influence but candidates.
As you read… Annotate the text. Be Prepared to Discuss: What did you find most shocking about campaign finance? How are interest groups connected to or.

As you read… Annotate the text. Be Prepared to Discuss: What did you find most shocking about campaign finance? How are interest groups connected to or.
Today’s Agenda Any Announcements? Any Questions? Let's Review our Bellwork.... Now... Let’s Begin Today’s Lesson…..

Today’s Agenda Any Announcements? Any Questions? Let's Review our Bellwork.... Now... Let’s Begin Today’s Lesson…..
Chapter 10.3 Paying for Election Campaigns. Running for Office A campaign for a major office takes a lot of money. A campaign organization runs each campaign.

Chapter 10.3 Paying for Election Campaigns. Running for Office A campaign for a major office takes a lot of money. A campaign organization runs each campaign.
Constitutional and Normative Issues Related to the Regulation of Internet- Based Campaign Activities Under the California Political Reform Act Professor.

Constitutional and Normative Issues Related to the Regulation of Internet- Based Campaign Activities Under the California Political Reform Act Professor.

Similar presentations

Ads by Google