1. TOSCA Normative Types Proposal Internal Working Draft v0.5 Submitter: Matt Rutkowski

2. Proposed Normative (Base) Node Types – Viewed as “layers”

3. Structural Types

4. : RootNodeType – Part 1 Properties nametypePrescription default description name (component name) stringoptionalN/AComponent or service common name This is different than the Node’s “name” attribute or its “ID”. It is a property that can be matched via a requirement. (e.g. for MySQL Community Edition, name=“MySQL CE”) version (component version) stringoptionalN/AComponent or service’s version. (e.g. for “MySQL”, version might be “5.0.9” Definition: The fundamental type that all TOSCA NodeTypes derive from. Interfaces namedescription InstallFormerly “create” configure- start- stop- uninstallFormerly “delete” suspendCIMI, OpenStack pauseCIMI, OpenStack captureCIMI restoreCIMI Requirements namerequirementTypelowerboundupperboundconstraints N/A---- Capabilities namecapabilityTypelowerboundupperboundconstraints N/A--- * Cells shaded in blue indicate suggested new interfaces (operations that correspond to “compute” and “storage”

5. : RootNodeType – Part 2 Definition: The fundamental type that all TOSCA NodeTypes derive from. InstanceStates state Allowed operations description installinguninstallBeing installed. startingstop, uninstallBeing started. startedstop, uninstall (pause, suspend, capture, restore, restart) Available and ready for use. configuring?Should “configure” be assumed to be part of “starting”? stoppingstart, stop, uninstall (restart)Being stopped. stoppedstart, uninstall (capture, restore, restart) Powered off; no saved CPU or memory state. uninstallingBeing uninstalled. Note this applies to a CIMI Machine, CIMI Volume, CIMI Network restartIFF this is justifiable different than a “stop” followed by a “start” pausingBeing paused. Allowable actions : start, restart, and delete. pausedResources remain instantiated ; processing stopped; not enabled for tasks. Allowable actions: start, restart, backup, restore, delete. (sleep) suspendingMachine being suspended. Allowable actions when in this state are: start, restart, and delete. suspendedmachine and its virtual resources are stored on non-volatile storage. (hibernate) errorCIMI Machine, CIMI Volume, CIMI Network capturingCIMI Volume (snapshot), could apply to VMs? availableCIMI Volume (perhaps use started instead?) Notes: If lifecycle operations are sequential (i.e. rely upon script completion) then perhaps allowing operations for “transitional” states do not make sense. Seems to help “imperative” models more so than declarative The set of Potential InstanceState values available for any node:

6. RootNodeType: Tier (this is a “grouping” type) Definition A tier is a topological concept used to describe sets of nodes (or sub-topologies) that can be deployed and managed as a single logical processing element with specific scalability, availability and other group-wise semantics while supporting a specific kind of application processing (sometimes referred to as “roles”). Tiers that support the same kind of application processing are substitutable. The application processing capability of a tier is a function of the kinds of application components which are hosted by its constituent compute elements. The tier’s scaling discipline defines how and when the capacity of the tier is adjusted. Requirements namerequirementTypelowerboundupperboundconstraints N/A---- Capabilities namecapabilityTypelowerboundupperboundconstraints nodesServerContainerCapability0unboundedTBD – It seems that “tiers” should capable of containing any type of nodes not just servers. InstanceStates statedescription N/A- Interfaces nameparmsdescription N/A-- Properties nametypePrescription default description minInstancesintegerRequired1Minimum number of instances for scaling tier (range 1 - N). maxInstancesintegerRequired1Maximum number of instances for scaling tier (range 1 - N). * This is primarily a grouping concept for scaling. Is there a better way?

7. IaaS Types

8. RootNodeType : Compute (formerly Server) Definition An instantiated compute resource that encapsulates both CPU and Memory. Ideally, this would support a “built-in” host OS (or platform API), as many typical / common use cases assume one. Interfaces nameparmsdescription N/A Requirements namerequirementTypelowerboundupperbounddescription containerServerContainerRequirement01Optional. Capabilities namecapabilityTypelowerboundupperbounddescription osOperatingSystemContainerCapability01Optional Runtime Capability VMCapability Properties (ServerProperties) NametypePrescription default descriptionrestriction cpuArchstringOptionalN/A numCpusintegerRequired1Number of CPUs: Number of CPUs (for the virtual machine). How does this value factor with “Tier” for scaling? Note: These could be “virtual” CPUs Restricted only by provider capability? memoryintegerRequiredN/A?Memory (in MB): Amount of memory (for the virtual machine) - Same as above? diskintegerRequiredN/A?Disk (in GB): Amount of disk space to allow execution of the application (e.g. for the Virtual Machine) Perhaps define a type based on “integer” that represents “storage size” Megabytes to be used by both memory and disk properties (and elsewhere) -same as above?

9. RootNodeType : Storage Definition TBD Requirements namerequirementTypelowerboundupperboundconstraints TBD Capabilities namecapabilityTypelowerboundupperboundconstraints TBD InstanceStates statedescription N/A- Interfaces nameparmsdescription N/A Properties nametypePrescription default description TBD

10. RootNodeType : Network Definition TBD Requirements namerequirementTypelowerboundupperboundconstraints TBD Capabilities namecapabilityTypelowerboundupperboundconstraints TBD InstanceStates statedescription N/A- Interfaces nameparmsdescription N/A Properties nametypePrescription default description logicalNamestringLogical network name

11. RootNodeType : OperatingSystem (Optionally merge as a property of “Compute” Node Type) Definition TBD – This is typically a guest OS. Ideally, if indeed for 99% of use cases it is simply an OSType and version would like to flatten this conceptually as properties on Server/VM Requirements namerequirementTypelowerboundupperboundconstraints containerOperatingSystemContainerRequirement11 Capabilities namecapabilityTypelowerboundupperboundconstraints softwareSoftwareContainerCapability0unbounded InstanceStates statedescription N/A- Interfaces nameparmsdescription N/A Properties nametypePrescription default description OSstringOptionalN/AOpeerating System name (e.g. “Ubuntu”). Note: Still an option to to model OS independently. OSVersionstringOptionalN/AOperationg System version (e.g. “12.04)”. Still an option al to model OS independently.

12. Runtime (PaaS) Types

13. RootNodeType : WebServer Definition TBD – Ideally, would like to move towards an “Application Runtime” (indicates additive APIs / language to the OS) since that is its primary purpose. Requirements namerequirementTypelowerboundupperboundconstraints containerSoftwareContainerRequirement11 Capabilities namecapabilityTypelowerboundupperboundconstraints webappsWebApplicationContainerCapability0unbounded InstanceStates statedescription N/A- Interfaces nameparmsdescription N/A Properties nametypePrescription default description N/A

14. RootNodeType : DBMS Definition TBD Requirements namerequirementTypelowerboundupperboundconstraints containerSoftwareContainerRequirement11 Capabilities namecapabilityTypelowerboundupperboundconstraints databasesDatabaseContainerCapability0unbounded InstanceStates statedescription N/A- Interfaces nameparmsdescription N/A Properties nametypePrescription default description N/A

15. Application (Software) Types

16. RootNodeType : SoftwareComponent Definition Provides a simple means to define a generic software component to be modeled and referenced while allowing scripts to be invoked, etc. (Chef cookbooks run etc.) as part of the topology. Requirements namerequirementTypelowerboundupperboundconstraints Capabilities namecapabilityTypelowerboundupperboundconstraints InstanceStates statedescription N/A- Interfaces nameparmsdescription Properties nametypePrescription default description TBD

17. RootNodeType : WebApplication Definition TBD – “Web” is unecessary, any “Application” with exported endpoints is valid, perhaps just use “Application” Requirements namerequirementTypelowerboundupperboundconstraints containerSoftwareContainerRequirement11 Capabilities namecapabilityTypelowerboundupperboundconstraints N/A InstanceStates statedescription N/A- Interfaces nameparmsdescription N/A Properties nametypePrescription default description N/A

18. RootNodeType : Database Definition TBD Requirements namerequirementTypelowerboundupperboundconstraints containerDatabaseContainerRequirement11 Capabilities namecapabilityTypelowerboundupperboundconstraints clientsDatabaseEndpointCapability (ConnectionTarget?) 0unbounded InstanceStates statedescription N/A- Interfaces nameparmsdescription N/A Properties nametypePrescription default description TBD DBNameLogical DB Name DBUserAdmin only? DBPasswordAdmin only? DBPortCould this be supplied by “connection” along with IP?

19. Composite Node Types (Need mechanism for compositing nodes for substitution)

20. AppLayer (Composite NodeType) (as a Service Template) AppLayer (Composite NodeType) (as a Service Template) PaaSLayer (Composite NodeType) (as a Service Template) -At its simplest a, “ApplicationRuntime” environment PaaSLayer (Composite NodeType) (as a Service Template) -At its simplest a, “ApplicationRuntime” environment IaaSLayer (Composite NodeType) (as a Service Template) IaaSLayer (Composite NodeType) (as a Service Template) Public (Quantum) Network Public (Quantum) Network SugarCRM with abstract Layers (Node Types) allowing substitution VM (Nova) Compute VM (Nova) Compute Apache WebServer Apache WebServer SugarCRMApp Web Application SugarCRMApp Web Application Linux Operating System Linux Operating System 1..n IaaSLayer Layer IaaSLayer Layer PaaSLayer Layer PaaSLayer Layer Storage (Cinder) Storage Storage (Cinder) Storage == hostedOn PHPModule Apache Module PHPModule Apache Module DependsOn hostedOn DependsOn SugarCRMApp Web Application SugarCRMApp Web Application hostedOn DependsOn

21. RootNodeType : ApplicationRuntime (Composite Runtime Environment) Definition Implies a WebServer + one or more LangaugeRuntimes (e.g. PHP, Java, etc.)? Requirements namerequirementTypelowerboundupperboundconstraints Capabilities namecapabilityTypelowerboundupperboundconstraints InstanceStates statedescription N/A- Interfaces nameparmsdescription RuntimesDictionary of language runtimes/versions? (e.g. “Java” “6.0”, “Python” “2.6”, etc.) TBD Properties nametypePrescription default description TBD

22. RelationshipTypes

23. : RootRelationshipType Abstract Interfaces nameparmsdescription preConfigureOptionalTBDNodes on either end of any relationship should support a “pre- configuration” operation (e.g. “preConnect”) configureOptionalTBDNodes on either end of any relationship should support a “configuration” operation (e.g. “connect”) postConfigureOptionalTBDNodes on either end of any relationship should support a “post- configuration” operation. (e.g. “postConnect”) Properties nametypePrescription default description Definition The fundamental type that all TOSCA RelationshipTypes derive from. InstanceStates statedescription N/A-

24. RootRelationshipType : HostedOn ValidSource typeRefdescription ContainerRequirementRootRequirementType ValidTarget namedescription ContainerCapabilityRootCapabilityType Interfaces nameparmsdescription TBD Properties nametypePrescription default description TBD Definition Relationship that indicates a node can “host” or contain another node of a specified type. For example: a Database node is “hostedOn” a DBMS (Database Management System) node a WebServer node is “hostedOn” a n OperatingSystem node. InstanceStates statedescription N/A-

25. RootRelationshipType : ConnectsTo ValidSource typeRefdescription EndpointRequirementRootRequirementType ValidTarget namedescription EndpointCapabilityRootCapabilityType Interfaces nameparmsdescription TBD Properties nametypePrescription default description TBD Definition Relationship that indicates a node can “connect” to another node of a specified type. For example: A WebApplication node “connectsTo” a Database node. Known Subclasses IPEndpointRequreiment, HTTPEndpointRequirement, IPEndpointCapability, HTTPEndpointCapability Can we not flatten??? Using properties such as “protocol” (or protocol list?) InstanceStates statedescription N/A-

26. RootRelationshipType : DependsOn ValidSource typeRefdescription FeatureRequirementRootRequirementType ValidTarget namedescription FeatureCapabilityRootCapabilityType Interfaces nameparmsdescription TBD Properties nametypePrescription default description TBD Definition Relationship that indicates a node is “dependent” on another node of a specified type. For example: A PHP runtime “dependsOn”an Apache web server InstanceStates statedescription N/A-

27. ArtifactTypes

28. : RootArtifactType Definition The fundamental type that all TOSCA Artifact Types derive from. Known Subclasses name="ScriptArtifact" PropertiesDefinition element="tns:ScriptArtifactProperties" name="FileArtifact“ None name="ArchiveArtifact“ PropertiesDefinition element="tns:ArchiveArtifactProperties" name="OsPackageArtifact“ PropertiesDefinition element="tns:OsPackageArtifactProperties“ name="UserContentArtifact“ PropertiesDefinition element="tns:UserContentArtifactProperties“ name="RPMGroupArtifact“ PropertiesDefinition element="tns:RPMGroupArtifactProperties"

29. SugarCRM Variant Use Cases

30. WebTier ScalableTier WebTier ScalableTier ApacheVM Compute ApacheVM Compute Apache WebServer Apache WebServer SugarCRMApp Web Application SugarCRMApp Web Application DBTier Tier DBTier Tier MySqlVM Server MySqlVM Server MySQL DBMS MySQL DBMS SugarCRM Database SugarCRM Database ApacheLinuxOS Operating System ApacheLinuxOS Operating System MySqlLinuxOS Operating System MySqlLinuxOS Operating System Advanced SugarCRM Scenario: SugarCRM with Networking 1..n 1 1 Public Network Public Network Private Network Private Network hostedOn PHPModule Apache Module PHPModule Apache Module DependsOn hostedOn ConnectsTo

31. WebTier ScalableTier WebTier ScalableTier ApacheVM Compute ApacheVM Compute Apache WebServer Apache WebServer SugarCRMApp Web Application SugarCRMApp Web Application DBTier Tier DBTier Tier MySqlVM Server MySqlVM Server MySQL DBMS MySQL DBMS SugarCRM Database SugarCRM Database ApacheLinuxOS Operating System ApacheLinuxOS Operating System MySqlLinuxOS Operating System MySqlLinuxOS Operating System Advanced SugarCRM Scenario: SugarCRM with Storage 1..n 1 1 Public Storage Public Storage Private Strorage Private Strorage hostedOn PHPModule Apache Module PHPModule Apache Module DependsOn hostedOn ConnectsTo

32. Reference Slides Follow

33. ... ? ? … ? + ?... ?... + + ? ( XML fragment ? … ? + XML fragment ? … ? ? + XML fragment ?... ? ? artifact specific content ? + ? | … ) + TOSCA Service Template schema

34. XML fragment + ? <PropertyConstraint property="...“ constraintType="xs:anyURI"> + constraint ? ? + ? + ? policy specific content ? + ? ( | | ) + ? ? TOSCA Boundary Definitions Schema

35. <NodeType name="xs:NCName" targetNamespace="xs:anyURI"? abstract="yes|no"? final="yes|no"?> + ? ? ? <RequirementDefinition name="..." requirementType="..." lowerBound="xs:integer"? upperBound="xs:integer |..."?> constraint type specific content + ? + ? <CapabilityDefinition name="..." capabilityType="..." lowerBound="xs:integer"? upperBound="xs:integer |..."?> constraint type specific content + ? + + ? <InputParameter name="..." type="..." required="yes|no"?/> + ? <OutputParameter name="..." type="..." required="yes|no"?/> + ? + ? NodeType XML schema

36. <RelationshipType name="xs:NCName" targetNamespace="xs:anyURI"? abstract="yes|no"? final="yes|no"?> + + ? ? ? + ?... + ?... + ? ? ? + RelationshipType

37. WebTier Service Template WebTier Service Template DBTier Service Template DBTier Service Template WebTier ScalableTier WebTier ScalableTier ApacheVM Server ApacheVM Server Apache WebServer Apache WebServer SugarCRMApp Web Application SugarCRMApp Web Application DBTier Tier DBTier Tier MySqlVM Server MySqlVM Server MySQL DBMS MySQL DBMS SugarCRM Database SugarCRM Database ApacheLinuxOS Operating System ApacheLinuxOS Operating System MySqlLinuxOS Operating System MySqlLinuxOS Operating System Advanced Scenarios: “Scalable SugarCRM Web Application” ApacheLB LoadBalancer ApacheLB LoadBalancer “Tier” Node Types convey scalability The “Web Application Tier” is declared Scalable with upper bounds “n” instances  Note: the “Database Tier” remains a single instance A Load Balancer node is added to the previous template to route requests among “Web Application Tier” instances Both tiers are packaged into their own service templates permitting Substitution 1..n 1 1 The range of instances would be a property of the “Tier” Node Type Components grouped into composable service templates. Scalability