1. Submission Indonesian National Internet Registry [NIR-ID] IDNIC Program Information-Internet Society of Indonesia [ISOC-ID] http://www.isoc-id.org Taipei, 28 - 31 August 2001 APNIC Meeting

2. ISOC-ID Profile The ISOC-ID is a non profit, non-governmental, research, education, and national-international professional membership organization Secretariat Grha Citra Caraka, Mezzanine Floor Jln Jend. Gatot Subroto 52, JK, 12710, ID V: +62-21 5296 3841 F: +62-21 5296 3844 M:+62-82 184 4444 National Internet Registry Office [NIRO] INDONESIA INSTITUTE Of SCIENCES - LIPI Sasana Widya Jln Jend. Gatot Subroto 10 JK, 12710, ID V: +62-21 522 5711 F: +62-21 527 7125

3. MISION Development, maintenance, evolution, and dissemination of standards for the Internet and its internetworking technologies and applications in Indonesia; Growth and evolution of the Internet architecture [packetized] in Indonesia; Maintenance and evolution of effective administrative processes necessary for operation of the global Internet. Education and research related to the Internet and open-system resources internetworking; Harmonization of actions and activities at international levels to facilitate the development and availability of the Internet; Collection and dissemination of information related to the Internet and internetworking, including histories and archives;

4. ISOC-ID STRUCTURE ISOC-ID NATIONAL Executive Boards 5 Year Electoral Process Member 32 Provinces 1.ISOC-BALI 2.ISOC-WEST SUMATRA 3.ISOC-WEST JAV 4.ISOC-EAST JAVA 5.ISOC-NORTH SUMATRA 6.ISOC-JAKARTA 7.ISOC-BANTEN 8.ISOC-CENTRAL JAVA. 32. ISOC-GORONTALO Independent Organization Industries Support Association Non Profit Org NGO Information Societies Governmental Bodies

5. PROGRAM STRUCTURE

6. ISOC-ID Supporting Organization [IIDSO] [1] MAHATEL, PT [http://www.maha.net.id] Packet Switched Public Data Network [PSPDN] Provider [2] BROADBAND MULTIMEDIA, PT [http://www.kabelvision.com] Network Service Provider [NSP], Network Access Point [NAP] Provider Broadband/HFC Provider [3] NAPSINDO PRIMATEL INTERNATIONAL, PT [http://www.napsindo.net] Network Access Point [NAP] Provider [4] ID DOMREG [http://www.idnic.net.id] cc-TLD Indonesian Domain Registration [5] INDONESIAN INSTITUTE OF SCIENCE – LIPI [http://www.lipi.go.id] Government Science Research & Development

7. PROGRAMS [1] Information-Infrastructure a. Neutral Public eXchange Point [NPXP] b. National Internet Registry [NIR] - IDNIC * IP Registration * AS Registration - ID-TLD * g-TLD Domain Registration * cc-TLD Domain Registration [2] National Public Key Infrastructure [N-PKI] a. Standard Working Group b. Publishing Network Implementation Ready

8. Indonesian Network Information Center [IDNIC] 1. Commercial ISP APJII-ID Federation [http://www.apjii.or.id] and [http://www.idnic.net.id] 2. Non-Commercial ISP : GovNIC [nic.go.id] All Government Offices are banned to use Commercial ISPs including IP Addresses & Ass related to Indonesia Country Gateway Initiatif MilNIC [nic.mil.id] All Military Offices are banned to use Commercial ISPs including IP Addresses & ASs 3. Ordinary ISP Non-ISP license or other license based Others Network Provider

9. Multi-homing If multi-homing becomes a common option of corporate customers, then what happening is that the function of providing resiliency within a network has shift from a value- added role within the network to that of customer responsibility. And if customers are not prepared to pay for highly robust network services from any single ISP then there is little economic incentive for any single ISP to spend additional money to engineer robustness within their service. From that perspective, what ISP industry appears to be heading into is a case of a somewhat disturbing self-fulfilling prophesy of minimalist network engineer with no margin for error. http://www.isoc.org/issues/003

10. Indonesian – Top Level Domain [ID-TLD] (Propose to ICANN : http://www.tld.net.id) 1. cc-TLD Existing : http://www.idnic.net.id Proposed to ICANN : http://domain.net.id 2. g-TLD : Proposed to ICANN : http://www.gtld.net.id

11. Information-Internet Infrastructure Development of ISOC-ID Plan Request to have APNIC Membership Member name : IDNIC.NET Membership Type : VERY LARGE MEMBERSHIP Assignment for Back-end Infrastructures Redistribute and Allocation IP Addresses and Aut-num National Internet Registry [NIR] of APNIC ISOC-ID will request for NIR of APNIC 32 ISOC-Provinces to be LIR of ISOC-ID Website : http://www.isoc-id.org/idnicttp://www.isoc-id.org/idnicttp://www.isoc-id.org/idnic We want to propose http://www.idnic.net

12. Policy Issues [Source : e-mail’s between APNIC – ISOC-ID] Confederation Membership is suspended, but the role of these previous members are not suspended. NIR Membership and Charter are not well established however, NIR in several countries are officially established by APNIC. Un-clear/similar definition of LIR and ISP. Which ISP Definition ? By RFC References or by ISP License from each Government that we have to put into policy documents of APNIC [ The policy request for ISP Licenses from Indonesia’s Government by sending its copy to APNIC ] Under which policy is it mentioned ? Are other members/countries treated the same way by APNIC?

13. OTHER ISSUE Proposal NEW Regional Internet Registry [RIR] for Asia Region. Background ICANN ICP-2 : Criteria for Establishment of New Regional Internet Registry [RIR] http://www.iana.org/icp/icp-2.htm Why ISOC-ID Propose This Issue ? In consideration of RFC 1951 and other related RFCs; the process of adding new RIRs (and therefore new hostmasters) should be proposed by ASIAN Internet Societies to IETF (ISOC). Similary with LATINIC for Latin America countries and AFRINIC for African countries.

14. Emerging New RIR Candidates [1] African Network Information Center [AFRINIC] http://www.afrinic.org [2] Asia Network Information Center [ASIANIC] [3] Pacific Network Information Center [PACNIC] [4] Latin America & Caribbean Network Information Center [LACNIC] http://www.lacnic.org Source : http://www.iana.org/icp/icp-2.htm

15. EMERGING NEW RIR MAPPING [PLAN]

16. CONCLUSION ISOC-ID is a neutral body that serves & facilitates public demand on Information Internet Facilities. International participation on membership, contribution, and establishment of the Information Infrastructure affordability, dynamical, stability and reach ability to the people. The Internet Society has strongly supported IDNIC Program as the best hope a nongovernmental approach to Internet governance. The future of IDNIC depends on its ability to develop international support for its programs and to build a stable financial base. The sometimes conflicting interests of governments, of the operators of the country code top-level domains, and of various nongovernmental parties cannot be resolved without serious attention to a variety of public policy issues. These include questions about the primacy of public interest versus commercial interests, the continuing role of the Internet Society, and the continuing conflict between the needs of trademark owners and the interests of Internet users in expanding the domain name space. ISOC-ID will support public policy such as Access, Censorship, Children and the internet, Copyright, Digital divide, Domain Name Systems, E-Commerce, Encryption, Privacy, Security, Societal, Spamming, Woman and the internet, and others public policy. Internet is for Everyone