1. Unity in Diversity, ETDs at UNT : and a look towards BibFrame Ralph Hartsock and Daniel Gelaw Alemneh University of North Texas Texas Music Library Association University of North Texas, Denton, Texas October 3, 2014

2. Panelists:  Ralph Hartsock Senior Music Catalog Librarian University of North Texas Libraries Ralph.Hartsock@unt.eduRalph.Hartsock@unt.edu  Daniel Alemneh Digital Curation Coordinator University of North Texas Libraries Daniel.Alemneh@unt.eduDaniel.Alemneh@unt.edu

3. Objectives Compare 8 cases of ETD or dissertation treatment Offer models in RDA to remedy some of these Looks at certain aspects and pitfalls of BibFrame

4.  Digital Projects  Metadata for each item  Audio Center staff adds metadata for sound recordings  Access to the PDF files  Access to Recordings  Local usage of audio files  Cataloging  Metadata for international audience  Unification of all metadata, PDF files, recordings  Linkage between various files, audio or text

5.  Variables includes UNT and other universities’ requirements for DMA. UNT seems to require more substantiation in recitals and a more academic thesis. The subject of the lecture unifies the final recital.  Osvaldo Lacerda's Sonata for flute and piano (1959): a performance guide with historical background of Brazilian genres embolada, seresta, and baião  Responsibility Marilia Gabriela do Nascimento Gimenes, B.M., M.M.  THESIS/DISS Publication Info Publication Info: Denton, Texas: University of North Texas, 2012  Copyright Notice Date Copyright Notice Date: ©2012  Series Series: NT dissertation, Music; 2012

6.  Permanent link is http://iii.library.unt.edu/record=b4431151~S 12 http://iii.library.unt.edu/record=b4431151~S 12

7. Advantages:  Unified or integrated bibliographic record of the document, all recitals, and the lecture recital.  Topic has focus: Title created by student  OCLC users may see the entirety of links, and observe listed contents online, including contents of the audio recording itself.  Like other streamed recording, only those in the UNT community of users can listen to the audio.  Curation controlled by Digital Projects

8. Limitation:  OCLC record has access points only for the document, not all the recordings.

9.  Michael C. Thursby  Recital, a physical manifestation, with printed abstract as accompanying material  Advantage: OCLC access points to specific pieces  CDs available for local circulation  RDAizing the record creates links

10.  Michael C. Thursby  RDAizing the record creates links ◦ Relationship designators: composer author instrumentalist sponsoring body Container of (work)

12.  Thesis by Anastasios Polis  Thesis and six supplementary recordings, including interviews and concerts  Advantage: OCLC access to each manifestation  Disadvantage: None is linked

13.  Thesis by Anastasios Polis  RDAizing the record creates links, that are reciprocal  The annotated thematic index is augmented by each recording.  Each recording augments the annotated thematic index.

14.  [Tiffany Damicone recital]  No paper dissertation with recital  No lecture, no unifying text  Title devised by cataloguer

15.  Juliana Yap  Document only. No recitals in the library.  No recitals online.  Theme of unity, without performances  Recitals did occur, but the programs and recordings may reside within the Music Department.

16.  Isaac Bustos  Four disjointed recitals  But the program of the last recital is the title of the lecture: Un Tiempo Fue Italica Famosa: A Synthesis of Joaquin Rodrigo’s Composition Styles  Minimal level cataloging given to these recordings  Contrived titles, less tangible; one could have been distinctive

18.  Name changes, even from a change in the manifestation of the same work  Barbara C. Phillips Farley  Entered as Farley, Barbara C. Phillips. For the 1991 dissertation  Entered as Phillips-Farley, Barbara, ǂe author. For the digitized 1991 dissertation

19.  Previous policy at UNT was to unite all manifestations of the dissertations.  Advantage: expediency, allowing one to simply change local system, III  Disadvantages: Manifestations are not reflected in OCLC  Interlibrary Loan may bypass UNT, even though there is an available copy, but in long term, digital will prevail.  Solution: RDA allows linkages such as “Reproduction of” or “Reproduced as”.

21. Streaming Audio available only at UNT Audio discs or streaming audio available locally.  UNT Practice treats lecture as unifying element/title  Bibliographic record resembles a kit with accompanying material  Links are made.  Audio contents available to view.  Better long term management.  Other models  Leave disjointed performances, unlinked  Ignore the performance altogether  Require contrived titles, with less tangibility

22. BibFrame http://www.loc.gov/bibframe/ Bibliographic Framework Initiative Initiated by the Library of Congress, BIBFRAME provides a foundation for the future of bibliographic description, both on the web, and in the broader networked world.

23. Bibframe page

24. Bibframe features

25. Currently in MaRCSimilar to Dublin core  RDA / FRBR  Work  Expression  Manifestation  Item  Bibliographic Framework (BibFrame)  Creative Work  Instance  Authority  Annotation

26. MARC FormatBibframe  382 is machine readable field for Medium of Performance  If the musicMediumNote, equals 382, then the number of performers may not be usable  If it is musicMedium, then the Note would be for textual reading.  Certain MARC fields have not had a parallel BF field: 347 (Digital characteristics)

27.  Christopher Lamb: Blueline concerto as authority   Blueline concerto   Lamb, Christopher, 1989- 

28.  Blueline concerto   ARK: ark:/67531/metadc283800   DOI = Digital Object Identifier  Derived from BIBFRAME Relationships Draft Specification — 25 April 2014 http://www.loc.gov/bibframe/docs/bibframe-relationships.htmlhttp://www.loc.gov/bibframe/docs/bibframe-relationships.html

29. Visits from 200+ Countries : http://digital.library.unt.edu/explore/collections/UNTETD/browse/ http://digital.library.unt.edu/explore/collections/UNTETD/browse/