1. 1 Systems Analysis Advisory Committee (SAAC) Tuesday February 10, 2004 Michael Schilmoeller John Fazio

2. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 2 Agenda Welcome Back! Overview of methods Presentation of candidate plan Models and modeling Algorithms Next meeting

3. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 3 Similar to Everyday Decision Making under Uncertainty Analogy with choosing transportation Cost and benefits Risks –Accidents Likelihood Protection afforded –Likelihood and cost of breakdowns and repairs –Missed meetings or appointments Overview of Methods

4. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 4 The Analysis Possible “futures” Likelihood of those circumstances Bad outcomes

5. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 5 The Trade-off The choice of transportation depends on how we weight the costs or benefits and the risk associated with that choice 3456789 10 Cost -> 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 Risk -> A B

6. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 6 Decision Making Terms Risk –A measure of bad outcomes Variation –Normal changes in outcome, which may be highly predictable Uncertainty –The predictability of outcomes

7. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 7 Decision Making Terms An example of variation is average daily temperature over the course of a year Time (a year) Temperature

8. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 8 Decision Making Terms For any particular day, the uncertainty in daily temperature can be large. Time (a year) Temperature ?

9. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 9 Decision Making Terms Plans –Future actions we can control Example: buy a 1978 Toyota corolla Futures –Future situations we can not control Example: A automobile crash in the local intersection Scenarios –Combinations of plans and futures Example: how did your Toyota fare in the crash

10. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 10 Power Plan Futures Behavior for key variables –Power requirements –Natural gas price –Hydro generation –Electricity market price –Aluminum price –CO2 tax –Power plant availability Variation and uncertainty, including jumps and complex paths; Relationships among these

11. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 11 Power Plans Specific recommendations, capacity and timing, for the construction of new additions over the next 20 years –CCCT –SCCT –Conservation –Price responsive demand –Wind –Coal

12. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 12 Example of a Particular Plan

13. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 13 Power Plans We do not make decisions before we need to do so. We want as much information as possible before making a commitment Therefore, we want to focus on the “Implementation Plan” that identifies actions over the next three to five years. Preparing a 20-year plan enables us to assure our short-term implementation plan create no long-term risk and does not preclude important long-term planning options. (We want to understand the strategic significance of our short-term actions.)

14. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 14 Power Cost (¢/kWh)-> Number of Observations Cost for Future 2 Cost for Future 1 Distribution of Cost for a Plan 1.002.003.004.005.006.007.008.009.00 10.00

15. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 15 Risk and Expected Cost Associated With A Plan Likelihood (Probability) Avg Cost 1.002.003.004.005.006.007.008.009.00 10.00 Power Cost (¢/kWh)-> Risk = average of costs> 90% threshold

16. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 16 A Different Plan: The Trade-off Likelihood (Probability) Risk Avg Cost 1.002.003.004.005.006.007.008.009.00 10.00 Power Cost (¢/kWh)->

17. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 17 Trade-off Basic information about the trade-off between cost and risk 3456789 10 Cost (cents/kWh) -> 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 Risk (cents/kWh) -> A B

18. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 18 Insights Insights into –What a plan costs –How we expect it to perform –What the risks are How does the plan perform under specific futures? What are the chances we may see these futures?

19. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 19 Agenda Welcome Back! Overview of methods Presentation of candidate plan Models and modeling Algorithms Next meeting

20. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 20 Research the cost and potential for regional demand response (DR) –Preliminary studies suggest DR significantly reduces both risk and cost Continue support of conservation –Conservation additions at levels above those determined by market price reduces risk at little expected cost –At least a 5 mill/kWh premium The region appears to have sufficient conventional resources for the next four to five years, although individual load-serving entities or customers may have vastly different risk-management situations Recommendations

21. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 21 Without Demand Response 4.24 Cost (cents/kWh) -> Risk (cents/kWh) -> 4.26 4.28 4.30 4.32 4.714.73 4.75 4.77 Least cost: –500MW of CCCT today –500MW of Wind Generation after 2006 –Incent dispatchable conservation at 0.50 ¢/kWh

22. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 22 Without Demand Response 4.24 Cost (cents/kWh) -> Risk (cents/kWh) -> 4.26 4.28 4.30 4.32 4.714.73 4.75 4.77 Least risk: –Incent dispatchable conservation at 2.50 ¢/kWh

23. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 23 With Demand Response 4.24 Cost (cents/kWh) -> Risk (cents/kWh) -> 4.26 4.28 4.30 4.32 4.714.73 4.75 4.77 Demand Response moves the entire trade- off curve to the left

24. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 24 Agenda Welcome Back! Overview of methods Presentation of candidate plan Models and modeling –Trade-Off: The construction of the efficient frontier –Estimating the distributions –Examination of futures –Representation of resources –Load/Resource balance Algorithms Next meeting

25. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 25 Risk and Expected Cost Associated With A Plan Likelihood (Probability) Avg Cost 1.002.003.004.005.006.007.008.009.00 10.00 Power Cost (¢/kWh)-> Risk = average of costs> 90% threshold

26. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 26 The Source of the Trade-Off Increasing Cost Increasing Risk Alternative Plans

27. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 27 Space of feasible solutions Efficient Frontier Increasing Risk Increasing Cost Alternative Risk Levels Efficient Frontier

28. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 28 Finding the Efficient Frontier We are really only interested in the efficient frontier: “Risk-Constrained Least-Cost Planning”

29. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 29 Finding the Efficient Frontier How many plans are there in our feasibility space? A few.... In our modeling, we have examined levels of six resources at eight time periods (2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2013, 2018)

30. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 30 The Process We can reduce the number of states by requiring that no capacity, once added, may be “de- constructed.” With this constraint, we have merely 2.7 x 10 15 plans, or so.

31. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 31 Finding the Efficient Frontier The solution? Use a stochastic optimization program

32. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 32 Finding the Efficient Frontier Does distribution meet risk constraint? Pick an arbitrary plan and arbitrary risk constraint Determine distribution of costs for plan Look for a plan with lower cost Look for a plan with lower risk Does distribution have lowest cost? no

33. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 33 Agenda Welcome Back! Overview of methods Presentation of candidate plan Models and modeling –Trade-Off: The construction of the efficient frontier –Estimating the distributions –Examination of futures –Representation of resources –Load/Resource balance Algorithms Next meeting

34. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 34 Cost Distribution Associated With a Plan Hourly demand Coal Buy in Market Sell in Market Gas Fired Price-driven generation Hydro Contracts Hydro Total Resources Year 1 SummerWinter Year 2 SummerWinter Background

35. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 35 Modeling Issues In principle, we could perform our calculation on an hour-by-hour basis Time to make one of those “order-of- magnitude” calculations!

36. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 36 Modeling Issues Let’s say, we have a very smart optimizer that can find the efficient frontier by examining only 500 plans To estimate the 10 th percentile tail of a distribution, we need at least 500 futures, each representing 20 years of assumed hydro, fuel cost, loads, etc.

37. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 37 Modeling Issues We therefore would need to make 8760 hrs/year*20 years/study*500 studies/plan*500 plans/optimization = 43.8 billion hourly calculations Clearly some approximation/sampling/aggregation is in order!

38. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 38 Modeling Issues A natural thing to do is to aggregate the time scale, and that is exactly what we have done. However, in calculating things like cost using aggregate statistics, we need to be careful with things like correlation For example, computing cost when quantity and price are related is tricky

39. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 39 Using Valuation To Estimate Cost Average cost, given average price E(p) and average quantity E(q) is given by

40. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 40 Using Valuation To Estimate Cost Resource q i load Q market requirement

41. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 41 Using Valuation To Estimate Cost Costs using “rate base” calculation these are usually correlated! But how??

42. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 42 Using Valuation To Estimate Cost Costs using “valuation” calculation

43. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 43 Using Valuation To Estimate Cost The valuation formula simplifies the cost calculation, because we only have to consider how each resource’s cost and dispatch relate to the market (rather than to each other) –electric market price to total loads (probably strongly positively correlated) –electric market price to wind generation (uncorrelated) –electric market price to turbine generation (directly related to correlation with fuel price)

44. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 44 Our calculation times Recall the purpose of all this was to make our calculation times more manageable....

45. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 45 Our calculation times Using 160 periods per 20 year study –80 hydro-year quarters (Sept-Nov, Dec-Feb, March-May, June-Aug), on- and off-peak –About 1-2 seconds (5-8 iterations for RRP*) Using 750 trials (futures) per plan About 17 minutes per plan For 1000 plans, this ordinarily would take 12 days, but....

46. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 46 Our calculation times... Using parallel processing on six machines afforded by Decisioneering’s CB Turbo, we can perform this in two days.... With twelve machines, in one day...... You get the picture. Cost of Crystal Ball Professional: $1600 Cost of CB Turbo: $2500

47. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 47 Real Feasibility Spaces Current spaces

48. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 48 Real Feasibility Spaces Earlier space, more representative of situation with relatively greater risk!

49. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 49 Measures of Central Tendency The median and mean for these plans are closely related Using the mean cost is probably fine

50. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 50 Risk Measures Along the efficient frontier, the risk measures tend to converge

51. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 51 Risk Measures Along the efficient frontier, the risk measures tend to converge

52. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 52 Risk Measures Along the efficient frontier, the risk measures tend to converge

53. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 53 Risk Measures Along the efficient frontier, the risk measures tend to converge

54. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 54 Our Models The meta-model: Olivia The portfolio model: Olivia’s “daughter”

55. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 55 Olivia Creates Crystal Ball-aware Excel workbooks that run under OptQuest/CB Turbo Uses a database for model structure and data reuse –Special editing features and capabilities for duplicating and extending models, while preserving previous versions Permits the user to model their own system

56. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 56 Olivia

57. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 57 Olivia

58. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 58 Olivia

59. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 59 Olivia

60. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 60 Olivia The relationship among records in the database reflects the structure of calculations in an Excel workbook Structure.pdfStructure.pdf

61. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 61 Olivia’s Daughter The Crystal Ball-aware Excel workbook that run under OptQuest/CB Turbo is the “Portfolio model,” or “Olivia’s daughter” Current regional model (L4.xls) hasL4.xls –80 hydro quarters, on- and off-peak –One region –Imports and exports of 4000 MWa –30 resources, including hydro, commercial hydro response, conservation supply curves for lost opportunity conservation and “dispatchable” conservation, smelter response to aluminum and power prices, planning flex.....

62. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 62 Agenda Welcome Back! Overview of methods Presentation of candidate plan Models and modeling –Trade-Off: The construction of the efficient frontier –Estimating the distributions –Examination of futures –Representation of resources –Load/Resource balance Algorithms Next meeting

63. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 63 Futures A workbook has been prepared that illustrates the 750 futures we have used. Graph of Futures.xls

64. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 64 Agenda Welcome Back! Overview of methods Presentation of candidate plan Models and modeling –Trade-Off: The construction of the efficient frontier –Estimating the distributions –Examination of futures –Representation of resources –Load/Resource balance Algorithms Next meeting

65. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 65 Representation of resources How are the main resource candidates represented in this model?

66. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 66 Agenda Welcome Back! Overview of methods Presentation of candidate plan Models and modeling –Trade-Off: The construction of the efficient frontier –Estimating the distributions –Examination of futures –Representation of resources –Load/Resource balance Algorithms Next meeting

67. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 67 Load/Resource balance What is the representation of the remaining resources? Coal:5,115 Gas 5,659 Other: 1,490 Hydro12000 sum24,265

68. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 68 Load/Resource balance

69. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 69 Agenda Welcome Back! Overview of methods Presentation of candidate plan Models and modeling Algorithms –Dispatch –Resource-responsive price (RRP) –Planning flexibility –Long-term price response: DSIs and other industrial loads –Supply curves for conservation and for commercial use of hydro –Stochastic hydrogeneration based on 50-year stream flow record Next meeting

70. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 70 Typical Dispatchable Example of 1 MW Single Cycle Combustion Turbine (no dispatch constraints) Natural Gas price, $3.33/MBTU Heat rate, 9000 BTU/kWh Price of electricity generated from gas, $30/MWh Representations - thermal Value: note: we assuming the entire capacity is switched on when the turbine runs

71. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 71 Price Duration Curve If we assume each hour’s dispatch is independent, we can ignore the chronological structure. Sorting by price yields the market price duration curve (MCD) Value V is this area Representations - thermal

72. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 72 Digression to Options The value of an option is the expected value of the discounted payoff (See Hull, 3 rd ed., p. 295) Representations - thermal

73. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 73 European spread option The Margrabe pricing formula for the value of a spread option, assuming no yields Representations - thermal

74. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 74 Variability viewed as CDF Turning the MCD curve on its side, we get something that looks like a cumulative probability density function (CDF) Value V is this area Representations - thermal

75. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 75 Dispatch Model: Conclusion –Thermal dispatch can be reasonably well using a spread call option on electricity and gas –The monthly capacity factor of the thermal unit is provided by the “delta” of the option, that is, the change in the option’s price (value) with respect to the underlying spread –The standard Black-Scholes model for option pricing gives a good estimate of the plant value and capacity factor, with these adjustments: The risk free discount rate r is 0 Time to maturity T=1 The hourly price volatility on ln(p t /p t-1 ) is  Representations - thermal

76. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 76 Example of Spread Option

77. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 77 Agenda Welcome Back! Overview of methods Presentation of candidate plan Models and modeling Algorithms –Dispatch –Resource-responsive price (RRP) –Planning flexibility –Long-term price response: DSIs and other industrial loads –Supply curves for conservation and for commercial use of hydro –Stochastic hydrogeneration based on 50-year stream flow record Next meeting

78. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 78 Influence Diagram Independent Effects

79. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 79 Dependence on Influences Wholesales power prices as we currently model them reflect changes in –Natural Gas Prices in the PNW –Loads in the PNW (specifically on-peak loads) –Hydrogeneration Modeled as a sensitivity to these

80. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 80 Role of Independent Term Jumps and excursions unrelated to key fundamental drivers Unincorporated fundamental influences –e.g., new technology Unanticipated non-fundamentals –Policy changes e.g., price caps –Psychology in the markets

81. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 81 Consequence of Independent Term Prices are not a well-defined function of natural gas prices, loads, or hydro (“key drivers”) Fixing key drivers does not fix the price A given price can reflect many different levels of key drivers. In particular, Price is to a certain extent independent of any key variable

82. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 82 Well-Defined Function A machine that always gives you “Y” every time you put in “X.”

83. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 83 Problems In an open system, such as for a single market participant, who is a price taker, all this works fine. But... Intuition tells us that in a closed, or partially closed system, price should be a function of resources available. If resource generation is responsive to price, and prices are not driven by supply and demand balance, we will violate the first law of thermodynamics. If capacity expansion decisions are made based on revenues in the market, there is no self-limiting due to over building.

84. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 84 The Analysis of Olivia RRP Given a variation in resources, we got the following behavior. Why is price insensitive to adding resource? Positive L/R mean deficit Points (L to R) obtained by decreasing size of fixed resource

85. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 85 RRP Algorithm Prices surplus deficit

86. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 86 Observation 1 “Price is independent of key drivers” Not surprising, therefore that is independent of resources, at least until we would cause imbalance of supply and demand

87. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 87 Proposition Independence of price from resource generation levels is necessary for the existence of an independent electricity term

88. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 88 Proof by Contradiction So assume that prices did have to increase under all conditions when we decreased resources

89. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 89 Proof by Contradiction -10,000,000 -8,000,000 -6,000,000 -4,000,000 -2,000,000 0 2,000,000 4,000,000 6,000,000 8,000,000 10,000,000 12,000,000 050100150200250 Price L/R Bal (mwh) Intertie Capacity

90. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 90 Proof by Contradiction If you had some independent term that would add to the price we open up the possibility of decreasing prices price resources

91. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 91 Another Example Eliminating import and export drives us to no independent term! -10,000,000 -8,000,000 -6,000,000 -4,000,000 -2,000,000 0 2,000,000 4,000,000 6,000,000 8,000,000 10,000,000 12,000,000 050100150200250 Price L/R Bal (mwh) Intertie Capacity

92. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 92 Finally, Some Computational Considerations Computation time is dramatically increased when we try to fine-tune RRP Computation time is increased when we reduce imports and exports

93. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 93 Resource-responsive price We can examine the function of RRP by considering a small toy application ( Testbed_new.xls )Testbed_new.xls

94. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 94 Agenda Welcome Back! Overview of methods Presentation of candidate plan Models and modeling Algorithms –Dispatch –Resource-responsive price (RRP) –Planning flexibility –Long-term price response: DSIs and other industrial loads –Supply curves for conservation and for commercial use of hydro –Stochastic hydrogeneration based on 50-year stream flow record Next meeting

95. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 95 Sources of Resource Planning Flexibility Modularity (small size) –Reduces fixed-cost risk –Can more exactly match requirements Short Lead-Time –Can respond rapidly to opportunities or requirements Cost-effective Deferral –Usually available for only a limited time Cost-effective Cancellation –e.g., high salvage value or small capital commitment Choosing a Plan

96. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 96 Candidate Plan Under Future 1000 Choosing a Plan CO2 tax high gas prices

97. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 97 Candidate Plan Responds Choosing a Plan CO2 tax high gas prices lower power prices

98. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 98 The Construction Cycle Planning flexibility is related to the construction cycle of power plants The construction cycles may be viewed in terms of cash flows and decision points Cash expenditures 18 months 9 months

99. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 99 The Construction Cycle After an initial planning period, there typically large expenditures, such as for turbines or boilers, that mark decision points. Cash expenditures 18 months 9 months

100. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 100 Valuing Flexibility construction phase optional cancellation period evaluation phase time criterion To capture the value of flexibility, we need to model decision making On-Line!

101. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 101 Planning flexibility The function that performs planning flexibility can be examined as a standalone routine in ( PlanningFlex.xls )PlanningFlex.xls

102. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 102 Agenda Welcome Back! Overview of methods Presentation of candidate plan Models and modeling Algorithms –Dispatch –Resource-responsive price (RRP) –Planning flexibility –Long-term price response: DSIs and other industrial loads –Supply curves for conservation and for commercial use of hydro –Stochastic hydrogeneration based on 50-year stream flow record Next meeting

103. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 103 DSI Loads Compute break-even price for each of nine PNW aluminum plants Assume plant will leave the system if the spread between aluminum prices and electricity cost component gets too small Examine the impact of 100 MW allocation of BPA power at various prices Loads

104. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 104 DSI Loads Loads

105. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 105 DSI Loads Loads

106. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 106 DSI Loads minimum shut-down period evalulation phase time wholesale electricity market aluminum-elec price spread expected price trend minimum restart period evalulation phase Loads

107. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 107 DSI Loads Model DSI load as a function of electricity prices and aluminum prices. Represents monthly response. Would stay down for several months and take several months to bring back on-line. Has value as a exchange option or spread option. Loads

108. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 108 Long-term price response See the RRP model for an example of the function of the DSI LTPRD function

109. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 109 Agenda Welcome Back! Overview of methods Presentation of candidate plan Models and modeling Algorithms –Dispatch –Resource-responsive price (RRP) –Planning flexibility –Long-term price response: DSIs and other industrial loads –Supply curves for conservation and for commercial use of hydro –Stochastic hydrogeneration based on 50-year stream flow record Next meeting

110. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 110 Supply curves Provides for reversible supply curves –Used for modeling commercial hydro generation Provides for lost opportunity supply curves –Used for modeling conservation measures, such as energy efficiency measures introduced in new construction, that disappears after an fixed “window of opportunity” –Lost opportunity supply can be proportional to a factor such as load growth

111. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 111 Supply curves Can represent either incremental energy and costs, or cumulative energy and real levelized costs A workbook illustrating the supply curve logic appears in ( Supply Curve.xls )Supply Curve.xls

112. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 112 Agenda Welcome Back! Overview of methods Presentation of candidate plan Models and modeling Algorithms –Dispatch –Resource-responsive price (RRP) –Planning flexibility –Long-term price response: DSIs and other industrial loads –Supply curves for conservation and for commercial use of hydro –Stochastic hydrogeneration based on 50-year stream flow record Next meeting

113. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 113 Stochastic hydrogeneration Function has been removed from the Excel Add-in and placed in a regular worksheet for use with CB Turbo Estimated on- and off-peak energy for each of the fifty stream flow records Does not respond to price, but may be used with the reversible, incremental supply curve logic to capture that aspect.

114. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 114 Agenda Welcome Back! Overview of methods Presentation of candidate plan Models and modeling Algorithms Next meeting

115. Northwest Power and Conservation Council 115 End