1. 1 Semantic Cloud Computing with Linked Open Data Brand Niemann, Senior Enterprise Architect U.S. EPA November 20, 2009

2. 2 Federal CIO Council’s Architecture & Infrastructure Committee Meeting November 19, 2009, at Main Interior Building: –Co-Chairs: Sanjeev “Sonny” Bhagowalia, CIO, Department of the Interior, and Michael Carleton, CIO, Health & Human Services. –AIC – Cloud Computing Advisory Council (CCAC) Collaboration Update by George Thomas, Services Subcommittee Co-Chair. Note: Peter Tseronis is the Chair of the CCAC and George Thomas works for Michael Carleton. –Open Government Directive Update by Sonny Bhagowalia. –Data.Gov Concept of Operations Update by Kshemendra Paul, Manager of the FEA PMO and Sonny Bhagowalia.

3. 3 Federal CIO Council’s Architecture & Infrastructure Committee Meeting My notes (official minutes to be published): –George Thomas has the lead in preparing a briefing on an implementation framework (procurement and security) for Katie Lewin, Chief of Staff to GSA CIO Casey Coleman and Lead for Federal CIO Vivek Kundra’s Cloud Computing Initiative. –The public release of the Open Government Directive and Data.gov Concept of Operations has been delayed because it will be a Presidential Event and the President has been out of the country. Emphasize this is a Directive following the January 21 st Memo. –Sonny Bhagowalia asked everyone for three things for OMB (which I provided a summary of in the next slide*) and for me to have a followup conversation with him this coming week. Very interested in the DoD Cloud Computing Desktop Pilot (like iPhone Apps Store) we saw at the September NCOIC Cloud Computing Workshop. Could save government on conventional desktop infrastructure costs and increase the efficiency of collaboration and information sharing!

4. 4 My Ad-hoc Roadmap ScaleOrganizationOMB Needs* Comments GlobalNCOIC and OMG (1) Framework Semantic Cloud Computing with Linked Open Data (2) InteragencyIWGDD (3)Pilots ADS/Chandra to NASA Nebula (4) AgencyU.S. EPADevelop Data.gov Piloted Using Wiki That Became An Internet Operating System Desktop (5) and (6) Note: See next slide for footnotes.

5. 5 My Ad-hoc Roadmap Footnotes: –(1) NCOIC: Network Centric Operations Industry Consortium – http://www.ncoic.org and OMG: Object Management Group – http://www.omg.org http://www.ncoic.org http://www.omg.org –(2) http://networkcentricity.wik.is/@api/deki/files/33/=BrandNiemann102220 09.doc http://networkcentricity.wik.is/@api/deki/files/33/=BrandNiemann102220 09.doc –(3) IWGDD: Interagency Working Group on Digital Data – http://federaldata.wik.is/Interagency_Working_Group_on_Digitial_Data http://federaldata.wik.is/Interagency_Working_Group_on_Digitial_Data –(4) http://adswww.harvard.edu/ Note: Ranked 6 th in the World for Repositories - http://repositories.webometrics.info/top400_rep.asphttp://adswww.harvard.edu/http://repositories.webometrics.info/top400_rep.asp –(5) http://federaldata.wik.is/Statistical_Abstract_of_the_United_States%3a_ 2009 (improve data quality, metadata, and analysis tools, use desktop cloud computing, support the Semantic Web’s Linked Open Data, etc.) http://federaldata.wik.is/Statistical_Abstract_of_the_United_States%3a_ 2009 –(6) http://cloud.mindtouch.com/?x_lf_kt=2&_x_lf_kvid=303c62e0-3d50- 5e2e-ca43-ad0112f89b62http://cloud.mindtouch.com/?x_lf_kt=2&_x_lf_kvid=303c62e0-3d50- 5e2e-ca43-ad0112f89b62

6. 6 Pattern or Framework? Received about 6 comments / suggestions: Allen Jones, Jason Lee, Rex Brooks, Todd Schneider, Kevin Jackson, & Peter Tseronis Conclusion: Really a Framework for: –(1) Expressing and executing SOA patterns in Linked Open Data (e.g. Open Group's Service-Oriented Architecture Ontology and Model- Driven Architecture Solutions).Model- Driven Architecture Solutions –(2) Bridging the NCIOC Services WG and Cloud Computing Team for SOA Patterns Implemented with Cloud Computing (e.g. the All Hazards Alert and Warning Capability Pattern that is looking at NASA's Nebula Cloud Computing Facility for implementation). –(3) Bridging multiple NCOIC Products (e.g. Lexicon, SCOPE, etc.) and Patterns (e.g., SOA, Cloud Computing, etc.). –(4) Bridging multiple ontologies, frameworks, and ecosystems (e.g. University of California/IBM, GSA/Federal CIO Council, AgilePath, etc.).University of California/IBM –(5) Building the Semantic Web for Government Applications (CENDI Conference) ("Hendler - the Semantic Web relies on many good URI's", common vocabularies, and lite ontologies).CENDI Conference –(6) The Federal CIO Council and OMB that need a framework that deals with procurement and security.

7. 7 Patterns, Frameworks, & Roadmaps The NCOIC has both patterns and frameworks. OMG: –Richard Soley provided a “framework” at the July 15 th Federal Cloud Computing Summit.framework –Bob Marcus has organized a Cloud Interoperability Roadmaps Session at the December 10 th OMG Meeting and has proposed a follow-on activity to create a "Framework and Roadmap for Cloud Interoperability, Portability, and Capabilities”.Cloud Interoperability Roadmaps Session One possibility is to host a Session at the March NCOIC Plenary bringing together government, industry, and standards groups to assign roles and schedule for creating a draft Document.

8. 8 Patterns, Frameworks, & Roadmaps We can discuss this with the Japanese Cloud Computing Survey Team (see next slide) this coming week: –Requested Speakers: Peter Tseronis, Chair, Federal CIO Council’s Cloud Computing Advisory Group, and Deputy Associate CIO, Department of Energy. Kevin Jackson, Co-Chair, NCOIC Cloud Computing Team, and Vice-President, Dataline. Brand Niemann, Senior Enterprise Architect, U.S. EPA, and Member of the NCOIC Services WG and Cloud Computing Team. –Logistics: Wednesday, November 25 th, EPA Crystal City Facility IT Training Room S-4350 on the 4th Floor, at the U.S. EPA Potomac SOUTH Building (seats 20) - 8:30am - 1:00pm. –See http://www.epa.gov/opp00001/contacts/officelocation.htmhttp://www.epa.gov/opp00001/contacts/officelocation.htm No host lunch afterwards at Crystal City Hyatt (across the street). Please notify me by this Monday morning if you plan to attend for security clearance (niemann.brand@epa.gov ).niemann.brand@epa.gov

9. 9 Japanese Cloud Computing Survey Team Mr. Atsushi YASUDA –Deputy Director of IT Promotion Division, METI. Mr. Seiichi NOBUHARA –Strategic Consultant for METI, President of IBT co.Ltd. Mr. Masayoshi ARAI, –Industrial Researcher of JETRO, NY. Prof. Hajime HORIUCHI –Tokyo International University, ISO/IEC JTC1 SC32WG2.