1. DRAFT - NOT FOR PUBLICATION 14 July 2004 – ITRS Summer Conference 2004 ITRS Public Conference PIDS ITWG Emerging Research Devices San Francisco, CA July 14, 2004 Jim Hutchby - SRC

2. DRAFT - NOT FOR PUBLICATION 14 July 2004 – ITRS Summer Conference 2 u George BourianoffIntel/SRC u Joe BrewerU. Florida u Toshiro HiramotoTokyo U. u Jim HutchbySRC u Mike Forshaw UC London u Tsu-Jae King UC Berkeley u Rainer WaserRWTH A u In YooSamsung u John CarruthersOGI u Lothar RischInfineon u Ming-Jinn Tsai ERSO/ITRI u Wei-Tsun ShiauUMC u Peter ZeitzoffISMT u Makoto Yoshimi SOITEC u Kristin De MeyerIMEC u Tak Ning IBM u Philip WongIBM u Luan TranMicron u Victor ZhirnovSRC/NCSU u Simon Deleonibus LETI u Thomas Skotnicki ST Me u Yuegang ZhangIntel u Kentaro Shibahara Hiroshima U. u Byong Gook ParkSeoul N. U. u Fred BoeufST Me u Dan HammerstromOGI ITRS PIDS Emerging Research Devices Working Group

3. DRAFT - NOT FOR PUBLICATION 14 July 2004 – ITRS Summer Conference 3 u Charles BlackIBM u John CarruthersOGI u Alex DemkovFreescale u Mike ForshawUCL u Gerhard KlimeckPurdue u Mike GarnerIntel u Bruno GhysieneSOITEC u Jeff GrossmanLLNL u David Muller Cornell u Dan Herr SRC u Susan HollIntel u Jim HutchbySRC u Lalita ManchandaSRC/Agere u Rafael ReifMIT u Sadasivan ShankarIntel u Shinichi TakagiU. Tokyo u Eric VogleNIST u Kang WangUCLA u Rainer WaserAachen U. u In YooSamsung u Victor ZhirnovSRC/NCSU ITRS PIDS Emerging Research Materials Working Group

4. DRAFT - NOT FOR PUBLICATION 14 July 2004 – ITRS Summer Conference 4 u Mike ForshawUCL u John CarruthersOGI u George BourianoffIntel/SRC u Tobias NollAachen U. u Victor Zhirnov SRC/NCSU u Dan Hammerstrom OGI u Vwani Roychowdery UCLA ITRS PIDS Emerging Research Architectures Working Group

5. DRAFT - NOT FOR PUBLICATION 14 July 2004 – ITRS Summer Conference 5 Emerging Research Devices Introduction and Scope Cast a broad net to introduce readers to new material, device and architecture concepts for information processing --- Concept Identify Include Stimulate -- not hardened solutions -- not endorse -- and quantify -- and assess/critique Prioritize -- and define research needs (new)

6. DRAFT - NOT FOR PUBLICATION 14 July 2004 – ITRS Summer Conference 6 Requirements & Motivations for Information Processing Beyond CMOS Fundamental Requirements uEnergy restorative functional process (e.g. gain) uCompatible with CMOS uAt or above room temperature operation Compelling Motivations uFunctionally scaleable > 100x beyond CMOS limit uHigh information processing rate and throughput uMinimum energy per functional operation uMinimum, scaleable cost per function

7. DRAFT - NOT FOR PUBLICATION 14 July 2004 – ITRS Summer Conference 7 Emerging Research Devices Introduction and Scope 2004/2005 Broadened Scope Compared to 2003 Chapter --- New quantitative performance metrics In-depth critical assessment --- key application driven questions/issues --- potential versus to-date performance Knowledge requirements roadmap --- requirements-driven research needs (new)

8. DRAFT - NOT FOR PUBLICATION 14 July 2004 – ITRS Summer Conference 8 Non-classical CMOS Emerging Research Devices Organization & Component Tasks (2003) Emerging Research Devices Research Logic and Memory Devices Functional Organization (Architectures) Transfer to PIDS/FEP in 2005

9. DRAFT - NOT FOR PUBLICATION 14 July 2004 – ITRS Summer Conference 9 Scope of Emerging Research Devices 2003 Bulk CMOS Double-Gate CMOS Quantum cellular automataMolecular devices Nanotubes Emerging Information Processing Concepts New Memory and Logic Technologies New Architecture Technologies

10. DRAFT - NOT FOR PUBLICATION 14 July 2004 – ITRS Summer Conference 10 Single Gate Non-classical CMOS Transfer to PIDS/FEP in 2005

11. DRAFT - NOT FOR PUBLICATION 14 July 2004 – ITRS Summer Conference 11 Multiple Gate Non-classical CMOS Transfer to PIDS/FEP in 2005

12. DRAFT - NOT FOR PUBLICATION 14 July 2004 – ITRS Summer Conference 12 Emerging Research Memory Devices

13. DRAFT - NOT FOR PUBLICATION 14 July 2004 – ITRS Summer Conference 13 Technology Performance and Risk Evaluation Emerging Research Memory Devices

14. DRAFT - NOT FOR PUBLICATION 14 July 2004 – ITRS Summer Conference 14 Emerging Research Memory Devices Move to PIDS/FEP in 2005

15. DRAFT - NOT FOR PUBLICATION 14 July 2004 – ITRS Summer Conference 15 Emerging Research Logic Devices

16. DRAFT - NOT FOR PUBLICATION 14 July 2004 – ITRS Summer Conference 16 Scaling Limit of Charge Based Switch An Example of Critical Assessment Observations u Transistor critical dimension limited to ~ 1 nm (In the 2003 ITRS physical gate length = 7 nm for 2018) u Power density, not critical dimension, limits gate density to ~ 1 x 10 9 gates/cm 2 u For the ITRS density and switching time, CMOS is approaching the maximum power efficiency

17. DRAFT - NOT FOR PUBLICATION 14 July 2004 – ITRS Summer Conference 17 Technology Performance and Risk Evaluation Emerging Research Logic Devices

18. DRAFT - NOT FOR PUBLICATION 14 July 2004 – ITRS Summer Conference 18 Emerging Research Devices Organization & Component Tasks (2004/2005) Emerging Research Devices Emerging Logic and Memory Devices Emerging Architectures Emerging Materials Add to ERD in 2004

19. DRAFT - NOT FOR PUBLICATION 14 July 2004 – ITRS Summer Conference 19 Scope of Emerging Research Devices 2005 Quantum cellular automataMolecular devices Nanotubes Emerging Information Processing Concepts New Memory and Logic Technologies New Architecture Technologies New Materials Model Knowledge

20. DRAFT - NOT FOR PUBLICATION 14 July 2004 – ITRS Summer Conference 20 Emerging Research Devices Summary u ERD transferring new potential solutions to PIDS/FEP Non-Classical CMOS Phase Change and Floating Body DRAM Creating a new section on Emerging Research Materials Enhancing technology evaluation and guiding activities Quantitative critique of emerging technologies New roadmap of scientific and technology information required to advance emerging information processing technologies