1. August 6, 2009 Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel 1 Ontology Repository Research Issues Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel Discussion Ken Baclawski August 6, 2009

2. Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel 2 Purpose and Organization of Session Discuss longer term ontology repository issues Identify Prioritize Propose milestones Both tool and content development Panelists will present their issues/positions Review of issues raised in Ontology Summit 2008 Open for discussion

3. August 6, 2009 Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel 3 Panelists Michael Gruninger: Common Logic support Elisa Kendall: OOR for Public Sector Use Bart Gajderowicz: Uncertainty for mapping Mathieu dAquin: Ontology Repositories Katherine Goodier: Socio-cultural awareness Todd Schneider: Research questions

4. August 6, 2009 Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel 4 Granularity Issues Logical granularity Unit for import Context for mapping Storage granularity Same as logical granularity? Unit for mirroring? Unit for versioning? Other issues dependent on granularity Language dependence Effect of updates to part of a unit Query and retrieval across single and multiple units

5. August 6, 2009 Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel 5 Language Issues Representation languages: text, XML, frames, graphs, DL, CL, HOL, UML, SQL When and how will they be supported? Search languages: text, faceted, SPARQL,... When and how will they be supported? Inter-ontology mapping representation Initially just sameAs support When should more complex mappings be supported?

6. August 6, 2009 Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel 6 Internal Storage Storage strategies: triple stores, quad stores What is the API for the storage component? Language dependence Single or multiple internal representations Can one storage unit have multiple internal representations? Could this be lossy?

7. August 6, 2009 Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel 7 Management Issues Version management Configuration management Provenance and other metadata See next slide Metadata validation/authentication Related to policy issues Ontology ownership and access control

8. Annotates Image data set Image data set Sensor data set Sensor data set Knowledge base Knowledge base Metadata Domain Specific Ontology Domain Specific Ontology Domain Specific Ontology Repository Metadata Repository Metadata Repository Metadata Repository Ontology Semantics of

9. August 6, 2009 Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel 9 Modularization and Mapping Inter-ontology mapping consistency Formal definition? Weaker notions of consistency Ontology modularization support Convenience or meaningful If meaningful what is the semantics?

10. August 6, 2009 Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel 10 Architecture Issues Web service (API) ontologies (including the repository itself as a Web service) Potential new source of ontologies Ontology repository as web service registry Ontology based software engineering Repository architecture: components and internal APIs Ontologies for the repository development itself

11. August 6, 2009 Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel 11 Tool Support Issues Inference support When and how should it be supported? Ontology editors, pretty printers, visualization tools, differencing tools, explanation tools, summarization tools Should these be prioritized? Should it be up to repository instances?

12. August 6, 2009 Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel 12 Administration and Policy Issues Gatekeeping policies and enforcement Overall policies or left to individual repositories Policy-making body When should it be constituted?

13. August 6, 2009 Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel 13 Scalability Issues Scalability goals Size milestones Concurrent access milestones Instance data See slide 8

14. August 6, 2009 Joint Ontolog-OOR Panel 14 Outreach and Education Integration with other semantic tools Semantic wikis Others? Education Documentation is not enough Community outreach Meet with representatives of the community Assist in transition to ontology repositories