1. SMART REGULATION FOR ENERGY SECTOR CHALLENGES

2. 2 Power Sector Challenges Decarbonisation Security of Supply Competitiveness Smart Regulation POWER SECTOR CHALLENGES

3. 3 Smart Regulation Optimal way to design and implement the rules of regulation SMART REGULATION What is Smart regulation? Smart regulation is not a form of regulation it is a method to regulate

4. 4 SMART REGULATION: PRINCIPLES Preference for a mix of policies, tools and institutions Low-key flexible regulation Gradual response mechanism Empowerment of stakeholders Encouraging companies to embrace self regulation Smart Regulatory Design Principles

5. 5 SMART REGULATION: MAIN FEATURES S M A R T Streamlined Meaningful Adaptable Relevant Transparent Source: World Bank (2013). Doing Business Report Regulation should be clear and accessible to anyone who needs to use it

6. 6 What are the main challenges in the power sector that a smart regulatory approach can help to meet? How can this approach meet energy sector challenges? Two questions arise: SMART REGULATION

7. 7 Source: IEA (2013). Redrawing the Energy Climate Map World Energy-Related CO2 Emissions World Power Sector emissions reduction is central in order to achieve the 2 degree scenario by the IEA. CO2 EMISSIONS

8. 8 Energy dependence 2011 (Energy imports in % of energy use) Source: World Bank Data & Eurostas (for EU28) Energy dependence puts at risk energy security in Europe, Japan, Turkey and Korea ENERGY DEPENDENCE

9. 9 Source: EC (2014) Commission Staff WD. Energy Prices and Cost Report. SWD (2014) 21 Final/2 High industrial energy prices affect competitiveness… Retail electricity prices 2012 - Industrial consumers ENERGY PRICES

10. 10 How can these three challenges be met through smart regulation? SMART REGULATION

11. 11 Smart regulation is expected to play a key role in the future development of the instruments that will help to meet the Power Sector Challenges Competition through Energy Market Integration Empowering stakeholders Consumers in the driving seat SMART REGULATION

12. 12 Increase competition Lower prices Regulatory Harmonization COMPETITIVENESS Energy Market Integration

13. 13 EMPOWERING STAKEHOLDERS Transparency: public consultation Agents need to be involved in the regulation processes Complete information Empowerment Stakeholders

14. 14 CONSUMERS Consumers Participation In the driving seat of regulation: Participation in electricity markets Flexibility Demand Side Response

15. 15 SELF-REGULATION Examples of Self-Regulatory Mechanisms: Enlightened self-interest Customer/Supplier requirements Third-party certification and management systems Sectorial guidelines Self-interest augmented by government incentives Smart Regulation involves regulated companies embracing the objectives set by themselves Self-Regulation

16. 16 SELF-REGULATION: EMPIRICAL EVIDENCE Self-Regulation Recent empirical study Costa-Campi et al. (2015) on energy efficiency determinants has pointed out in regard to self-regulation: Self-Regulation can be supported by smart regulation measures Regulation has a multiplier effect on the actions companies set out on the way to accomplish that regulation (Self-regulatory actions) This is valued by smart investors

17. 17 Conclusions CONCLUSIONS

18. 18 CONCLUSIONS The energy sector is facing important challenges (Decarbonisation, Security of Supply and Industrial Competitiveness) : Smart regulation should help to meet them The energy sector is facing important challenges (Decarbonisation, Security of Supply and Industrial Competitiveness) : Smart regulation should help to meet them

19. 19 CONCLUSIONS To motivate self-regulation To consider the impact on the cost of energy, on economic growth and job creation. To ensure a predictable regulatory framework through transparency and empowerment of agents and consumers. To keep legislation low-key to avoid overlaps

20. 20 Smart Regulation should be the path chosen by policy makers and regulatory bodies… CONCLUSIONS …to enhance the performance of the energy sector and help achieve the important objectives set for it.

21. 21 Thank you for your attention ilginiz için teşekkür ederiz