1. 3SAQS Technical Workshop April 30 th, 2015 Data Warehouse Current and Future Development Intermountain West Data Warehouse

2. Outline Update - DW Overview & Development Data Request Status Visualization tools – Image browser linklink – Model-to-obs tooltool – Emissions review tooltool – Dynamic Geospatial Model visualization tooltool – ENVIRON Source Apportionment tool ENVIRON site ENVIRON site Functionality Data Request Form Prototype data selection form Category Management Inventory Management Forum & email notifications Forum Wrap-up and action items 3SAQS Technical Workshop, CIRA, Fort Collins, CO April 30, 2015

3. Outline Update - DW Overview & Development Data Request Status Visualization tools – Image browser linklink – Model-to-obs tooltool – Emissions review tooltool – Dynamic Geospatial Model visualization tooltool – ENVIRON Source Apportionment tool ENVIRON site ENVIRON site Functionality Data Request Form Prototype data selection form Category Management Inventory Management Forum & email notifications Forum Wrap-up and action items 3SAQS Technical Workshop, CIRA, Fort Collins, CO April 30, 2015

4. IWDW Overview

5. 3SAQS Technical Workshop, CIRA, Fort Collins, CO April 30, 2015 IWDW Overview

6. DW Development Update Project Management – Q1 2015 Data Requests; Inventory Management; Data Delivery Documentation Data & Information Management – Q2 2015 through 2016 Visualization tool development (modeling I/O & analysis) Modeling platform review Expanded documentation and “easy-to-reference” information 3SAQS Technical Workshop, CIRA, Fort Collins, CO April 30, 2015

9. Outline Update - DW Overview & Development Data Request Status Visualization tools – Image browser linklink – Model-to-obs tooltool – Emissions review tooltool – Dynamic Geospatial Model visualization tooltool – ENVIRON Source Apportionment tool ENVIRON site ENVIRON site Functionality Data Request Form Prototype data selection form Category Management Inventory Management Forum & email notifications Forum Wrap-up and action items 3SAQS Technical Workshop, CIRA, Fort Collins, CO April 30, 2015

10. Data Request Summary – pg. 1 RequestRequestorData Supporting Docs Request Submitted 3-State Steward Action Direct Interest Studies for WSAQS Cooperators Methane/VOC Control Sensitivity Study Tammy Thompson CIRA 2008 EmissionsScope of WorkYes Emissions Inventory Data Summary for 2008 Tammy Thompson CIRA 2008 EmissionsNoneYesMike Barna Filled 4/24/2015 Source Apportionment Modeling for Nitrogen in Greater Yellowstone Area (GYA) Tammy Thompson CIRA 2011 Emissions (unreleased) Project PlanYesMike Barna National Park AQRV Todd McDonnell E&S Environmental Chemistry 2011 Emissions (unreleased) NoneYes Routes to Sustainability for Natural Gas Development and Water and Air Resources in the Rocky Mountain Region - Sensitivity Analysis Shannon Capps University of Colorado, Boulder 2008b Base year Platform (partial) Modeling Protocol and Timeline Yes Kevin Briggs Filled 4/24/2015 Comparison of source contributions to nitrogen deposition at Class 1&2 areas in the Western U.S. Tammy Thompson CIRA 2008b Emissions and CAMx inputs NoneNo WRAP TSS Emission Tool Updates – 2011a emissions displays Cassie Archuleta Air Resource Specialists 2011a Emissions (unreleased) NoneNoTom Moore Inventory--categories and methodology consistent with previous WRAP inventories for regional haze from 2004 and 2008 (reasonable progress) Daniel Bon CDPHE 2008b Base year Platform None (may be taken care under Archuleta request above) YesTom Moore Will fulfill via TSS after update w/2011 emissions

11. Data Request Summary – pg. 2 RequestRequestorData Supporting Docs Request Submitted 3-State Steward Action NEPA Studies Hiawatha Regional Energy Development Project (HREDP) Environmental Impact Statement Ralph Morris ENVIRON 2008b NEPA Platform NoneNoCharis Tuers Converse County Development Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) Chao-Jung Chien AECOM 2008b NEPA Platform NoneYes Ryan McCammon Fulfilled 3/18/2015 Outside Requests (applicability to WSAQS Cooperators not clear) Colorado Oil and Gas Sensitivity Analyses James Wilkinson Golder Associates Inc. 2008b NEPA Platform NoneYes Update of a USFS Fire handbook Suresh Ratnam University of Southern California Base2020_08aNoneNo Improving Ozone modeling in Uintah Basin Huy Tran Utah State University 2008b Emissions and utilities None Yes incomplete Analysis of FRAPPÉ and DISCOVER- AQ 2014 campaigns Gabriele Pfister NCAR 2011a Emissions and utilities (unreleased) NoneYes

12. Responding to Data Requests Process needs for operating the Data Warehouse noted so far: – the identities, roles, and responsibilities of cooperating agency “stewards” need to be clarified – the necessary level of documentation and applicability to the overall goals of the cooperators; and – the form of a “release” of a platform and its component data, including the associated use recommendation.

13. Pending Project Proposals with no data requests Information or Data Request Proposal RequestorStart DateData Request Submitted Fulfillment ApproachAction Emissions QA 2011 Base A Gail Tonnesen EPA Region 8 10/1/2014NoneNoInternal project report completed Ozone spatial plots for 2011 MPE Gail Tonnesen EPA Region 8 10/16/2014NoneNo Display capability on DW in development PEM integration with SMOKE/CMAQ Private consultant11/11/2014NoneNoCancelled 2011a Modeling SensitivitiesZac Adelman UNC-IE9/1/2014NoneNo Conducted as internal DW modeling study analysis PMDETAILRalph Morris ENVIRON12/1/2014NoneNo Pending, will utilize files from DW and PMDETAIL project 2020 Future Case Sensitivity Mike Barna National Park Service, Air Resource Division 1/23/2015NoneNoPending

14. Outline Update - DW Overview & Development Data Request Status Visualization tools – Image browser linklink – Model-to-obs tooltool – Emissions review tooltool – Dynamic Geospatial Model visualization tooltool – ENVIRON Source Apportionment tool ENVIRON site ENVIRON site Functionality Data Request Form Prototype data selection form Category Management Inventory Management Forum & email notifications Forum Wrap-up and action items 3SAQS Technical Workshop, CIRA, Fort Collins, CO April 30, 2015

15. Image Browser http://views.cira.colostate.edu/tsdw/Tools/ImageBrowser.aspx?pathid=TsdwPlotsRoot Displays large image sets delivered by data provider Possible Next Steps – Improve navigation (fewer mouse clicks) – Display meta data – Browse multiple image sets side by side

16. Model-To-Obs Tool http://views.cira.colostate.edu/TSDW/modeling/modelobscomparison_iwdw.aspx Compare model values to observed values by network Possible Next Steps – Platform selection – Additional filtering capabilities

17. Emissions Review Tool http://views.cira.colostate.edu/tsdw/Emissions/ReviewTool.aspx View modeled emissions by source category, state, county, and SCC Possible Next steps – Refactor data base to correctly label and aggregate parameters and source categories – Expand SCC visualization capabilities

18. Dynamic Geospatial Model Visualization http://views.cira.colostate.edu/tsdw_Dev/Maps/ModelDataGIS.aspx Displays model output data with overlaid monitor data

19. Dynamic Geospatial Model Visualization ArcSDE (Spatial Database Engine) with SQL Server – Stores/Serves rasters of model data – Stores/Serves raster attributes – Data can be accessed remotely by ArcGIS users ArcServer – Provides web services which render data stored in SDE – Web Services consumed by web applications such as the data warehouse

20. Dynamic Geospatial Model Visualization Advantages – Map Projection – Uniform color scale – Monitor data overlay – Ease of combining multiple features – Sharing data with other GIS users

21. Dynamic Geospatial Model Visualization Disadvantages – More Pre-processing – Data duplication – Infrastructure heavy (ArcServer, ArcSDE)

22. Dynamic Geospatial Model Visualization Possible Next steps – Parameterize, platform, species, layer, time window – Additional Monitor data – Additional features Cities Roads – Automate preprocessing, execute on demand

23. Source Apportionment Tool http://ims.environcorp.com/aqms_test Developments/Status Received prototype from Environ Database up and running Possible Next steps Deploy prototype user interface on CIRA systems Integrate user interface with main warehouse system Integrate database with main warehouse DB Automate data ingestion

24. Outline Update - DW Overview & Development Data Request Status Visualization tools – Image browser linklink – Model-to-obs tooltool – Emissions review tooltool – Dynamic Geospatial Model visualization tooltool – ENVIRON Source Apportionment tool ENVIRON site ENVIRON site Functionality Data Request Form Prototype data selection form Category Management Inventory Management Forum & email notifications Forum Wrap-up and action items 3SAQS Technical Workshop, CIRA, Fort Collins, CO April 30, 2015

25. Data Request Form Automated FTP fulfillment – One click FTP user creation and data access – Create/Update FTP user account – Enable FTP access to requested data without duplication of data – Two Successful deliveries via FTP – Image Browser uses FTP fulfillment to serve images

26. Data Request Form http://views.cira.colostate.edu/tsdw_dev/DataRequest/PlatformSelection.aspx Component Selection – Flattened tree – More descriptive information – Alternative to category tree

27. Data Request Form Possible Next Steps – Integrate component selection with request form – Possibly separate project proposal from data request – Continue to evolve approval and stewardship policies and procedures – Integrate data release status and/or evaluation level – Notification email clean-up

28. Category Management Create/Remove/Edit – Data Categories – File Items in category – Meta Data Browse file system Data Management Reports – Missing data Possible Next steps – Additional reporting as needed – Better display of category/file meta data parameters – File/Category history

29. Inventory Management MD5 checksums stored in relational database History of file meta data – file size – mod time – checksum Data Recovery tool Next Steps – Incorporate detailed meta data scraper – Automation of Checksum computation – Reporting Report changes to data requestors File level data status

30. Forum & Email Notifications http://views.cira.colostate.edu/tsdw/Forum/

31. Outline Update - DW Overview & Development Data Request Status Visualization tools – Image browser linklink – Model-to-obs tooltool – Emissions review tooltool – Dynamic Geospatial Model visualization tooltool – ENVIRON Source Apportionment tool ENVIRON site ENVIRON site Functionality Data Request Form Prototype data selection form Category Management Inventory Management Forum & email notifications Forum Wrap-up and action items 3SAQS Technical Workshop, CIRA, Fort Collins, CO April 30, 2015