1. Social justice, teacher education and technology Gary Motteram and Eljee Javier

2. Increasing use of technology to deliver teacher education in the developing world There are a range of projects happening all over the world We see increasing links between what is happening in the north and the south, and south south

3. … 87% of Pakistani households own mobile phones (Express Tribune, 2014 quoting The Pakistan Demographic and Health Survey) Difference between urban and rural is 94.7% and 83% Network is currently mostly 2G, although 3G has arrived in Karachi Difference in internet connection: 17.4% urban; 1.3% rural 60.2% of households countrywide own a TV http://tribune.com.pk/story/666965/87-of-pakistani-households-own-cellphone-only-6-8-have-internet-connection- survey/ Pakistan technology background

4. Data similar to an opportunistic survey conducted in 2013 with in-service Pakistani teachers: 96.5% own mobile phone (70% basic Nokias) 85.3% own a TV 55.2% have access to a computer Most common use of the mobile phone is for making calls (93.7%); 50% use them for texting We don’t currently know anything about student access It would be good to get more of this background data

5. ICTs can “… open[…] up prospects and opportunities for promoting democracy and prosperity in poor parts of the planet …” (Zembylas, 2009, p18) Materials can be provided for teachers who don’t have access to any resources These materials can be localised based on existing materials/ models being used by the British Council in other parts of the world supplemented with our own ideas and ideas from other development projects Aim is to enhance teachers knowledge and skills and enable them to be more effective as teachers in the classroom (Key theme related to the success of Millennium Development Goals)

6. If some teachers don’t have the necessary mobile technologies, they can be given them, thus dealing with another issue of equity of access Reducing the digital divides in a country...whether ICT is useful for development or not depends on overcoming the same social structures that contribute to inequities and the unjust distribution of wealth (Zembylas, 2009, p19) Access to ICT can be seen these days as a basic human right (Power et al., 2009, p96)

7. “productive model” (Zembylas, 2009, p20) ICT tools can also be used for other parts of the community, so that mobile technologies can be used in the promotion of health, can be supportive of the local economy in a variety of ways, there are plenty of examples of micro businesses, advice on crop prices for farmers, and selling on mobile phone air time to people who don’t own a mobile. This is the domain of more mainstream ICT 4 Development http://ict4dblog.wordpress.com http://ict4dblog.wordpress.com

8. I would argue with Power et al (2009, p90) that: “... one of the most important contestations around ICT for rural education and development is to strengthen the voice and power of educators and their communities over the discourse of technicians and global capital.” We also need to avoid the “... [f]our barriers to educational ICT interventions in rural schools… Poor intervention design … Costs … Social conditions … Disempowering educators”. Power et al. (2009, p96-97)

9. Leveraging low-cost mobile technologies in Bangladesh for teacher professional development and ELT Collaboration between The Open University (UK), The BBC and locally UCEP and FIVDB Project Phase 2: Mobile phone kits w/ pre-loaded resources and audio on SD cards Aimed to foster a more communicative approach to ELT

10. Mobile developments based on a variety of different projects and other ideas UNESCO and Nokia to Use Mobile Technology to Improve Education in Nigeria General UNESCO reports on Mobile learning Mobile phones supporting women’s literacy in Pakistan Job seekers – British Council India

11. English language teaching in Ethiopia http://lifelineenergy.org http://lifelineenergy.org/our-technology/

12. Solar Aid and Mobile phone charging https://solar-aid.org/buy-a-light/

13. ELT through video conferencing in primary schools in Uruguay Plan Ceibal and Plan Ceibal on Ingles (British Council) Collaboration between experienced lesson plan writers, remote and regular classroom teachers Fibre optic cable based video conferencing In conjunction with an online training course for the teachers

14. School in Pakistan using Schools Online

15. On-going teacher development in Pakistan Working with the Dept for Schools Development (DSD) Skype is being used to manage teacher development interventions in resource centres Using mobiles, teachers can also be part of the dialogue around education in their contexts, making a contribution to the on- going debates. These can be conducted using text and can feed back into the development of further materials that are developed with them during workshops Extensions could include access to MOOCs, connections with other teacher groups in Pakistan and other countries: https://www.coursera.org/course/ictinprimary https://www.coursera.org/course/ictinprimary https://www.futurelearn.com/courses/explore-english-language- culture

16. References Banegas, D. L. (2013). ELT through videoconferencing in primary schools in Uruguay: First steps. Innovation in Language Learning and Teaching, 7(2), 179-188. McNally, P. (2014). Case Study: BBC Janala. London: Mobile for Development Impact. Powers, T., Porteus, K., Ramadiro, B., Tshume, N., Makalema, S. and Thomas, R. (2009). Is there a role for ICTs in the education and development of disadvantaged rural communities? In C. Vrasidas, M. Zembylas, & G. V. Glass (2009). ICT for education, development and social justice. Charlotte, NC: Information Age Publishing. Walsh, C., Shrestha, P., & Hedges, C. (2011). Leveraging low-cost mobile technologies in Bangladesh: A case study of innovative practices for teacher professional development and communicative english language teaching. In R. Kwan, C. McNaught, C. Tsang, F. Wang, & K. Cheong-Li (Eds.), Enhancing learning through technology - education unplugged, mobile technologies and web 2.0. Berlin: Springer, pp. 152 - 166. Zembylas, M. (2009). ICT for education, development and social justice: Some theoretical issues. In C. Vrasidas, M. Zembylas, & G. V. Glass (2009). ICT for education, development and social justice. Charlotte, NC: Information Age Publishing.