1. SUBMISSION 2 Library Research

2. SUBMISSION 1 Just To Remind Everyone

3. Submission One – 10% Paper One consists of 2 parts: 1.Annotated Bibliography 2.Research Proposal (worksheet)

4. Research Proposal Worksheet. Overview ONLY! Do not go into depth. Get the arguments right! In prose form, this becomes the introduction to Submission Two.

5. Sub 1: Annotated Bibliography Basically a feasibility study Requires 14 sources total, pro- and con- Books, scholarly articles, legitimate websites and government resources No “helper” sources (limited journalistic sources and magazines allowed, but NO Wikipedia, NO Taking Sides or Controversial Issues citations etc.) Include: MLA Works Cited plus “annotations” (comments on each source’s authority, and on how you will use each source) Due on February 13th

6. About the Sources 14 Total sources A minimum of – 1 Book – 3 Articles – 3 Webpages Sources Must be from 2008 and Later

7. Annotation involves 2 things Develop a standard MLA citation for each entry Summarizing each source – What is the source about – Why it is credible – How it will contribute to your project

8. Recap Submission One = Annotated Bibliography + Research Proposal (worksheet) Research Proposal is revised for the introduction to Submission Two and subsequent submissions. Save the information to put in your Research File

9. SUBMISSION 2 Library Research

10. The Bad News The hardest paper The Single longest paper The Paper that involves the most research The paper that begins the Capstone “fade”

11. The Good News Once this is completed, Capstone becomes much easier This paper forms the basis of your first oral presentation

12. WHAT IT ENTAILS

13. THREE SECTIONS 1.Introduction to social problem 2.Background/history/ current policy 3.In-depth presentation of the sides

14. INTRODUCTION Section I

15. INTRODUCTION (Sec 1) (approximately 3 pages) Interesting Introduction Social problem – Significance – Statistics – Importance Brief overview of the controversy (no more than 2 paragraphs) Conclude with normative/research question

16. Significance of the Social Problem The social problem that underlies your controversy (the broad macro problem) Statistics for the problem, describing the scope – Demonstrate that this is a problem – Targets- who is hurt by the social problem Why it is important that the problem is solved Watch out for bias

17. INTRODUCTION : Definitions The Current controversial policy (these are the laws that are currently in place) Important words in topic sentence Relevant law(s), guidelines, etc. (specific laws should be put the text in your research file)

18. Overview of the Controversy Identify the Real political actors involved (stakeholders) Identify the issues that shape the debate Identify the values central to each side

19. The Solution Conclude the introduction with your solution The normative question that is also the title of your paper

20. INTRODUCTION (Sec 1) After Reading your introduction, the reader should: – Understand why this is an important controversy – Understand who is affected by this problem – Understand why this problem needs to be solved – Understand the major actors and what they want – Understand the controversial solution to solve the problem

21. Your introduction should scare the reader by convincing him/her that the fate of the world depends on solving this problem

22. BACKGROUND AND HISTORY Section 2

23. BACKGROUND/HISTORY (Approximately 5 pages) Goal: historical context to understand current controversy Starting place: it should be far back enough to describe the modern dilemma Ending point: Most recent events

24. BACKGROUND cont. Narrate the History of Government Action Include: – Pivotal events- e.g. the first legislation – Important court cases (if applicable) – Proposals, laws, etc.- previous attempts to solve the problem – Important people- real actors who have made a difference Chronological order Varied sources- avoid the cut and paste from CQ!

25. Finish With The Current Policy What is it (be specific) How does it work What are the problems

26. For Each Key Event Why was it controversial Which side passed it Who opposed it

27. Sources Vary your Sources Do not simply cut and paste from CQ Researcher (it is worth mentioning again) Reliance on a single source is transcribing!

28. Things to avoid Going Back too far in time Wikipedia (of course) Missing out on important events

29. BACKGROUND/HISTORY At the End of this section, the reader should: – Know the policy attempts at solving the social policy – Know the deficiencies with the current policy – Know the current policy: As of Spring 2013, what is the current policy.

30. PRESENTATION OF EACH SIDE Section 3

31. What it Contains (4-5 Pages for Each Side) Stakeholders Arguments Issues Plans

32. IN-DEPTH PRESENTATION OF EACH SIDE: Stakeholders and Values Approximately 4-5 pages per Position General parties to the controversy – Comprehensive information Specific parties to the controversy – Comprehensive information – WHAT DO THEY VALUE?

33. Who are the Stakeholders? Identify the General Stakeholders Identify the Specific Stakeholders – Tell me why the group matters – Tell me what they value Conclude by identifying their major arguments on the solution

34. IN-DEPTH PRESENATION OF EACH SIDE, Issues and Arguments. Clearly identify Issues for Both sides (minimum 3 for each side) Specific Arguments for each side’s issue Evidence supporting each argument, such as: – Case studies – Statistical evidence – Expert testimony – Court cases

35. Issues and Arguments. Introduce the issues in a paragraph listing the issues You must have 3 for each side

36. For Each Issue Identify the Issue Provide the argument why they want it Provide the evidence to support their argument

37. Examples of Evidence Examples – Government Reports – Research Studies – Legal arguments – Case Studies Not all evidence is created equal

38. Presenting the Plans. What are the specific ways that the stakeholders are trying to influence policy How are they advancing the cause – Electoral – Lobbying – Media – Legal

39. MECHANICS Approximately 14-16 pages long (Minimum of 12) Works Cited Correct MLA form throughout Style – In accordance with Capstone guidelines – Polished, proofed DUE: In Class 3/8/2013

40. Turnitin.Com This paper must also be submitted to turnitin.com

41. About Turnitin.com It Checks your paper for plagiarism – Against the web – Against the other papers in the turnitin archive Failure to use this results in a 10 point deduction from your paper