1. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries Second series of results of the first planning exercise 10 – 14 October 2005 Accra David Botha

2. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries Administrations: Prepare input requirements Test planning options Study spectrum capacity Familiarise with software PXT: Testing planning assumptions Test planning software Implement planning software Test display software Purpose of the planning exercise

3. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries Equivalent reference situation: Analogue Television Input data:

4. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries Equivalent reference situation: Other primary services Input data:

5. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries Digital broadcasting requirements: Participation Input data: 100 member states and PSE submitted requirements 19 member states did not submit any: 2 from EBA 16 from ABA 1 from RCC

6. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries Digital broadcasting requirements: Composition in terms of type Input data: 42% 48% 3% 7%

7. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries Digital broadcasting requirements: Composition in terms of submissions per band Input data: 78% 22%

8. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries Administrative declarations: Between digital broadcasting requirements only Input data:

9. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries Administrative declarations: Between digital broadcasting requirements only Input data:

10. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries First series of results (July 2005): Four study cases – 1.Basic plan (include analogue TV and other primary services) 2.Include analogue TV, exclude other primary services 3.Exclude analogue TV, include other primary services 4.Exclude analogue TV and other primary services Two series of results for the first planning exercise

11. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries Second series of results (September 2005): Same study cases as for the first series Include three variants Including additional administrative declarations (22 August 2005) Including requirements NIG, NGR Corrected errors in planning software Corrected protection margins allowing for multiple interfering sources Two series of results for the first planning exercise continued

12. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries Based on IPG-1 decision (IPG-1/51 Annex 17) Variants used during second series of results: Based on study case 4 (only requirements) Protection margin relaxed by 3 dB 90% locations probability for DVB-T Combination of the above two variants Variant not used during second series of results: 5% time of interference, Zones C & D Two series of results for the first planning exercise continued

13. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries Band III total Results:

14. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries Band III – sound broadcasting Results:

15. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries Band III – television broadcasting Results:

16. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries Bands IV/V Results:

17. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries Variants in Band III Results:

18. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries Variants in Band III Results:

19. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries Variants in Bands IV/V Results:

20. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries Variants in Bands IV/V Results:

21. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries General findings: Impact of analogue TV and other primary services Results: Study Case 1 – 104569 available channels identified Study Case 4 – 407602 available channels identified Analogue TV and other primary services occupy nearly ¾ available spectrum

22. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries General findings: Band III – Study Case 1 Results: 9582 requirements for synthesis 4474 (~47%) with no available channel => cannot be satisfied - Of these had one or more acceptable channels 2.7 available channels per requirement 25 incompatibilities per requirement 330 (3%) requirements with no incompatibility 4067 (~42%) with 1 available channel and between 1 to 214 incompatibilities - Many incompatibilities => unlikely to be satisfied Up to 227 incompatibilities per requirement

23. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries General findings: Band III – Study Case 4 Results: 9582 requirements for synthesis 991 T-DAB requirements with 32 available frequency blocks 6 available channels per requirement 75 incompatibilities per requirement Up to 607 incompatibilities per requirement All requirements have at least 1 available channel 1678 – No incompatibility => get a channel 1665 – only 1 available channel => satisfied => coordinated well 5962 (~63%) with 1 available channel and 1 to 379 incompatibilities - Many incompatibilities => unlikely to be satisfied

24. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries General findings: Bands IV/V – Study Case 1 Results: 38602 requirements for synthesis 3274 (<10%) have no incompatibility 18881 (~49%) with 1 available channel and 1 to 300 incompatibilities - Many incompatibilities => unlikely to be satisfied 7207 with 49 available channels Each AC requested by 7800-8400 requirements – evenly requested

25. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries General findings: Bands IV/V – Study Case 4 Results: 38602 requirements for synthesis All requirements have at least 1 AC 11948 requirements with no incompatibility => get a channel 11866 – only 1 available channel => satisfied => coordinated well 28521 (~74%) with 1 available channel and 1 to 1170 incompatibilities - Many incompatibilities => unlikely to be satisfied

26. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries General findings: Countries considered in isolation Results: Conditions: Analogue television assignments taken into account as indicated Disregarded all requirements from all other administrations Disregarded all analogue television and other primary service assignments of all other administrations Results for 22 administrations: - 2 administrations had all their requirements satisfied - 20 out of 22 cannot have all their requirements satisfied

27. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries General findings: General errors/problems identified Results: Some declarations referred to incompatibilities that do not exist Declarations were not submitted for all members of linked requirements Conversions failed because: - Conversions were not indicated or incorrectly indicated - Converted requirement still has a larger service area after ERP reduction - Conversions from interfering analogue TV assignments

28. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries General findings: Number of recommended multiplex coverage layers (IPG-1) Results: Band III: 1 layer of television multiplex coverage (DVB-T) and 3 layers of sound broadcasting (T-DAB) multiplex coverages or 2 layers of television multiplex coverages (DVB-T) Bands IV/V: 4 to 7 layers of television multiplex coverages (DVB-T)

29. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries Conclusions Reduce the number of input requirements Eliminate internal (national) incompatibilities and those with neighbours – but ONLY where such elimination is justified! Reconsider the need for high transmitter power assignments Consider the possibility for large assignments/allotments Choose the appropriate Reference Network

30. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries Thank you

31. BR/TSD Accra 2005 BCD Workshop for the African Countries