Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byArline Benson Modified over 9 years ago
1
U.S. Department of the Interior U.S. Geological Survey Effects of restoration on avian populations in the Napa Sonoma Marshes Wildlife Area: density changes from 2000-2010 L. Arriana Brand, Lacy Smith, Joel Shinn, Isa Woo, Tanya Graham, and John Takekawa
2
Acknowledgements USGS Western Ecological Research Center USGS Priority Ecosystem Studies, SF Bay Program Ducks Unlimited – Renee Spenst, Steve Carroll, Austin Payne, Russell Lowgren, Ron Galindo, Fritz Reid Wildlife Conservation Board - Bonnie Turner, Tony Chappelle State Coastal Conservancy – Amy Hutzel, Nadine Hitchcock, Betsy Wilson SF Bay Joint Venture - Beth Huning, Christina Sloop California Department of Fish and Game – Karen Taylor, Tom Huffman, Mike Sipes, Larry Wyckoff, Stacy Martinelli GAIA Consulting, Inc. - Susanne von Rosenberg Cargill – Butch Paredes
3
Critical region for migratory birds Central challenge: How to maintain waterbird populations given conversion to tidal marsh? Western Waterfowl Migration Routes Western Waterfowl Migration Routes Pacific flyway - 20% of North American waterfowl in the Central Valley & SF Bay Western Hemispheric Shorebird Reserve Network
4
Napa Sonoma Marshes Timeline 1994 NSMWA purchased by DFG 1995 Breach of Pond 2A Aug 2002 “Midnight” breach Pond 3 Mar 2003 NPS purchased by DFG Apr 2004 NSMWA Project EIR Feb 2006 NPS Draft EIR Fall 2006 Breach Ponds 3, 4, and 5 Oct 2008 Breach Pond 9/10 Sept 2009 Breach Wash Pond Aug 2010 Breach Crystallizers
5
Restoration Phases I: Managed Ponds 1, 1A, 2 II: Breached Ponds 3, 4, 5 III: Breached Ponds NPS IV: Managed Ponds 6-8 Largest salt pond conversion to tidal wetlands in the SF Bay (~1500 ha)
6
Questions Do breached ponds support similar avian densities to managed ponds? How have avian densities changed over time in breached vs. managed ponds? What factors may be influencing these patterns?
7
Methods Data collection Monthly counts at HT Counts at LT 2008-2010 WQ sampling Data analysis Aggregate to pond scale Generalized LS regression for clustered data with pond random effect Monthly sequence as time series variable
8
Avian Guilds Drawing adapted from Warnock 2004
9
Avian guilds by season North Bay Ponds 2000-2010
10
Salinity changes over time Winter
11
Dabbling Duck trends Winter
12
Dabbling Duck trends Winter
13
Diving Duck trends Winter
14
Diving Duck trends Winter
15
Medium shorebirds trends Winter
16
Medium shorebirds trends Winter
17
Small shorebird trends Winter
18
Small shorebird trends Winter
20
Use of breached ponds 3, 4, 5 at low versus high tide 2008-2010 winter
21
Use of breached ponds 3, 4, 5 at low versus high tide 2008-2010 winter
22
Vegetation changes in breached ponds 3, 4 and 5
23
Percent of ponds with elevations sufficient to support Spartina foliosa Pond 3: 19.3% Pond 4: 12.6% Pond 5: 25.3%
24
Dynamic avian response to pond changes over time Winter Small shorebirds
25
Conclusions Birds respond quickly to changes in water level and/or salinity Once ponds accrete enough sediment, vegetation establishment may be rapid Initial bird response is not necessarily indicative of long-term population changes Newly breached ponds create temporary mudflats that are desynchronized with Bay mudflats and extend shorebird foraging time Marsh conversion may replace mudflats, reducing foraging value
26
Future studies Need to quantify what factors influence bird density patterns in order to best manage reduced salt pond habitat for birds: Water depth Water quality Inundation time Tidal lags Vegetation growth Prey resources Proximity to islands and levees Landscape context
28
Drainage development over time
29
Conclusions Production ponds contain lower densities compared with ducks in Alviso and shorebirds in Eden Landing Density trends vary by pond complex Dabbling ducks, med. and small shorebirds densities have increased in restoration ponds
30
1 1 © Peter LaTourrette Goal: Mixture of habitats … diverse mosaic of habitats and species… Ma nag ed pon d salt pan slo ugh tidal mars h mu d flat upl and
32
Small shorebird trends Winter
Similar presentations
© 2025 SlidePlayer.com. Inc.
All rights reserved.