Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byJeffery Flynn Modified over 8 years ago
1
Key Category Trends Jon Swallen TNS Media Intelligence Sept. 6, 2007
2
2 TNS Media Intelligence What We Do Leading provider of strategic advertising and marketing information to U.S. advertisers, agencies and media properties Competitive intelligence across 20 media Monitoring the industry: 2.8 million brands $150 billion in ad expenditures 190 million ad occurrences (400,000 occurrences collected every day)
3
3 Today’s Agenda An economic focus centered on ad expenditures Spending levels Media allocation – where the money is going Select, high-value categories Key segments and advertisers Categories AutomotiveRestaurants Financial ServiceMotion Pictures TelecomDepartment Stores
4
4 Methodology All of the ad expenditure figures were pulled from the TNS MI database Internet spending reflects display advertising only – search not included For 2007, actual figures from January-May were used The notation “2007 (e)” An estimate developed by applying Jan-May 2007 growth rates to year-end 2006 actuals
5
5 Automotive
6
6 Automotive Category Definition INCLUDED Passenger cars and light trucks Manufacturers, dealer associations, local dealers EXCLUDED Motorcycles, mobile homes and RVs Commercial vehicles Aftermarket accessories, equipment, services
7
7 Background Stagnant sales Domestic manufacturers losing market share Attempting to reduce cost structure 7 consecutive quarters of declining advertising spend Falling ratio of ad spend to unit sales Still the # 1 ad category – 11% of total measured ad spend
8
8 Auto Advertising A 3 Year Slump $1.72 -3.9% -6.3% -8.0% +9.1% Source: TNS Media Intelligence
9
9 All Segments Are In Decline Source: TNS Media Intelligence
10
10 Total Nameplate Spending % Change: Jan-May 2007 vs. Year Ago Source: TNS Media Intelligence
11
11 Where Is The Money Going? Big Losers Newspaper spending off 35% from 2005 levels Smaller Losers (comparatively) National TV losses are widening Spot TV falling back in ‘07 Magazine spending has stabilized after the 2005-06 cutbacks Radio - a steadily leaking bucket Winners Internet display spending up 177% from 2005 levels
12
12 MediumFactory Dealer Associations Local Dealers National TV+5.9------- Spot TV(-1.0)+5.0+3.5 Newspapers(-6.2)(-5.3)(-6.5) Magazines(-1.8)--- Internet+3.10.8+1.7 Radio(-0.2)(-1.3)+0.6 Share of Spend: Scorecard Point Change: 2007 (e) vs. 2005 Source: TNS Media Intelligence
13
13 The Media Mix Has Shifted $19.16 Billion 32.2% 25.9% 24.8% 25.7% 25.6% 10.1% 21.8% 10.8% $16.51 Billion (est) Source: TNS Media Intelligence
14
14 Spot TV – Gaining Dealer Share $5.62 Billion 68.6% 62.1% 16.4% 20.0% 11.8% 11.3% $4.72 Billion (est) Source: TNS Media Intelligence
15
15 Recap A bloody mess A $3 billion hit Newspapers and TV had the most to lose…..and did It can’t get any worse…..can it?
16
Financial
17
17 Financial Advertising - $11.93 billion in 2006 Up 43% From 2003 +28.5% +92.7% +39.0% +27.7% -2.5% +42.7% Source: TNS Media Intelligence
18
18 Auto Insurance Background Fragmentation Concentration State Farm + Allstate + Progressive + GEICO = 43% share of market Short purchase cycle $15-25 billion in churn annually A price-driven marketplace Advertising’s role: build/maintain awareness and recognition
19
19 Auto Insurance Advertising Nearly Trebled Since 2003 +40.3% +27.4% +10.3% +45.0% Source: TNS Media Intelligence
20
20 Category Spending Is Concentrated 2003 Ad $ (millions) 2006 Ad $ (millions) 2003 % Share 2006 % Share TOTAL$600$1,557100.0% Top 4 Advtsrs$494$1,14082.3%73.2% Remainder$106$41717.7%26.8% Source: TNS Media Intelligence
21
21 Spending Concentrated Among Top 4 Companies 2003 Ad $ (millions) 2006 Ad $ (millions) % Change $184$497+ 170% $149$257+72% $109$234+116% $52$152+89% TOTAL$494$1,140+131% Source: TNS Media Intelligence
22
22 Growth Continuing Into 2007 January-May YTD % Change vs. Prior Year +16.7% +24.6% -16.4% +0.7% +7.3% Source: TNS Media Intelligence
23
23 Where Is The Money Going? TV share of category spend holding steady at 75-80% Split between national and spot TV varies by company Radio has 8-10% share Internet display has 3-5% share Would be considerably higher if search were measured and included
24
24 $1.14 billion in spend $417 million in spend 61.3% 15.0% 48.8% 35.5% Source: TNS Media Intelligence
25
25 Top Brands Pursue Different Media Mixes 2006 vs. 2003 Allstate Winner: National TV (+20 share points) Losers: Magazines (-15 pts) and Spot TV (-9 pts) GEICO Most diversified mix National TV dollars moved to spot TV and radio Progressive Dollars shifting from national TV to spot broadcast Deep spot market list State Farm National TV share has declined from 90% to 74% Internet display share has risen from 1% to 14%
26
26 Recap Auto insurance hot category – but presently running a bit cooler 30% growth rates are not sustainable Fierce competition among 4 national brands – which is sustainable Allstate, GEICO, Progressive, State Farm National TV still the preferred medium Allocations beginning to evolve as top brands seek to maintain consumer awareness and achieve competitive differentiation
27
Telecommunications
28
28 Background Shifting terrain Mergers and consolidation Convergence and competition Wireless penetration growth is subsiding
29
29 A Downturn in 2007 2006 Levels Inflated by AT&T $1.72 +1.5% +9.9% -5.6% +12.3% Source: TNS Media Intelligence
30
30 Segment Definitions Wireless Telephony All wireless services Wired Telephony Copper wire & VOIP Local and long distance ISP Internet service providers TV Service All TV services Cable, satellite or phone company Bundles Packaged offers of voice, video and ISP All Other Equipment, directories, corporate ads, et al
31
31 Wireless Still Advancing Other Segments Lagging -35.8% -3.9% -29.8% -37.4% +11.7% +114.5% 0 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500 $ Millions WirelessWiredTV SvcISPBundlesOther Jan-May 2006Jan-May 2007 Source: TNS Media Intelligence
32
32 20052006 Jan-May 2007 Ad Spend ($MM)1,6632,184866 % Change(-19.3%)31.4%(-13.6%) Ad Spend ($MM)1,5931,769793 % Change8.1%11.1%13.1% Ad Spend ($MM)1,0901,140535 % Change(-2.4%)4.6%18.8% Source: TNS Media Intelligence
33
33 20052006 Jan-May 2007 Comcast+16.3%+19.7%+45.5% Time Warner+7.6%(-22.9%)(-56.9%) DirecTV +8.5%+6.7%+5.9% Echostar +43.4%+35.9%(-37.0%) Alltel +4.4%+29.9%+56.0% Qwest (-22.7%)2.3%(-20.6%) Source: TNS Media Intelligence
34
34 Where Is The Money Going? Increased category spend has been disproportionately allocated towards national TV, leading to share gains Newspaper dollars have been flat, leading to share loss Internet display budgets holding steady at 8% of category spend Expanding faster among the Top 3 advertisers Spot TV spending has been comparatively more robust among the mid-size advertisers
35
35 Source: TNS Media Intelligence
36
36 % of Budget Allocated To Major Media Select Telecom Segments: Jan-May 2007 SegmentNat’l TV Spot TV NewspRadioInternet Wireless42.0%31.4% Wireline31.4%17.1%22.8% TV Services29.6%17.6%18.6%16.8% ISP29.4%39.2%17.8% Source: TNS Media Intelligence
37
37 National Chain Restaurants
38
38 Background A slow-growth, highly competitive industry Industry sales growing at low single-digit rates More than 350 advertised brands in 2006 Fresh concepts and new product offerings Health and nutrition
39
39 National Restaurants Modest Growth Rate $1.72 +5.8% +4.4% +1.5% +5.9% Source: TNS Media Intelligence
40
40 National Restaurants 100% = $4.75 Billion Source: TNS Media Intelligence
41
41 Top 10 Advertisers 2006 Rankings In Parentheses Ad Spend Trending Up Ad Spend Trending Flat/Down In Limbo McDonalds (1)Burger King (4)Wendy’s (3) Subway (2)KFC (6)Applebees (8) Taco Bell (5)Pizza Hut (7) Dominos (9) Chili’s (10)
42
42 20052006 Jan-May 2007 Ad Spend ($MM)672.4707.3307.9 % Change+9.7%+5.2%+7.2% Ad Spend ($MM)319.8353.5169.2 % Change+0.7%+10.6%+21.3% Ad Spend ($MM)231.6260.0109.4 % Change+9.8%+12.3%+6.2% Increasing Budgets Source: TNS Media Intelligence
43
43 Where Is The Money Going? TV the medium of choice for all the top chains National TV extending its share-of-market lead over Spot TV QSR and Casual Dining have different splits between National and Spot TV Radio share holding steady at around 9-10% But slipping within some segments Other media are minor players in this category
44
44 Spending Allocation Casual Dining vs. QSR $1.07 Billion (est) $3.00 Billion (est) Source: TNS Media Intelligence
45
45 Share of Budget: National vs. Spot TV Select Advertisers: Jan-May 2007 Advertiser % of Spend on National TV % of Spend on Spot TV McDonald’s52.2%20.9% Burger King70.7%3.3% Wendy’s67.2%13.8% Source: TNS Media Intelligence
46
46 Share of Budget: National vs. Spot TV Select Advertisers: Jan-May 2007 Advertiser % of Spend on National TV % of Spend on Spot TV Olive Garden92.6%6.6% Outback Steakhouse50.4%14.2% Denny’s84.9%8.9% Source: TNS Media Intelligence
47
47 Recap A $4.8 billion category dominated by TV advertising Budgets at most of the large chains are currently flat or down Large budget QSRs devote smaller share of spend to national TV than the casual dining restaurants with their mid-size budgets
48
Motion Pictures
49
49 Background Welcome to the digital revolution Traditional revenue streams being challenged Can Hollywood adapt? Advertising tactics largely unchanged Reach early, frequency late Thursday night fever
50
50 2004200520062007 YTD* Ad Spend ($Bn)3.883.933.921.63 % Change+0.7%+1.3%(-0.3%)+3.5% Box Office ($Bn)9.428.849.216.45 % Change+2.5%(-6.1%)+4.2%+6.8% Median Ad Budget ($ millions) 12.9813.6710.65--- * YTD periods: Jan 1- May 31 for ad spend; Jan 1 – Aug 16 for box office Ad Spend Lagging Box Office
51
51 Where’s The Money Going? National TV Dollars increasing at 3-6% per year Share of spend from 48% to 54% since 2004 Newspapers Down $240 million (-19%) since ‘04 Movie location and time info available elsewhere Spot TV Dollars and share trending flat 50% still goes to the Top 5 DMAs Internet Display Despite gains, still <4% of spend Next play: broad- band video?
52
Department Stores
53
53 Background Industry sales in decline since 2000 Mergers and consolidation Ad budgets moving towards national media
54
54 Source: U.S. Census Bureau
55
55 Department Stores Ad Spending Also Stagnant $1.72 -3.5% +0.8% -3.5% +2.7% Source: TNS Media Intelligence
56
56 Company 2006 Ad Spend ($ Millions) % Share of Category Spend % Change in Spend vs. ‘05 Macy’s1,06523.9%(-4.2%) Target64414.4%+10.0% Sears Holding58913.2%(-1.9%) Wal-Mart45610.2%(-10.0%) Kohl’s4359.8%+8.3% JC Penney4309.6%+8.7% 6 Holding Companies – 80% Share of Spend Source: TNS Media Intelligence
57
57 Parent Company 20032007 (e)% Change Ad Spend ($MM)466679+45.5% # Stores1,2251,502+22.6% Ad Spend ($MM)308460+49.4% # Stores542824+52.0% Expansion…. Sources: TNS Media Intelligence; Company annual reports
58
58 Parent Company 20032007 (e)% Change Ad Spend ($MM)1,2111,056(-12.8%) # Stores847858+1.2%) Ad Spend ($MM)718529(-26.4%) # Stores2,3822,323(-2.5%) …Contraction Note: Macy’s data are pro-forma and encompass the continuing operations of the former Federated and May companies.. Sears data are pro-forma and include the Sears and K-Mart divisions. Sources: TNS Media Intelligence; Company annual reports
59
59 Where Is The Money Going? Newspapers maintaining a plurality share of spend – but it’s shrinking Money is shifting into national media – both TV and magazines Macy’s; Target; Kohl’s Internet display still accounts for less than 5% of budgets
60
60 Kmart-Sears merger: March 2005 Federated-May merger: Aug 2005 Sources: TNS Media Intelligence;
61
61 Recap Anemic performance Mergers lead to consolidation of brands and ad budgets Pronounced shift from local media to national media
62
62 Wrap Up
63
63 Category 2006 Ad Spend ($ Billions) 2007 % Change: (Jan-May) Automotive$ 17.95(-6.3%) Auto Insurance$1.56+10.3% Telecom$ 9.18(-5.6%) Nat’l Restaurants$ 4.75+1.5% Motion Pictures$ 3.92+3.5% Dept. Stores$ 4.46(-3.5%) Where The Money Is Source: TNS Media Intelligence
Similar presentations
© 2024 SlidePlayer.com. Inc.
All rights reserved.