1. Presentation on New HEC Ranking Criteria

2. SCHEME OF PRESENTATION Parameters of old & new Ranking Criteria Comparative Study - HEC Ranking Criteria Old & New Current BU Status Recommendations

3. OLD & NEW PARAMETERS OF RANKINGS S.No Old Ranking Criteria (2010) ScoreS.No New Ranking Criteria (2012) Score 1 Implementation of QA Criteria 181 Quality Assurance & Enhancement 20 2Teaching Quality422Teaching Quality35 3Research403Research35 4Employer Perception5 5Peer Perception5 Total Score100 Total Score100

4. COMPARATIVE STUDY - HEC RANKING CRITERIA NEW & OLD 1. QA Criteria / Sub parameters S#Old Ranking Criteria (2010) MAX Points New Ranking Criteria (2012) MAX Points System for Assessment & Marking 1 Implementation of QA Criteria 18 Quality Assurance & Enhancement 20 aPlagiarism policy implementation6a 6 Based on evidence on various stages of implementation : 1. Constitution of Plagiarism standing committee (PSC) 2. Notifications/Minutes of Syndicate/BOG/Statutory body meetings. 3. Functioning of the committee (PSC) by resolving the plagiarism cases. b Eligibility Criteria for appointments of faculty members 4b 4 Based on adherence HEC criteria appointments of faculty members : 1. Notifications/Minutes of Syndicate/BOG/Statutory body meetings for implementation of criteria by university. c Criteria for M.Phil./MS & Ph.D. Programmes 4c Compliance of M.Phil./MS & Ph.D. criteria 4 Based on compliance of HEC criteria : 1. Notifications/Minutes of Syndicate/BOG/Statutory body meetings for implementation of criteria by university. d Quality Enhancement Cell Categorization 4d 6 As per scorecard developed and shared with Universities by QAA of HEC. Total Score18 Total Score20

5. S#Old Ranking Criteria (2010) MAX Points New Ranking Criteria (2012) MAX Points System for Assessment & Marking 2Teaching Quality42Teaching Quality35 a Student Teacher Ratio12 a Student Teacher Ratio 7 Total regular faculty and FTE (Full Time Equivalent) faculty will be considered for calculating overall Student Teacher Ratio. b Ratio of PhD faculty to total faculty 9 b 6 It is the PhD faculty divided by total faculty. For medical FRCS, FCP etc. will be treated as terminal degrees. c Selectivity5 c 5 It is the ratio of the total applicants seeking admission in the university and students actually selected. d Computers (Number of computers provided to students by university) 4 d Computers4 The total number of computers available to students and faculty of university. e Library books4 e 4 Total number of books at campus library excluding electronic books. f Full Time PhD faculty3N/A g Total PhD output for 20105 N/A f Ratio of Full time faculty to part time 3 It is the ratio of full time faculty to part time faculty. Full time faculty is regular and contractual faculty whereas part time faculty is the visiting faculty. N/A g Teacher Evaluation3 Mechanism of teacher evaluation established within the framework of QEC or universities’ own conducted faculty evaluation survey. N/A hTraining of faculty3 As per HEC record and data provided by universities on ranking proforma will be used for this component. Other faculty training information (National as well as international) as per evidence provided by universities will be considered. Total Score42 Total Score35 2. Teaching Quality/Sub-Parameters

6. 3.Research/Sub-Parameters S.No Old Ranking Criteria (2010) MAX Points New Ranking Criteria (2012) MAX Points System for Assessment & Marking 3Research403Research35 i HEC Approved supervisors 5 i Approved supervisors 5 HEC Approved supervisors are those who can enroll HEC scholars. Whereas HEC registered supervisors are those who can only supervise scholars which are not funded by HEC. ii Indigenous scholarship 4 ii Indigenous scholarship 4 Total number of HEC indigenous scholars enrolled in university as per records of HEC scholarship section. iii Research grants approved 2 iii Research grants approved other than HEC 2 As per the record of HEC R&D Division the number of research grants approved by the HEC will be used. Documentary evidence viz. MOUs etc. will be required for those research grants received by the university other than the HEC. Last 3 years data will be considered. iv Travel Grants approved 2 iv Travel Grants approved 2 As per the record of HEC R&D Division, number of travel grants received by the faculty members of the universities will be used. Documentary evidence will be required for those travel grants received by the university faculty other than the HEC sources. Last 3 years data will be considered.

7. S.No Old Ranking Criteria (2010) MAX Points S.NoNew Ranking Criteria (2012) MAX Points System for Assessment & Marking v Publications in Impact Factor Journals 5 v 4 ISI web of knowledge will be benchmark and (research output extracted by HEC Digital Library will be used. Details of Research Publications of Universities by HEC as flashed vi Number of papers published by the university 3 vi Number of papers published by the university 3 vii Citations 4 viiCitations3 viii University H Index 4 viiiUniversity H Index2 ix Number of W, X, Y, Z Journals Published by the University 5 ix Number of W, X, Y, Z Journals Published by the University 3 As per Quality Assurance Division’s record,, number of HEC recognized journals published by the university in W, X, Y, Z category will be used. x Internet Bandwidth (PERN) utilization 4 x 3 Average utilization of Internet bandwidth by the universities acquired through PERN and other ISPs will be used. Documentary proof MRTG (Multi Router Traffic Grapher), PRTG (Paessier Router Traffic Grapher) etc. of Internet bandwidth utilization will be required of other ISPs. xi Number of Conferences Organized 2 xi Number of Conferences Organized 2 As per the record of R&D Division, HEC the number of seminars, conferences, workshops & symposia organized by university through HEC funding will be used. In addition conferences etc. organized by universities through national/international collaboration from sources other than HEC funding will also be accounted, for which documentary evidence will be required. Last 3 years data will be considered. -- xiiTotal PhD output for 20112 Data provided by universities through ranking proforma and records of PhD Country Directory data will be used. Total Score40 Total Score35

8. S#Old Ranking Criteria (2010) MAX Points New Ranking Criteria (2012) MAX Points System for Assessment & Marking 3Employer Perception Survey3 5 N/A Employer Perception Survey All Universities have been requested to Provide the 05 top recruiters information in the relevant field. Employer perception survey will be finalized based on responses received from potential employers of university graduates. 4 Peer Perception 4 5 N/ANil Peer Perception Each university has been given opportunity to consider academic standing of other universities among peers and rank them as1,2,3, …. to 10, accordingly. Each university has to rate other one falling in the same category, excluding itself. Universities in ‘General Category’ will be providing peer perception according to respective size of distributed on enrollment basis, given below: Large>=7000 Medium>=3000 & <7000 Small <3000 The relevant list has been provided by HEC to each university. Total ScoreNil Total Score10 04. New Parameters added Note: Relative method of scoring or grading will be used among 18 General Large Universities

9. STATUS OF BU AMONG GENERAL UNIVERSITY (LARGE) OLD RANKING 2010 S.N o Institute Name Teaching Quality (42) QA Criteria (18) Research (40) Total Score (100) 1University of Punjab, Lahore 15.8917 12.1845 2University of Karachi 15.1110 10.6736 3Bahauddin Zakariya University, Multan 12.0812 9.7634 4University of Peshawar 12.0610 10.4332 5 Intemational Islamic University, Islamabad 9.1215 6.8332 6Govt College University, Faisalabad 8.0618 2.9529 7 Federal Urdu University,Arts, Science & Technolgy 8.8417 2.8429 8University of Sargodha 8.3513 4.6126 9University of Sindh, Jamshoro 8.3011 5.7425 10The Islamia University, Bahawalpur 9.3310 5.6925 11Hazara University, Mansehra 8.6313 3.1625 12Bahria University 6.3515 2.1824 13University of Education, Lahore 4.9415 2.7023 14 National University of Modern Languages, Islamabad 5.6914 2.5422 15University of Gujrat 5.9714 1.5822 16Preston University, Kohat 7.057 0.3714 17University of Lahore 6.315 0.7212

10. BU STATUS Old V/S New S.No Status (2010) Points scored out Status (2012) Max Points 1 Implementation of QA Criteria 18 Quality Assurance & Enhancement 20 1 Plagiarism Standing Committee 3 Out of 6 Plagiarism policy implementation 2 Appointment Criteria 4 Out of 4 Eligibility Criteria for appointments of faculty members 3 Criteria for MS/Mphil & Phd 4 Out of 4 Compliance of M.Phil./MS & Ph.D. criteria 4 QEC Categorization 4 Out of 4 Quality Enhancement Cell Categorization Total 15 Out of 18

11. BU STATUS Old V/S New S.No Status (2010) Ratio / Nos Status (2012) Ratio/ Nos Teaching Quality (6.35 out of 42) Teaching Quality (35) 1 Student Teacher Ratio (8308:593) 14:1 Student Teacher Ratio (9867:813) 12:1 2 Ratio of PhD faculty to total faculty 40:1007 1:25 Ratio of PhD faculty to total faculty (76:737) 1:9 3 Selectivity (No of applicants against available seats) 8500:2500 3:1 Selectivity (No of applicants against available seats) 12000:3000 4:1 4 Computers (No of computers for the students provided by university) 642 Computers (No of computers for the students and faculty provided by university) 1027 5 Library books 50,000 Library books 55,001 6 Full Time PhD faculty 41 Full Time PhD faculty 40 7 Full Time faculty 406 Full Time faculty 392 8 Part Time Faculty 560 Part Time Faculty 345 9 Full Time Equivalent Faculty 593 Not Asked 10 Total PhD output for 2010 0 Not Asked 11 Not Asked - Ratio of Full time faculty to part time (392:345) 1:1 12 Not Asked - Teacher Evaluation 13 Not AskedTraining of faculty 226

12. BU STATUS Old V/S New S.No Status (2010) Nos Status (2012) Nos iHEC Approved supervisors7Approved supervisors15 iiIndigenous scholarship6 16 iiiResearch grants approved4 Research grants approved other than HEC 24 ivTravel Grants approved10Travel Grants approved13

13. BU STATUS Old V/S New S.No Status (2010) Nos Status (2012) Nos v Publications in Impact Factor Journals - 14 (July 11-June12) vi Number of papers published by the university 10 Number of papers published by the university 25 vii Citations 3 7 viii University H Index2 - ix Number of W, X, Y, Z Journals Published by the University 0 - x Internet Bandwidth (PERN) utilization 18 Mbs out of 48 Mbs Internet Bandwidth (PERN) utilization 28.64% Utilization in Islamabad Campus 25.91% Utilization in Karachi Campus xi Number of Conferences Organized 0 28 Total PhD output for 20110

14. BU STATUS Old V/S New S.No Status (2010) Max Points Status (2012) Max Points Employer Perception Survey 1 Not AskedEmployer Perception Survey Peer Perception 2 Not Asked Peer Perception

15. COMPARATIVE STUDY – QA CRITERIA GENERAL UNIVERSITIES (LARGE) S.NoInstitute Name Appointment Criteria Criteria for MS/Mphil & Phd QEC Categorization Plagiarism Standing Committee Total 201020122010201220102012201020122010 1 Govt. College University, Faisalabad. 4446 18 2 Federal Urdu University of Arts, Science & Technology. 4436 17 3 University of The Punjab, Lahore 4436 17 4 Bahria University, Islamabad 4443 15 5 International Islamic University. 4443 15 6 University of Education, Lahore. 4416 15 7 National University of Modern Languages, Islamabad. 4433 14 8University of Gujrat.4433 14 9 Hazara University Mansehra, KPK. 4423 13 10University of Sargodha.4423 13 11 Bahauddin Zakariya University, Multan. 0426 12 University of Sindh.4430 11 13 The Islamia University of Bahawalpur, Pakistan. 4420 10 14University of Karachi.4033 10 15University of Peshawar.0433 10 16Preston University, Kohat4003 7 17University of Lahore, Lahore0023 5 18 National University of Science & Technlogy (NUST) 444418

16. COMPARATIVE STUDY - TEACHING QUALITY GENERAL UNIVERSITIES (LARGE) S.No Institute Name Student / Teacher Ratio ComputersApplicantsLibraryPhD Output Graduate/ Postgraduate students Undergraduate Students FT PhD Faculty FT FacultyPT Faculty FTE Faculty 201020122010201220102012201020122010201220102012201020122010201220102012201020122010 1BZU 17:1 3,500 35,000 304,573 15 7,256 7,594 175 523 960 843 2 Bahria University 14:118:1 6421027 8,476 11,539 50,000 55,00101 2,0542933 6,2546934 4140 406392 560345 593 3FUUAST 14:1 474 2,418 127,973 0 4,509 5,163 114 432 655 650 4 GCU, Faisalabad 16:1 800 16,942 19,500 1 3,530 8,603 117 592 426 734 5 Hazara University Mansehra 19:1950 11,000 107,000 0 1,175 7,090 79 405 81 432 6IIUI 23:1 3,478 16,642 119,560 16 8,333 11,323 156 585 777 844 7IUB 21:1 2,100 22,602 225,000 35 7,974 6,654 115 533 487 695 8KU 23:1 5,500 30,000 366,441 125 12,042 15,162 342 739 1,276 1,164 9NUML 26:1 600 6,156 115,000 24 9,741 4,146 49 513 29 523 10NUST 17:1 6,519 46,832 342,896 10 890 7,337 303 912 116 951 11PU 25:1 6,500 140,054 1,223,600 108 13,715 16,893 367 1,006 614 1,211 12 Preston University, Kohat 27:1 2,630 4,693 51,472 0 4,689 7,434 65 363 246 445 13UOE, LHR 47:1 893 30,000 169,964 5 8,213 5,051 29 247 104 282 14 UOS, Sargodha 25:1 1,500 18,263 78,721 3 6,521 8,244 132 559 55 577 15 UOP, Peshawar 22:1 1,350 20,000 191,197 7 5,938 5,706 179 419 267 508 16 UOS, Sindh 33:1 1,458 15,372 382,201 15 3,628 16,039 133 570 67 592 17 University of Gujrat 20:1 800 15,942 25,141 0 2,668 7,001 38 458 18 464 18 University of Lahore 16:1 1,680 11,693 25,409 0 2,679 11,290 44 770 163 824

17. COMPARATIVE STUDY - RESEARCH GENERAL UNIVERSITIES (LARGE) S.N o Institute Name ConferencesPERNH-INDEXCitations Research Papers HEC Aprvd Suprvsrs HEC Travel Grants Indigenous Scholars Research Grants W CategoryX CategoryY CategoryZ Category 20102012201020122010201220102012201020122010201220102012201020122010201220102012201020122010201220102012 1BZU 32516141143961928021 21 2 Bahria University 2818252-37102571510136244 1 3FUUAST 295356111122717 4 GCU, Faisalabad 6988734671422 2 5 Hazara UniversityM ansehra 2466358336193 6IIUI 33376157556917214 1 3 7IUB 2149998836411558 1 8KU 2 2530539280531221353 46 9NUML 7134186620 3 10NUST 4 42 19 273 155 17044 103 80 11PU 3402048735618248441531398 12 Preston University, Kohat 1397 0 13UOE, LHR 13411974252 1 14 UOS, Sargodha 91322819348173514 15 UOP, Peshawar 82714247153733217126 45 16 UOS, Sindh 320211799515361218 16 17 University of Gujrat 181620 8 1 18 University of Lahore 53 613210

18. RECOMMENDATIONS There must be some benchmark to measure performance. Despite weaknesses and flaws in the assessment, HEC benchmark be followed in letter & spirit. Any suggestion on proposed New Criteria of Ranking be forwarded to QA Dte for onward submission to HEC for consideration / review. Number of HEC enrolled indigenous scholars be increased Number of Research Grants from HEC & from other sources like: USAID, JICA, Corporate sector & NGOs etc be increased. Number of travel grants from HEC & other services be increased More utilization of PERN Organizing Conferences, National & International with the funding from HEC or atleast HEC may be intimated

19. Thank You

20. No.Institute Teaching Quality QA CriteriaResearchTotal Score 1Quaid-i-Azam University, Islamabad23.881132.4667 2Government College University, Lahore14.651311.9540 3Gomal University, D.I Khan10.64174.7132 4 Kohat University of Science and Technology, Kohat 9.54154.0729 5Shah Abdul Latif University, Khairpur9.18144.3928 6 The University of Azad Jammu & Kashmir, AJ&K 9.72153.5828 7 Riphah International University, Islamabad 9.74152.6727 8 Fatima Jinnah Women University, Rawalpindi 8.22152.7126 9University of Balochisan, Quetta9.44133.7326 10 University of Management & Technology, Lahore 7.49134.8125 11Forman Christian College, Lahore14.4571.9223 12 Mohammad Ali Jinnah University, Karachi 7.5336.717 13Hamdard University, Karachi6.8272.1216 14Jinnah University for Women, Karachi7.3970.6915 University of Central Punjab, Lahore5.6881.4715 GENERAL UNIVERSITIES MEDIUM

21. No.Institute Teaching Quality QA Criteria Research Total Score 1Pakistan Institute of Development Economics, Islamabad23.4367.7237 2University of Faisalabad, Faisalabad16.14150.7832 3Sardar Bahadur Khan Women's University, Quetta12.13152.3930 4National Defence University, Islamabad12.23113.9627 5Karakurum International University, Gilgit11.23121.7725 6Textile Institute of Pakistan, Karachi14.1611025 7University of Malakand, Dir, Malakand7.29133.3324 8Foundation University, Islamabad11.9673.322 9 Beaconhouse National University, Lahore7.59130.421 Dadabhoy Institute of Higher Education, Karachi6.0515021 Frontier Women University, Peshawar4.86151.4621 Sarhad University of Science and Information Technology, Peshawar10.05110.2621 University of South Asia, Lahore7.7111.921 10GIFT University, Gujranwala8.5211020 11 Indus Institute of Higher Education, Karachi8.5910019 Mohiuddin Islamic University, AJ&K7.7110.0119 12Hajvery University, Lahore6.7311018 13Kinnaird College For Women, Lahore8.1990.4818 14The Superior College, Lahore10.9170.0618 15 Karachi Institute of Economics & Technology, Karachi9.9370.5617 Newport Institute of Communications & Economics, Karachi5.89110.2517 16Greenwich University, Karachi8.3170.2516 17Minhaj University, Lahore11.033014 18Preston Institute of Management, Science and Technology, Karachi7.763011 19Preston University, Karachi7.301.018 GENERAL UNIVERSITIES SMALL

22. No. Institute Teaching Quality QA CriteriaResearch Total Score 1 Pakistan Institute of Engineering and Applied Sciences, Islamabad 36.511728.2781.79 2 National University of Sciences and Technology, Islamabad 25.831818.2262.05 3 Ghulam Ishaq Khan Institute of Engineering Sciences & Technology, Topi 24.37922.6756.03 4University of Engineering and Technology- Lahore16.151211.6539.79 5University of Engineering and Technology-Taxila16.821012.2339.05 6Institute of Space Technology, Islamabad14.72149.9238.64 7KPK University of Engineering and Technology12.48126.0530.53 8 Mehran University of Engineering & Technology, Jamshoro 12.11125.5929.7 9 NED University of Engineering & Technology, Karachi 10.66134.528.16 10Air University, Islamabad13.77104.2728.04 11National Textile University, Faisalabad9.6888.4426.12 12 Quaid-e-Awam University of Engineering, Science & Technology, Nawabshah 7.97141.5423.51 13 Balochistan University of Engg & Technology, Khuzdar 8.37131.5222.89 14 Sir Syed University of Engineering & Technology, Karachi 7.59140.8622.45 15Mirpur University of Science & Technology, AJ&K6.78132.1821.96 16 Dawood College of Engineering & Technology, Karachi 5.7814019.78 ENGINEERING

23. No.Institute Teaching Quality QA Criteria Research Total Score 1 Lahore University of Management Sciences, Lahore30.381424.8369 2Institute of Business Administration Karachi17.09158.4241 3Iqra University,Karachi20.09145.9640 4 Sukkar, Institute of Business Administration, Sukkar17.32157.3140 5 National College of Business Administration & Economics, Lahore22.11114.5938 6 Shaheed Zulfikar Ali Bhutto Institute of Science & Technology, Karachi11.51118.9431 7 Institute of Management Sciences,Peshawar9.14148.331 8Lahore School of Economics, Lahore13.48114.6129 9 Imperial College of Business Studies, Lahore20.117027 10Institute of Management Sciences, Lahore10.6112.4724 11Institute of Business Management, Karachi10.29101.7422 12 Institute of Business and Technology, Karachi17.820.2520 13KASB Institute of Technology, Karachi11.6670.3519 Business Education

24. No.Institute Teaching Quality (42) QA Criteria (18) Research (40) Total Score Position 1 COMSATS Institute of Information Technology (CIIT), Islamabad 28.671524.77681 2 National University of Computer and Emerging Sciences (NU-FAST), Islamabad 33.06918.85612 3 Qurtaba University of Science and Information Technology, D I Khan 26.72115.55433 4 Balochistan University of Information Technology and Management Sciences, Quetta 16.79146.04374 5 City University of Science and Information Technology, Peshawar 16.1110.91285 6 CECOS University of Information Technology and Emerging Sciences, Peshawar 14.61110266 Computer Sciences & IT Category