Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byGabriel Ford Modified over 9 years ago
1
BioUML Fedor Kolpakov Institute of Systems Biology (spin-off of DevelopmentOnTheEdge.com) Laboratory of Bioinformatics, Design Technological Institute of Digital Techniques Novosibirsk, Russia
2
Agenda Part 1: overview of BioUML workbench Cafe break Part 2: new concepts and possibilities (versions 0.8.0 – 0.8.3) Further development Questions and discussion
3
Part 1: overview of BioUML workbench Overview Main concepts Meta model Architecture overview Diagram types Database module concepts Full text search Graph search Simulation engine BioUML server BMOND/Biopath database Live demonstration: Installation of BioUML workbench Creating and simulating simple model SBML - Biomodels module BioPAX import BMOND database web interface JavaScript shell
4
Part 2: new concepts and possibilities Overview Reconstruction as solitaire game Levels of biological information BioHub concept Composite database module Composite diagram Experiment concept Graphic notation editor Microarray data analysis Live demonstration Loading database modules from server Text search Graph search Creating of composite database module Creating of composite diagram Experiment Graphic notation editor Microarray data analysis
5
Useful resources http://www.biouml.org/demo Flash movies that demonstrates how to work with BioUML workbench http://www.biouml.org/user/help/index.html http://www.biouml.org/download/0.7.8/manual.doc Useguide, >200 pages -HTML version -MS Word document http://bmond.biouml.org Examples of pathway annotation: BMOND – Biological Models aNd Diagrams database
6
Part 1 Overview of BioUML workbench
7
Main BioUML concepts and ideas Visual modeling oMeta model – problem domain neutral level of abstraction that describes system as compartmentalized graph oDiagram type concept – formally defines graphical notation and provides its incorporation into BioUML workbench. oAutomated code generation for model simulation. Database module concept - allows developer to incorporate databases on biological pathways into BioUML workbench taking into account database peculiarities. Plug-in based architecture (Eclipse platform runtime from IBM company).
8
Biological databases Data search and retrieving Visual modeling Automated code generation for model simulation of model behavior Formal description of structure of biological system MATLAB codeJava code Simulating using MATLAB. JMatLink allows to BioUML workbench to start MATLAB and retrieve simulations results Java simulation plug-in. Contains ODE solvers ported from odeToJava and methods for hybrid models support. … code
9
Meta model
10
Corresponding mathematical model: Example: system from two chemical reactions A B -k1[A] R1 C -k2[B] K2[B] R2 1000 0 k1 - reaction rate for R1 k2 – reaction rate for R2
11
A B -k1[A] R1 C -k2[B] R2 100 0 0 System structure is described as a graph Mathematical model of the system Description of system components in the database ID A CC..... // ID R1 A->B... // ID B CC..... // ID R2 B->C... // ID C CC..... // A B -k1[A] R1 C -k2[B] R2 1000 0 Meta-model: example of formal description of system from two chemical reactions
12
Suggested approach can be applied for modeling biological systems using: –Systems of ordinary differential equations –Systems of algebra-differential equations –State and transition diagrams –Hybrid models –Boolean and logical networks –Petri nets –Markov chains –Stochastic models –Cellular automates –… Some limitations –Spatial models –PDE –…
13
BioUML architecture
14
Plug-in based architecture Plug-in - plugin.xml - Java jar files A plug-in is the smallest unit of BioUML workbench function that can be developed and delivered separately into BioUML workbench. A plug-in is described in an XML manifest file, called plugin.xml. The parsed contents of plug-in manifest files are made available programmatically through a plug-in registry API provided by Eclipse runtime. - extension points are well-defined function points in the system where other plug-ins can contribute functionality. - extension is a specific contribution to an extension point. Plug-ins can define their own extension points, so that other plug-ins can integrate tightly with them. Plug-in - plugin.xml - Java jar files Plug-in - plugin.xml - etc. Eclipse platform runtime
16
Formal description and modeling of biological systems require coordinated efforts of different group of researchers: programmers - they should provide computer tools for this task. problem domain experts - they should specify what and how should be described. experimenters and annotators - they should describe corresponding data following to these rules. mathematicians - they should provide methods for models analysis and simulations. BioUML architecture separates these tasks so they can be effectively solved by corresponding group of researchers and provides simple contract how these groups and corresponding software parts should communicate.
17
Diagram types
18
Diagram type concept Diagram type defines: · types of biological components and their interactions that can be shown on the diagram; · diagram view builder - it is used to generate view for each diagram element taking into account problem domain peculiarities; · semantic controller - provides semantic integrity of the diagram during its editing; · filters – hide or highlight diagram elements according to some selection criteria.
19
Reconstruction and formal description of biological systems using different diagram types 1. Semantic network 2. Pathway diagram (semantic network + gene network or metabolic pathway) 3. Metabolic pathway 4. Gene network 5. Pathway simulation (mathematical model) Formality, details Semi-structured data Structured data (reactions and its components) Kinetic data (kinetic laws, constants, initial values
20
Graphic notation
21
Stimulus activating NF-kappaB (semantic network, ontology)
22
NF-kappaB family (semantic network, ontology)
23
Function of human DNA methyltransferases (pathway diagram)
24
The biosynthesis of catecholamines (metabolic pathway)
25
Cell cycle model of mammalian G1/S transition control with E2F feedback loops (pathway simulation diagram)
26
DGR0356 “NF-kB model” (Hoffmann et al., 2002)
27
NF-kB dynamics in nucleus and cytoplasm before and after TNF-alpha stimulation (Hoffmann et al., 2002)
28
Regulation of caspase-3 activation and degradation (Stucki and Simon, 2005 )
33
Database module concept The database module concept allows to developer define new diagram types and incorporate other databases on biological pathways into BioUML framework. The database module defines mapping of database content into diagram elements and diagram types that can be used with the database. Module also provides query engine that can be used by BioUML workbench to find interactiong components of the system.
34
BioUML database modules BioUML standard module Databases EBI databases: Ensembl, UniProt, ChEBI, GeneOntology Biopath/BMOND (http://biopath.biouml.org) KEGG/Ligand (http://www.kegg.com) TRANSPATH (http://www.biobase.de) GeneNet (http://wwwmgs.bionet.nsc.ru) Formats SBML – Systems Biology Markup Language, level 1, 2 (http:// www.sbml.org) CellML – Cell Markup Language (http://www.cellml.org) BioPax – Biological Pathways Exchange (http://www.biopax.org) PSI-MI OBO GXL - Graph eXchange Language ( http://www.gupro.de/GXL)
35
KEGG pathway
36
CellML model
37
SBML model
38
Full text search
39
User interface for full text search: 1) pop-up menu; 2) menu buttons for selected entity; 3) full text search pane.
40
Full text search (uses Lucene engine)
42
Graph search
43
Graph search engine
45
Simulation engine
46
Biological databases Data search and retrieving Visual modeling Automated code generation for model simulation of model behavior Formal description of structure of biological system MATLAB codeJava code Simulating using MATLAB. JMatLink allows to BioUML workbench to start MATLAB and retrieve simulations results Java simulation plug-in. Contains ODE solvers ported from odeToJava and methods for hybrid models support. … code
48
%script for 'CellCycle_1991Gol' model simulation %constants declaration global Reaction1_vi Reaction2_kd Reaction4_K1 Reaction4_Kc Reaction4_VM1 Reaction5_K3 Reaction5_VM3 Reaction6_K2 Reaction6_V2 Reaction7_K4 Reaction7_V4 Reaction1_vi = 0.023 Reaction2_kd = 0.00333 Reaction4_K1 = 0.1 Reaction4_Kc = 0.3 Reaction4_VM1 = 0.5 Reaction5_K3 = 0.1 Reaction5_VM3 = 0.2 Reaction6_K2 = 0.1 Reaction6_V2 = 0.167 Reaction7_K4 = 0.1 Reaction7_V4 = 0.1 %Model rate variables and their initial values y = [] y(1) = 0.0 % y(1) - $cytoplasm.C y(2) = 0.0 % y(2) - $cytoplasm.EmptySet y(3) = 0.0 % y(3) - $cytoplasm.M y(4) = 0.0 % y(4) - $cytoplasm.X %numeric equation solving [t,y] = ode23('CellCycle_1991Gol_dy',[0 100],y) %plot the solver output plot(t,y(:,1),'-',t,y(:,2),'-',t,y(:,3),'-',t,y(:,4),'-') title ('Solving Goldbeter problem') ylabel ('y(t)') xlabel ('x(t)') legend('$cytoplasm.C','$cytoplasm.EmptySet','$cytoplasm.M','$cytoplasm.X');
49
Function to calculate dy/dt for the model function dy = CellCycle_1991Gol_dy(t, y) % Calculates dy/dt for 'CellCycle_1991Gol' model. %constants declaration global Reaction1_vi Reaction2_kd Reaction4_K1 Reaction4_Kc Reaction4_VM1 Reaction5_K3 Reaction5_VM3 Reaction6_K2 Reaction6_V2 Reaction7_K4 Reaction7_V4 % write rules to calculate some eqution parameters rateOfReaction1 = Reaction1_vi; rateOfReaction4 = ((1 - y(3))*Reaction4_VM1*y(1))/((1 + Reaction4_K1 - y(3))*(Reaction4_Kc + y(1))); rateOfReaction5 = (Reaction5_VM3*(1 - y(4))*y(3))/(1 + Reaction5_K3 - y(4)); rateOfReaction6 = (y(3)*Reaction6_V2)/(Reaction6_K2 + y(3)); rateOfReaction7 = (Reaction7_V4*y(4))/(Reaction7_K4 + y(4)); rateOfReaction2 = y(1)*Reaction2_kd; % calculates dy/dt for 'CellCycle-1991Gol.xml' model dy = [ + rateOfReaction1 - rateOfReaction2 - rateOfReaction1 - rateOfReaction4 - rateOfReaction5 + rateOfReaction6 + rateOfReaction7 + rateOfReaction2 + rateOfReaction4 - rateOfReaction6 + rateOfReaction5 - rateOfReaction7]
52
Results of SBML semantic tests
54
BioModels – comparison BioUML simulation results with other simulators http://www.biouml.org/_biomodels/
55
Simulators comparison criteria Passed – CSV file was generated by simulator interval criteria no difference - 0.999 * min < x < 1.001 * max or x < ZERO and max < ZERO small difference – 0.5 * min < x < 1.5 * max significant difference - otherwise median criteria no difference - abs((x – median)/median) < 0.01 or x < ZERO and median < ZERO small difference - abs((x – median)/median) < 0.5 significant difference – otherwise x – variable value provided by compared simulator min, max, median – calculated from values provided by other simulators with which the specified simulator is being compared. Implementation note: if result file was not generated by BioUML, then other simulators can be compared one to each other.
57
BioUML Enterprise Edition: BioUML server
58
BioUML workbench Servlet container: Tomcat BioUML EE architecture MySQL database Web browser JDBC BeanExplorer Enterprise Edition Client side: Server side: Database module BioUML servlet JDBC DB module Lucene full text search engine
59
BMOND Biological MOdels aNd Diagrams database (former name – Biopath)
60
BioUML workbench Servlet container: Tomcat BMOND system architecture Biopath MySQL database Web browser JDBC BeanExplorer Enterprise Edition Client side: Server side: Biopath module
61
Figure 4. G1/S entry model (Kel et al., 2000) described using BioUML technology.
63
BMOND web interface live demonstration http://bmond.biouml.org - Interface overview - View diagrams - View diagram components - List of diagram components - Categories (classification) - Filter - Dynamic columns - Web forms for components editing
64
Part 2 New concepts and possibilities
65
Part 2: new concepts and possibilities Overview Reconstruction as solitaire game Levels of biological information BioHub concept Composite database module Composite diagram Experiment concept Graphic notation editor Microarray data analysis Live demonstration Loading database modules from server Text search Graph search Creating of composite database module Creating of composite diagram Experiment Graphic notation editor Microarray data analysis
66
Metaphor: biological systems reconstruction as solitaire (patience) game Desk – BioUML editor Solitaire – biological pathway Cards – biological objects (genes, proteins, lipids, etc.) Pack of cards – different biological databases
67
UniProtEnsembl ChEBI GO Level 1: Catalogs Level 2: Pathways, models GeneModels Biological objects Levels of biological information refers Level 3: Problem specific Cyclonet - leads - actions - targets refers LipidNet classifications: - lipids - genes refers UbiProt classifications: E1, E2, E3, … Main idea for data integration and pathway reconstruction: - escape information duplication - classify components of biological pathways by levels - each next level should refer but do not duplicate information from previous levels - use free EBI databases whenever it is possible. BMOND refers wikiwiki wikiwiki wikiwiki
68
Add-on technology This approach should help us to solve difficulties with usage of external catalogs when external catalog does not contain needed entity (for example gene or substance) or when we would like to add some information to existing entity description. Example for BMOND2, gene: special table allow us to add new entity to BMOND2 if such entity missing in corresponding external catalog. Gene catalog Ensembl Gene add-on table Synonyms Description DB references Literature references Classification SQL query BioUML BeanExplorer Web interface Java object Lucene Document
69
BioHub
70
BioHub concept BioHUB – an approach link information from different databases. Main usage: –binding microarray (omics) data to pathway diagrams –graph search –DBReferences editor –microarray (omics) data analysis Follows to MIRIAM standard: –References to database objects –Relationships between biological objects Simple Java API
71
BioHub structure Entities - DB_ID - version - ID - AC - species - description - key words Relations - DB_ID_1 - DB_version_1 - ID_1 - DB_ID_2 - DB_version_2 - ID_2 - relation - evidence - comment Databases - DB_ID - name - description - URL - url_patern_ID - url_patern_AC RelationTypes - relation - description - backwardRelation - comment RelationInfo - DB_ID_1 - DB_ID_2 - relation - comment
72
UniProtEnsembl ChEBI GO Level 1: Catalogs Level 2: Pathways, models GeneModels Biological objects Linking with experimental data and results of analysis refers Level 3: Problem specific BMOND refers Experimental data, results of analysis BioHUB OMICS data Results of analysis MSigDBGeneAtlas, NCI60 Cyclonet - leads - actions - targets refers LipidNet classifications: - lipids - genes refers UbiProt classifications: E1, E2, E3, … wikiwiki wikiwiki wikiwiki
73
UniProtEnsembl ChEBI GO Level 1: Catalogs Level 2: Pathways, models GeneModels Biological objects Linking with external databases refers Level 3: Problem specific BMOND refers Experimental data, results of analysis BioHUB OMICS data Results of analysis MSigDBGeneAtlas, NCI60 External databases: - KEGG - LipidMap, LipidBank - Reactome, … Cyclonet - leads - actions - targets refers LipidNet classifications: - lipids - genes refers UbiProt classifications: E1, E2, E3, … wikiwiki wikiwiki wikiwiki
74
Coloring diagram according to microarray data. Each bar corresponds to one value from corresponding microarray series.
75
Coloring diagram according to omics data
76
BioHub usage: graph search engine
77
Composite database module Flash movie: XML_module.exe
78
Composite database module is defined formally as XML document. It allows: specify dependencies from other database modules specify data types that can be used from external database modules describe dynamic properties for add-on technology specify what dynamic properties can be added to data types from external modules. This information will be stored in local module and merged dynamically with information from external modules. By this way user can add information to external catalogs like Ensembl, UniPropt, etc. specify data types used by local module specify diagram types used by local module specify QueryEngine Composite database module
79
DTD <!ELEMENT dbModule (jdbcConnection, properties?, dependencies?, types?)> name CDATA #REQUIRED title CDATA #REQUIRED description PCDATA version CDATA "0.8.0" type CDATA text|SQL databaseType CDATA databaseVersion CDATA databaseName CDATA > name CDATA #REQUIRED jdbcDriverClass CDATA #REQUIRED jdbcURL CDATA #REQUIRED jdbcUser CDATA jdbcPassword CDATA >
80
<!ATTLIST property name CDATA #REQUIRED type CDATA #REQUIRED short-description CDATA #IMPLIED value CDATA > <!ATTLIST tag name CDATA #REQUIRED value CDATA #IMPLIED > <!ATTLIST propertyRef name CDATA #REQUIRED value CDATA >
81
name CDATA #REQUIRED > <!ATTLIST externalType name CDATA #REQUIRED readOnly CDATA true|false > name CDATA #REQUIRED type CDATA Java|XML class CDATA path CDATA >
82
section CDATA #REQUIRED name CDATA #REQUIRED class CDATA #REQUIRED transformer CDATA #REQUIRED > class CDATA #REQUIRED luceneIndexes CDATA > class CDATA #REQUIRED table CDATA >
83
Editor for composite database module
87
Current status: Implemented: Database modules (initial version): Ensembl, UniProt, ChEBI, GO, IntAct, Reactome, BioModels Composite module (external referencies) –Defined as XML –Composite module editor Selecting and loading modules from server In process: BioHUB Protein state concept Add-on technology BMOND2 – redesigned version of BMOND.
88
From huge theory to practical output Automated language translation Practical output electronic dictionaries spell checkers Biological data integrations Practical output catalogs (Ensembl, UniProt, CheBI) controlled vocabularies, ontologies hubs
89
Model composition
90
Composite diagram: main concepts Block types: 1) block – only mathematical equations. Used mainly for physiological models; 2) subdiagram – other diagram Connection types: 1) directed – input output. Transformation function can be used; 2) undirected – contact. Indicates that 2 nodes in mode is the same entity. Semantic constraints: There are semantic constraints, for example: block can have only one input for each variable. Two inputs are forbidden for the same variable. Flat model: Before Matlab or Java code generation composite model is transformed into flat model and usual genertions routines are used.
91
Experiment
92
To make a virtual experiment it is frequently needed to modify initial model. Typical modifications (changes) are: changing of initial values changing of model parameters to imitate different conditions or mutations deleting of some model elements to imitate knock-out mutations adding events to imitate external influences on the model To skip model duplications for each virtual experiment we introduce “changes” concept.
95
Graphic notation formal definition as XML document http://www.biouml.org/sbgn.shtml Flash movie: Graphic_Notations_Editor.exe
96
Graphic notation versus graph layout allows edit diagram allows to create new diagram different graphic notations can be applied to the same SBML model allows formally define SBGN and use it in SBML models allows to reuse graphic notation by many tools
97
Graphic notation can be defined formally as XML document properties – formal definition of properties that can be used as properties of nodes and edges (for example, title, multimer, etc.). Definition of property includes: –name –type –short description –controlled vocabulary (optional) node types – definition of node includes: –name –icon –properties –view function (JavaScript) –short description edge types – definition of edge includes: –name –icon –properties –view function (JavaScript) –short description semantic controller – defines rules for semantic control of diagram integrity. For this purpose it defines following functions: –canAccept (JavaScript) –isResizable (JavaScript) –move (JavaScript) Examples – a set of diagrams that can be used as test cases, legend and examples for the graphic notation. DML - Diagram Markup Language – is used for this purpose.
98
SBML… Diagram Model API BioPAXLayout information Graphic notation Layout APINotation API Rendering engine JavaScript functions: - build node/edge view - semantic control Initial data JavaScript API for data access Rendering API JavaScript API for creating primitives similar with SBML layout extension Basic software architecture for rendering of biological models according to specified graphic notation and layout information
99
Formal definition of graphic notation as XML document and integration with SBML format
100
Graphic notation editor main concepts graphic notation is defined formally as XML document graphic notation editor provides user friendly interface for XML document editing SBGN graphic notation (prototype) is implemented BioUML workbench allows to create and edit diagrams using graphic notation defined as XML document May be graphic editor will be useful for SBGN community for: –improving SBGN specification –for testing SBGN specification by creating different diagrams Details: http://www.biouml.org/sbgn.shtml
101
BioUML workbech Select ‘Data’ tab to see the tab with a list with available graphic notations
102
Click right mouse button on selected graphic notation to open it Graphic Notation Editor
103
Main sections of formal definition of graphic notation
104
List of specific properties that are used by graphic notation Properties editor
105
User can click right mouse button on Properties node to create new property
106
Nodes – contains list of all node types used by graphic notation
107
For each node type user can define: - name - properties - icon - view function (JavaScript)
108
By clicking right mouse button on “Nodes” user can create new node type
109
By the same way user can define edge type: - name - properties - icon - view function (JavaScript)
110
“Examples” node contains a set of diagrams that demonstrates usage of graphic notation.
111
User can create and edit such diagram.
112
When user selects some element on the diagram he can edit: - object properties - JavaScript that builds a view for selected diagram element
113
“Semantic controller” node contains list of JavaScript functions that provide semantic constraints and semantic integrity of the diagram.
114
Graphic notation defined as XML document can be used by BioUML workbench to create corresponding diagram.
116
Graphic Notation Editor SBGN examples created in BioUML
122
Skins
125
Microarray plug-in (alpha version)
126
Microarray plug-in -Import microarray data in tab delimited format -Show data as a table -Filter data by different criteria -Microarray data analysis -Revealing up/down regulated genes -Meta-analyses -Binding with diagram nodes by ID -Coloring diagrams -JavaScript functions -Data manipulation (filter, join, intersect, trim, etc.) -Statistical analysis
127
Microarray plug-in Current work: -Powerful user interface for coloring diagrams -Support of other formats for microarray data and results of analyses -Sophisticated binding algorithm using different database references and ID (gene hub) Further work: -Server module that will provide access to ArrayExpress data
128
BioUML workbench. Data tab contains section “Microarray”. User can import microarray data in tab delimited format into this section.
131
Possibility to filter probe sets: - by column values - selecting only those probe sets that can be linked to the specified diagram
132
Microarray analysis
134
Coloring diagram according to microarray data. Each bar corresponds to one value from corresponding microarray series.
135
Coloring diagram according to omics data
136
Further development: Protein state
137
BioUML workbench: further development Protein states Complexes Improving team work on annotation –Login, single sign on –Editing history (what data were modified, whom and when) –Passing of changes from server to client Sequence analysis and visualization Agent based modeling
138
Protein state
139
Modification The functions of macromolecular entities (mainly proteins) are often determined not only by their primary sequences, but by chemical modifications they have undergone. In BMOND2 unmodified and modified forms of a protein refer to the same entity in UniProt database List of possible modifications is extracted from UniProt Feature Table BMOND2 modifications table –allows to describe modifications that are not described in UniProt. These modifications are automatically added to the protein, referred from BMOND2. Modification type – control vocabulary that describes possible modification types (for example, phosphorylation, acetylation, ubiqutination) To take into account protein modifications State concept is used.
140
UniProt Feature Table FT CHAIN 1 561 Cytosolic purine 5'-nucleotidase. FT /FTId=PRO_0000064389. FT REGION 202 210 Substrate binding (Potential). FT COMPBIAS 549 561 Asp/Glu-rich (acidic). FT ACT_SITE 52 52 Nucleophile. FT ACT_SITE 54 54 Proton donor. FT METAL 52 52 Magnesium. FT METAL 54 54 Magnesium (via carbonyl oxygen). FT METAL 351 351 Magnesium. FT BINDING 127 127 Allosteric activator 1. FT BINDING 154 154 Allosteric activator 2. FT BINDING 354 354 Allosteric activator 2. FT BINDING 436 436 Allosteric activator 1; via carbonyl FT oxygen. FT BINDING 453 453 Allosteric activator 2. FT MOD_RES 527 527 Phosphoserine (By similarity). FT VARIANT 3 3 T -> A (in dbSNP:rs10883841). FT /FTId=VAR_024244. FT VARIANT 136 136 Q -> R (in dbSNP:rs12262171). FT /FTId=VAR_030242.
141
Modification position amynoacid modification type (controlled vocabulary) evidence experimental, by similarity, predicted comment Publication reference
142
State concept State – describes states of all amino acids available for modifications possible values: –? – unknown, not specified –* – any –- – unmodified –p – phoshporylated –ac – acetylated –… – from controlled vocabulary Protein states are described in BMOND2 states table Reaction – user should specify protein state Diagram – user should specify protein state
143
State table module (database) id state – short name (like TRANSPATH) position modification
144
SBGN Mapping: BMOND2 -- SBGN modification – state variable state – state of macromolecule
145
Complex concept
146
A complex is s a biochemical entity composed of other biochemical entities, whether macromolecules, small molecules, multimers, or themselves complexes. Complex is specified as a set of units Complex modifications –all possible modifications of its units (some of them can not occur due to physical interactions between units – how we can take it into account) Complex state –var.1 – list of modifications for its subunits –var. 2 – list of states for its units
147
Complex tables Complex –ID –title (short name) –complete name –species –synonyms –comment References: –States –Synonyms –Structure –DBReferences –Publications Complex Units –complexDB –complexID –unitDB –unitID –multimer
148
SBGN
149
Reaction Reaction components –component identification DB id [state] [compartment] Reaction –[compartment] Reaction dialog –specie state –specie compartment –reaction compartment Tables –Reaction compartment –Reaction components state compartment
150
Diagrams Macromolecule state –“New diagram element” dialog Graphic notation –BioUML states – right label, one modification complexes –SBGN skin
151
Acknowledgements Part of this work was partially supported by following grants: European Committee grant №037590 “Net2Drug” Siberian Branch of Russian Academy of Sciences (interdisciplinary projects № 46) Volkswagen-Stiftung (I/75941), INTAS Nr. 03-51-5218 RFBR Nr. 04-04-49826-а Author is grateful to for useful comments, discussions and technical support Alexander Kel Sergey Zhatchenko Software developers Annotators Nikita Tolstyh Mikhail Puzanov Ruslan Sharipov Sergey Lapukhov Ilya Kiselev Ivan Yevshin Alexander Magdysyuk Denis Ryumin Elena Cheremushkina Vlad Zhvaleev Alexandr Koshukov Ekaterina Kalashnikova Vasiliy Hudyakov Igor Tyazhev Sergey Graschenko Oleg Onegov
Similar presentations
© 2025 SlidePlayer.com. Inc.
All rights reserved.